4 ms·
> The data does not show Microsoft needs to commit fraud to benefit here. So you are saying that, on “the data”, Microsoft would not be in a materially worse b
by dragonwriter 3y ago
> The data does not show Microsoft needs to commit fraud to benefit here.
So you are saying that, on “the data”, Microsoft would not be in a materially worse business position given the OpenAI chaos if the security of their rights to OpenAI models in the event of a breakdown in their existing relationship was perceived as insecure?
Because otherwise the chain of reasoning is:
The licensing is secure, because Nadella says so, and Nadella can be trusted because if he was lying it would be securities fraud, and Nadella wouldn't commit securities fraud even if it would benefit Microsoft’s and, therefore, his interests.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jacquesm 3y agoMicrosoft is not in a fight for its life, OpenAI definitely is at this point. That alone translates into Microsoft doesn't need to commit fraud, all they need to do is sit back and watch the rest implode and come out winners. They don't even have to sue, all they need to do is do nothing and OpenAI is toast. That press release from MS the other day is a bowshot, not a promise. 'Play ball or else' with the 'or else' bit conveniently left to the imagination of the recipient.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Microsoft is not in a fight for its life, OpenAI definitely is at this point. > That alone translates into Microsoft doesn't need to commit fraud My prior that “the only possible benefit to securities fraud is in circumstances of imminent existential risk” is clearly weaker than yours. Also, if Microsoft's description of the licensing situation is misleading, the existential risk to OpenAI—which makes it more likely that someone else ends up with control of its assets—makes the risk to Microsoft greater, not less.
- jacquesm 3y agoBased on Microsoft's presentations so far and the fact that OpenAI has protested none of them it appears to me that MS indeed has those rights and they undoubtedly have the capability. Change of control is a very standard clause in Escrow arrangements and it may have been subtly worded specifically to ensure that control of the company remained friendly to Microsoft interests given that they did not have a board seat. That's pretty much the only way they should have accepted that construct. If they didn't they were dumb and you can say a lot about Microsoft (I know I have and they're a shit company in my opinion) but they know the legal world like few other tech companies.
- brandall10 3y agoMSFT is up over 50% since investing $10B in OpenAI. That's a couple orders magnitude difference in market cap over the investment alone. Satya does not sound like someone communicating from a position of strength - he's been repeatedly assuring his shareholders that no matter what happens, their AI plans moving forward are secure. They need stability, not chaos, because whatever clear lead it seems they have right now could be quickly be eclipsed in the coming months. Committing securities fraud and accepting a fine would pale in comparison to the potential value erosion.
- jacquesm 3y agoSecurities fraud == jail time. You really don't want to go there as the public face of a listed company.
- brandall10 3y agoSure it can, but this is an extremely unlikely case for jail time.
- jacquesm 3y agoAsk Martha Stewart if she agrees with that statement. Unlikely doesn't mean it doesn't happen and the more high profile a case the more likely the SEC will do something about it. https://www.nbcnews.com/business/markets/10-ceos-who-went-boardroom-cell-block-flna783944 https://www.nbcnews.com/business/markets/10-ceos-who-went-bo...
- brandall10 3y agoMartha Stewart was clearly an unusual situation where they were trying to make an example to hit hard in the public discourse. I don't think the average citizen will care so much. When it comes to white collar crime making some white lies to bolster shareholder confidence is not in the same orbit as the type of massive fraud for notable jail time cases over the last couple decades. At worst it should be a moderate SEC fine, perhaps a shareholder lawsuit if things don't turn out favorable. And this is assuming a lot that has to go wrong.
- lazide 3y agoNadella has a lot to lose, and is in a very high risk situation of doing so, by lying about this. He could have worded it in a far safer way and had the same benefit if he wanted to as well. IMO, odds are low he’s lying about this. It would likely look much different if he was trying to.
- eitally 3y agoYes, and this is a logical jump. Almost certainly -- I would be my own money on it -- any contract Microsoft would have signed would have contingencies around breach and force majeure that would either 1) directly license or assign OpenAI IP to them, or 2) put OpenAI IP in escrow as as a risk hedge against their partner's potential liquidation. In either case, Microsoft covers their investment risk and very likely gets access to OpenAI code (and, of course, as we've seen, the ability to freely offer to hire their talent). To be frank, it's entirely possible that Sam could have been fired for agreeing to a contract like this without board approval because the existential risk OpenAI constantly faces dramatically increases the likelihood that OpenAI investors -- besides Microsoft -- would never be made whole in the case of an implosion. The "Adam D'Angelo spite" hypothesis is possible, too, but it seems far less likely that the board of such a valuable company -- no matter how inexperienced and feckless they might be -- would risk tanking the company on the personal vendetta of a single director.