2 ms·
The real risk always was, and remains, the innate stupidity of people applying machine derived "facts" to decisions of significance in the wider world. AGI is
by ggm 3y ago
The real risk always was, and remains, the innate stupidity of people applying machine derived "facts" to decisions of significance in the wider world.
AGI is a chimera. It doesn't exist and nothing in LLM or ML points to it's emergence (there is of course the hype risk in people believing it does exist "just over the horizon" and investing shit-tonnes of money chasing it)
But, mis-applied machine logic has existed for a long time. Back in the 1980s it was about systemic bias in Medical School entry. More recently it's been "robodebt" in Australia.
TL;DR the risks aren't the ones people shout about as headline grabbers. The risks are the problems of seeking "computer said no" in the answer without critical thought.
Plus economic risk, which is wider than you say. Until we decide to end IPR law, the current crop of 'this is a derived work' is ripping people off. So, there is a huge transfer of value happening as ML derives sellable goods from original makers without recognition.
Deepfakes are moving out of uncanny valley. Into a very nasty subversive place, undermining the integrity in what we see. I can laugh at the pope in a puffer jacket. I am less prone to laugh when the US election is around the corner.
- takinola 3y agoI agree with your main point that these are not new risks. Deepfakes have been available since Photoshop existed. I can create an photo (or even video) of your politician of choice doing something untoward without using AI. What is the additional risk that AI brings to this scenario?
- ggm 3y agoPutting the high Q product into the hands of anyone, and established beliefs. The general trend is "but the computer said so, it must be right" as in google maps misdirection into swamps. How can anyone wind up in that place? Specifically photoshopping, no: thats been around for ages. Movies? Less such. They're pretty terrible without AI assist for smooth blending, and voice faking. Mainly I'd say upscaling from Photoshop to believable movies, and sheer volume of materials are the probable risks. But its incremental not revolutionary. And this is only specifically this one niche, right? Overall in the scale of things, I'd say the risk is misplaced belief overall. Applied to different contexts.