3 ms·
But Twitter did serve those ads adjacent to the offensive content. No one seems to be claiming that Media Matters photoshopped the ads. The question boils down
by kstrauser 3y ago
But Twitter did serve those ads adjacent to the offensive content. No one seems to be claiming that Media Matters photoshopped the ads. The question boils down to how often it happens. Is Apple OK with half their ads being next to racist crap? A quarter? 10%? 1%? 0.1%?
Media Matters demonstrated that it does happen more than 0%. Looks like it's up to Twitter's advertisers to try the experiment for themselves and see if it breaks their own comfort threshold.
- JPKab 3y agoYes, they "demonstrated" it with this tactic described below: - *Media Matters’ Research Tactics*: - Created an alternate account to manipulate public and advertiser perception. - Curated posts and ads on the timeline to misinform about ad placement. - Contrived experiences are not platform-specific and could be replicated elsewhere. - *Ad Serving Instances*: - After curation, they refreshed timelines to find rare instances of ad placement. - Logs showed 13 times more ads served to their account than the median X user. - *Ad Impressions Data*: - On the day in question, of the 5.5 billion ad impressions on X, less than 50 were served against the content in the Media Matters article. - *Specific Brand Exposure*: - One brand had an ad run adjacent to a post twice, seen by only two users, including the article's author. - Another brand had two ads run adjacent to two posts three times, seen only by the article's author. - *Content Policy Evaluation*: - The article highlighted nine posts believed to be inappropriate for X. - Only one of the nine posts violated content policies. - Action was taken on the violating post under the "Freedom of Speech, Not Reach" enforcement approach.
- kstrauser 3y agoIt's unimaginable that any advertisers took their word for it and dropped their Twitter ad budget simply because Media Matters said so. At the most, Media Matters might have called their attention to it (if it wasn't already on the advertisers' radio, which it almost certainly was).
- s1artibartfast 3y ago>It's unimaginable that any advertisers took their word for it It doesn't matter if advertisers actually believe it if enough people do, the impact is the same.
- jasonwatkinspdx 3y agoI mean beyond that the ads don't literally need to appear next to the racist tweets for advertisers to consider the entire platform poisoned by the behavior of Elon. This is one of those nerd snipe "but you didn't say simon says" defenses that no one in the real world actually gives a shit about. Elon has shown his face, advertisers don't want their brands associated with that. It's that simple.
- kstrauser 3y agoI agree with all that. I doubt Apple, IBM, etc. saw the Media Matters report and took it at face value, then redirected their advertising budgets without checking into it on their own. In fact, I'd say it's a given that they had marketing people doing their own reload-and-count exercises. And when they did, they came up with a number that was greater than their comfort level. All platforms will have some awfulness. There's no way around it. If Twitter had a trillion good posts and 1 bad one, no one would bat an eye. It's a rounding error; things happen. But advertisers have at least an informal idea of how much badness is too much, and Twitter crossed. That's the end of the story. Apple and IBM et al ran the numbers and decided that Twitter's content is too tainted for them to want to associate with it. And because free market, they decided not to any more.