7 ms·
It's funny that you and a sibling have essentially opposite asks [0]. The other commenter's anecdote is about how even the magic of expressions resolving to val
by lolinder 3y ago
It's funny that you and a sibling have essentially opposite asks [0]. The other commenter's anecdote is about how even the magic of expressions resolving to values goes over some novices' heads— how much more so would a full expression-oriented language!
I'm a fan of functional programming, but I also sympathize with OP's observation that even python might be too far from the CPU to be a good introduction to computing. It probably depends a lot on the child and the teacher—a functional programming language would probably appeal more to older kids (high school) who are comfortable with math.
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38366268 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38366268
- indigochill 3y ago> even python might be too far from the CPU to be a good introduction to computing IMO Python is useful as a didactic tool not so much for teaching kids how computers work as for giving them an emotional experience of "Wow, I can make the computer do things! I'm basically a wizard!" that then might motivate some of them to keep learning about computing. But yeah, there will also be kids who are already well past that stage and ready for meatier stuff. So probably a combination of approaches is best to provide kids with the level of detail they'll find most engaging. Anecdotally, I grew up on Logo, Lego Mindstorms, and HTML, and got my early career started in Python before I really dug in and learned about how hardware makes the magic happen because I realized I was going to be handicapped until I knew that.
- hutzlibu 3y ago"It's funny that you and a sibling have essentially opposite asks" Trying to please everyone is the road to madness, while acomplishing nothing.
- george_____t 3y ago> even python might be too far from the CPU to be a good introduction to computing That depends on what one considers to be the best way to introduce computing. I personally think kids are a lot less likely to be engaged by a bottom-up approach (start with "this is what hardware does") than a top-down approach (start with "you can make cool things with it").