3 ms·
I also don't like how "provoke" is sometimes used as a get-out-of-jail-free card for people with who can't control their reactions or responses. We all have had
by ryandrake 3y ago
I also don't like how "provoke" is sometimes used as a get-out-of-jail-free card for people with who can't control their reactions or responses. We all have had to deal with random assholes, that's life. But we don't deal with it by acting out ourselves. If I get in a bar fight with someone, it's not acceptable, even if the other guy "provoked" me. We should hold ourselves to a higher standard than the assholes, and surely the police should have to hold themselves to an even higher standard.
- jawns 3y agoYou're right. Police and government officials routinely describe First Amendment auditors as attempting to bait law enforcement and public servants, intentionally provoking them into violating their rights. But baiting is when you entice a person to do something wrong by offering them some kind of incentive. And it has to be something they wouldn't otherwise do unless incentivized. Thus, you can't "bait" a law enforcement officer by simply engaging in constitutionally protected conduct, unless the argument from police is that officers just can't restrain themselves from violating people's civil rights when those rights are exercised. In fact, in one of Reyes's encounters with the NYPD that led to an unlawful arrest, one of the officers told him afterward, "You wanted this to happen," and Reyes responded, incredulously, "I wanted you to violate my rights and take away my freedom?" No, he wanted to be able to go about his business without being arrested -- which he was later able to do after this court ruling went into effect.
- tehwebguy 3y agoExactly — if police want most audits to stop they can simply act right. There is little reason for people to watch a video of police not reacting.
- jstarfish 3y agoSounds like the solution is to come down hard on Agent Provocateurs. You're victim blaming big-time. They're on the receiving end of bullshit and cannot opt out of it, but we'll condemn them for fucking up their response? I'm the most cool-headed person I know and I had to talk a neighbor down from kicking my ass on camera (and in front of my own child) just yesterday. It took a superhuman amount of restraint to not even raise my voice because the adrenaline factory was in overdrive on both sides, gearing up for a fight. The provocateur has an unfair advantage-- the element of uncertainty. Only they know they're not they're going to escalate. Defense is a losing game; it only takes one failure to anticipate a threat before you're dead or unconscious. In order to stay so calm, I had to embrace the possibility that I might actually -die- in that encounter if the guy pulled out a knife. I was armed myself, but didn't draw so as not to escalate. It's a position of vulnerability I should never have had to put myself in. Once the adrenaline rush subsided, I had to go take a fucking nap. Cops don't get that option; they're immediately dispatched to deal with the next asshole.
- thomastjeffery 3y agoBullshit. Police can quit anytime. If you can't keep a level head as a police officer, then you are failing to uphold the oath you swore. Full stop. Police have the unfair advantage: power. With power comes responsibility. We must hold those in power accountable for that responsibility. Every person who interacts with a police officer has to deal with the element of uncertainty you are talking about. We give police loaded firearms. We give them handcuffs. We give them dogs. We give them combat training. We all know just how wrong it can go, and just how quickly. We are not allowed to leave! People are getting murdered in the US by police, and those police are often not held to justice. There is an imbalance of both power and responsibility here that lives as a constant looming threat over many of us. It's time to change this story, and that change must begin with police.
- jstarfish 3y ago> Police have the unfair advantage: power. Yes. That is by design. Doormats don't make for a useful police force. > Every person who interacts with a police officer has to deal with the element of uncertainty you are talking about. No, actually. You're familiar with their capabilities and the rules within which they lawfully (and unlawfully) operate. Intelligence is clearly on your side. There is no "uncertainty" when it comes to police; you seem to know exactly what to expect and how to manipulate them into any particular outcome enough to be able to exploit it on camera. That is the antithesis of uncertainty. If there were uncertainty, people would be too afraid to fuck with them like this. It's certain you can safely do this. Cooperation tends to work pretty well for most people. Belligerence escalates the situation. Be the change you want to see.
- thomastjeffery 3y agoTell it to Mike Brown. Tell it to George Floyd. Tell it to Breonna Taylor. Oh, that's right: you can't. The very best of police can't either. Belligerence is escalating the situation of someone recording you. Belligerence is escalating the situation of someone yelling at you. Belligerence is threatening to assault and kidnap any person who doesn't behave precisely as you command. I expect every police officer to be the change they swore an oath to be. No less.