3 ms·
Who will fight them?
by jacquesm 3y ago
Who will fight them?
- himaraya 3y agoOpenAI's lawyers? Big tech passes everything through legal anyways.
- jacquesm 3y agoExcept for firing execs it seems. Everybody who remains in charge at OpenAI has so many conflicts of interest now that their best bet is to lay very low. Unless they want to be in lawsuits for the next couple of generations. And so far laying low is exactly what they are doing. Has there been any substantial statement from the new CEO yet?
- himaraya 3y agoOpenAI isn't Big Tech? Adam could reasonably argue his interest in Poe doesn't conflict with the nonprofit charter. Sam & Greg saw fit to leave him in place. Uncommunicative boards remain less unusual than you think, unfortunately.
- jacquesm 3y ago> Adam could reasonably argue his interest in Poe doesn't conflict with the nonprofit charter. Good luck with that line of argument, I wouldn't want my reputation and my fortune to hinge on that. > Sam & Greg saw fit to leave him in place. Bad mistake on their part given the guy's history. > Nothing from Emmett yet. I wonder if he'll resign...
- himaraya 3y agoI really don't think investors have the case you think they do. They may ultimately pin the board on some technicality but the case looks far from straightforward. Anyways, it looks like Sam has finally started talking with the board again. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-11-21/altman-openai-board-open-talks-to-negotiate-his-possible-return https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-11-21/altman-op...
- jacquesm 3y agoEverybody involved has more to gain by patching things up and the 'rogue' board members vacating their seats, the sooner they realize that the better. As for whether or not investors have a case: Microsoft may not, but the smaller investors probably do because they can fairly easily prove that their interests were harmed by the ill advised actions of the board.
- himaraya 3y agoThe nonprofit board holds no fiduciary duty to for-profit investors, big or small. In theory, I suppose you could sue the board over undermining the charter but that seems tricky itself, this case aside.
- jacquesm 3y agoYou keep saying that. But only a judge can confirm that that means that they are able to cause harm without consequences. I don't buy that. The charter is not the only thing that governs what a board can and can not do, just like you can't contract out of the law in any other way a non-profit board members does not have automatic and complete immunity from the fall-out of their actions. That would be an interesting device: a full blown corporate armor that exceeds even the degree of insulation an indemnification would offer. It would be the boardroom equivalent of a magic cloak.
- himaraya 3y agoHarming investors in order to uphold the nonprofit charter sounds more reasonable than you suggest. Take it from Matt Levine. I don't think investors would win this line of argument. https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2023-11-21/openai-is-a-strange-nonprofit https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2023-11-21/openai...
- jacquesm 3y agoBut there is no proof whatsoever that they did this to uphold the nonprofit charter. And until that proof surfaces I'm going on the assumption that it doesn't exist because if it does exist they would have certainly used it to bolster their case. Note Ilya's statement of regret and that none of the board members have said a word and that the current CEO is nowhere to be seen. That does not look like a group of people that are acting boldly in the defense of their corporate charter to me. It looks like a bunch of weasels that thought they could get away with murdering the chicken while they were unattended for five minutes and they're now all covered with blood and pretending to be innocent.
- alexdoesstuff 3y agothe people owning the remaining 51% of OpenAI?
- jacquesm 3y agoYou should probably check out who those people are. Hint: they're not the board members that decided to yank the rug out from under the company.
- alexdoesstuff 3y agoThey don't have to be board members to fight. The 51% shareholders are clearly wronged here in my view if MSFT just hires all of OpenAI staff AND takes the existing models and trade secrets.
- jacquesm 3y agoAgain, you should check who those 51% are. If you don't know who they are and what their relationship with Microsoft and the various board members is then you probably won't understand why your comments on this subject don't track. Hint: the 51% are more likely to go after the board than that they are going to go after Microsoft because the board action is what precipitated this whole mess. Microsoft is just - conveniently - picking up the pieces and periodically drops hints about what they'll do if anybody gets in their way of doing that.