6 ms·
Do Colder or Warmer Places Eat More Spicy or Bland Food?
- 1-6 3y agoYes
- hackermeows 3y agoSpices evolved to grow in warmer climates , go figure
- marginalia_nu 3y agoWell, looking outside peppers, horseradish and mustard grows in pretty cold climates.
- sn41 3y agoWhat a bizarre classification: unusually specific in some instances, and enormously vague in others - Mughlai vs. South Indian. South Indian food contains a lot of variety - from coastal Andhra, to Chettinad style, to Kerala food, Mysore, Udupi cuisine, and Hyderabad-style, all have varied levels of spices, some South Indian cuisine is spicier than Rajasthani cuisine, for sure. But on a more pertinent note - it may be something historical - you need to spice up the food a little to disguise slightly stale food. Historically, a lot of the present spices like black pepper, cardamom and cinnamon also came from places like Kerala, Sri Lanka and Malaysia which were very close to the equator. No wonder it affected the food there.
- manishsharan 3y agoAnother theory could be that a lot of Indians are vegetarian and spices make vegetarian foods more palatable. You could eat most meats with only a dash of salt; however vegetarian dishes need to pair spices with the vegetables to make them appealing.
- JohnFen 3y agoI don't think this holds generally, but it might be true for meat-eaters who eat vegetarian and miss the meaty flavors. At least... > however vegetarian dishes need to pair spices with the vegetables to make them appealing. I know a lot of vegetarians who would very much disagree with this assertion.
- _a_a_a_ 3y agoI wouldn't disagree at all.
- BenjiWiebe 3y agoI'm not a vegetarian, but I prefer my meat spiced and like vegetable with minimal seasoning. I simply enjoy the flavor of vegetables more then meat.
- mariojv 3y agoI wonder how they chose which countries to include in the graph. A lot of my family's Venezuelan and have 0 spice tolerance whatsoever despite growing up near the equator. They also seem to be ranking things per recipe rather than per unit of food eaten by the population, if you read the abstract. Even if there are 9 spicy recipes and 1 bland recipe in a country, if the 1 bland recipe is eaten every day, doesn't that just show that there are more spicy varieties of dishes? Still an interesting article regardless.
- gfaure 3y agoThis article seems to conflate "spice ingredients" with spicy ingredients. I would have a hard time considering how food from cuisines that use (e.g.) aniseed, caraway, cardamom or poppy seed could be considered "spicy food".
- tareqak 3y agoI had this distinction between “spicy” and “spiced” pointed out to me by a former colleague. In my experience, “spicy” is used when there is heat/capsaicin involved and “spice” is used when there is only flavor. I think it is a cause for confusion for many people. What is it like in other languages?
- pvaldes 3y ago> What is it like in other languages? Spiced / Spicy (pungent) Spanish: Especiado / Picante French: Épicé / Piquant Swedish: Kryddad / Pikant
- carlmr 3y agoThat's why, when I need to be clear about it, I say spicy hot (because hot in itself is also rather ambiguous) and uses a lot of spices when describing something that is rather more flavorful. English is just not very good at describing flavor. Looking at British food, there might never have been the necessity. In German there's scharf (spicy) and pikant (slightly spicy). As well as würzig (spiced).
- amluto 3y agoIt also discusses “mean number of spice ingredients per recipe,” which is absurd. For example, lots of moles are not very spicy but have a lot of spice ingredients, including many kinds of chili peppers. Mean annual temperature also seems like the wrong thing to consider. The temperature ranges seem more important.
- yumraj 3y agoThe article seems to ignore the fact that people eat what grows locally. So, India grows a lot of spices, hence the food has those as ingredients. Norway doesn’t, so food is bland. That’s my theory anyway..
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 4death4 3y agoYour theory ignores the fact that chili peppers are a new world vegetable.
- jamincan 3y agoIf you read to the end of the article, it seems the study is looking at spice use more broadly and not so much spicyness (ie. heat) specifically. That would explain why east African food that is influenced by spice trade with India ranks so high on the scale compared to west African food.
- 4death4 3y agoBut the main point being asserted that “people eat what grows locally” is invalidated by the prevalence of chili pepper in various Asian cuisines.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Teever 3y agoWhile the chili peppers originated in the New World the fact remains that they grow better in Asia than in Norway which is what people mean by 'local food's in this context.
- gizajob 3y agoYeah but chilli plants need hot conditions to perform well. You can’t grow them effectively in cold climates.
- eesmith 3y agoTLDR: Don't trust this paper as meaningful, it's meant only as a tentative step towards something which may be meaningful. They put Alabama and New Mexico in the same category? Even when the latter has "red or green [chile]" as the official state question, and has a very different environment due to being in the high desert? And all of South Africa into a single category? The supplementary materials say "For South Africa in the B&S dataset1, the cookbooks from which the recipes were derived are written by Afrikaans-speaking authors8, so we have used the Afrikaans language to represent this cuisine." but that is only one of many cultures in South Africa, including a large Indian population with spicy food. This makes me regard the paper with a wary eye. Ohhh! All of the peer reviews are published! See "Peer Review Information" at https://www.nature.com/articles/s41562-020-01039-8 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41562-020-01039-8 . It took a while to get this paper through, with lots of comments about issues. Reviewer #1, after giving the okay, points out: "I am aware this was a limitation of the sources upon which the study relied, and that similar biases were present in previous work, and this does not undermine the study overall because it is a “tenative step” towards better understanding, but please make this a very clear and strong caveat in the discussion and conclusions. It may also be leading to the rather odd correlation between GDP and spiciness which I refer to above." where that correlation above is: "the rather limited global sampling (see below) may also be playing a role here. For example, off the cuff, adding in say Singapore (which I imagine might have spicy food and be rich) and Nicaragua (which has rather bland food but is poor) could make a difference…I would not suggest the authors try to expand their sample (unless very straightfoward), but please at least discuss this possibility."
- 1970-01-01 3y ago>North USA >South USA This isn't a thing, and reminds me how 'steamed hams' is also a regional food. They're making up stuff and going along with whatever just to get clicks. Original paper: There is little evidence that spicy food in hot countries is an adaptation to reducing infection risk Original paper's conclusion: ...not explained by temperature and that spice use cannot be accounted for by diversity of cultures, plants, crops or naturally occurring spices. Patterns of spice use are not consistent with an infection-mitigation mechanism, but are part of a broader association between spice, health, and poverty.
- karmakaze 3y agoThe explanation that I was working with was that in hotter climates food spoils faster so spiciness can slow or mask the process. The article says: > The researchers suggest other explanations for why people in hot countries tend to eat spicier food. One possibility is that it’s because spices help preserve food in hot climates. Another is that people in hot countries have developed a taste for spicy food because it helps them cool down.
- stephenr 3y agoThis may be part of it. Even now in Thailand "fresh" (I use that term very loosely) meat bought from a supermarket can have wildly different times before it has an odour, and that's without considering the wet markets where everything is out in the open air relying on a block of ice to keep it "fresh".
- pipeline_peak 3y agoCountries that had better preservation methods and safer ways of consuming meat didn't rely on spices. Northern Asia, Europe
- alephnerd 3y agoThis analysis is crap. My family origin is Pahari farmers. In winters, my ancestral town's temperatures fall below freezing, yet Chili Powder from our region is a staple in most North Indian cooking (Kashmiri Mirch grown in JK and Himachal). That Punjab and Mughlai trendline can be attributed to that reason - Kashmiri Mirch is a staple in both styles of cooking now, but if you look at "pind style" cooking, it's way less spicy. A traditional Kadhi, Saag, or Choley isn't going to be spicy but might have 1 Kashmiri Mirch added as a garnish. Peppers only came to our portion of the Himalayas in the 18th and 19th century (hence why Bell Peppers are called "Shimla Mirch" - it was brought by the Brits), but became a popular commodity to sell due to high margins and easy to grow in small plots, which is important in JK and Himachal as land reform laws capped agricultural plots to 3 acres at most. Also treating "South Indian" as a single cuisine group is a travesty.
- desi_ninja 3y agoIgnoring kolhapur region of Maharashtra is another travesty. Not to forget, bhoot jholakia (ghost pepper) from Assam