3 ms·
Yes, indeed and that's the real loss here: any chance of governing this properly got blown up by incompetence.
by jacquesm 3y ago
Yes, indeed and that's the real loss here: any chance of governing this properly got blown up by incompetence.
- hef19898 3y agoOf we ignore the risks and threats of AI for a second, this whole story is actually incredibly funny. So much childish stupidity on display on all sides is just hilarious. Makes what the world would look like if, say, the Manhattan Project would have been managed the same way. Well, a younger me working at OpenAI would resign latest after my collegues stage a coup againstvthe board out of, in my view, a personality cult. Propably would have resigned after the third CEO was announced. Older me would wait for a new gig to be ligned up to resign, with beginning after CEO number 2 the latest. The cyckes get faster so. It took FTX a little bit longer from hottest start up to enter the trajectory of crash and burn, OpenAI did faster. I just hope this helps ro cool down the ML sold as AI hype a notch.
- jacquesm 3y agoThe scary thing is that these incompetents are supposedly the ones to look out for the interests of humanity. It would be funny if it weren't so tragic. Not that I had any illusions about this being a fig leaf in the first place.
- stingraycharles 3y agoPerhaps they were put in that position precisely because of their incompetence, not despite of it.
- jacquesm 3y agoI wouldn't rule that out. Normally you'd expect a bit more wisdom rather than only smarts on a board. And some of those really shouldn't be there at all (conflicts of interest, lack of experience).
- jibe 3y agoOf we ignore the risks and threats of AI for a second [..] just hope this helps ro cool down the ML sold as AI hype If it is just ML sold as AI hype, are you really worried about the threat of AI?
- hef19898 3y agoIt can be both, a hype and a danger. I don't worry much about AGI by now (I stopped insulting Alexa so, just to be sure). The danger of generative AI is that it disrupts all kinds of things: arts, writers, journalism, propaganda... That threat already exists, the tech being no longer being hyped might allow us to properly adress that problem.
- jacquesm 3y ago> I stopped insulting Alexa so, just to be sure Priceless. The modern version of Pascal's wager.
- anonymouskimmer 3y ago> Makes what the world would look like if, say, the Manhattan Project would have been managed the same way. It was not possible for a war-time government crash project to have been managed the same way. During WW2 the existential fear was an embodied threat currently happening. No one was even thinking about a potential for profits or even any additional products aside from an atomic bomb. And if anyone had ideas on how to pursue that bomb that seemed like a decent idea, they would have been funded to pursue them. And this is not even mentioning the fact that security was tight. I'm sure there were scientists who disagreed with how the Manhattan project was being managed. I'm also sure they kept working on it despite those disagreements.
- Apocryphon 3y agoThat's what happened to the German program though https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_nuclear_weapons_program https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_nuclear_weapons_program
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoWell, yes, but they were the existential threat. Hey, maybe this means the AGIs will fight amongst themselves and thus give us the time to outwit them. :D
- jowea 3y agoActual scifi plot.
- hooande 3y agoFor real. It's like, did you see Oppenheimer? There's a reason they put the military in charge of that.
- postmodest 3y agoIgnoring "Don't be Ted Faro" to pursue a profit motive is indeed a form of incompetence.
- zer00eyz 3y ago> any chance of governing this properly got blown up by incompetence No one knows why the board did this. No one is talking about that part. Yet every one is on twitter talking shit about the situation. I have worked with a lot of PhD's and some of them can be, "disconnected" from anything that isn't their research. This looks a lot like that, disconnected from what average people would do, almost childlike (not ish, like). Maybe this isn't the group of people who should be responsible for "alignment".
- kmlevitt 3y agoThe Fact still nobody knows why they did it is part of the problem now though. They have already clarified it was not for any financial reason, security reason, or privacy/safety reason, so that rules out all the important ones that spring to anyone’s minds. And they refuse to elaborate why in writing despite being asked to repeatedly. Any reason good enough to fire him is good enough to share with the interim CEO and the rest of the company, if not the entire world. If they can’t even do that much, you can’t blame employees for losing faith in their leadership. They couldn’t even tell SAM ALTMAN why, and he was the one getting fired!
- denton-scratch 3y ago> The Fact still nobody knows why they did it is part of the problem now though. The fact that Altman and Brockman were hired so quickly by Microsoft gives a clue: it takes time to hire someone. For one thing, they need time to decide. These guys were hired by Microsoft between close-of-business on Friday and start-of-business on Monday. My supposition is that this hiring was in the pipeline a few weeks ago. The board of OpenAI found out on Thursday, and went ballistic, understandably (lack of candidness). My guess is there's more shenanigans to uncover - I suspect that Altman gave Microsoft an offer they couldn't refuse, and that OpenAI was already screwed by Thursday. So realizing that OpenAI was done for, they figured "we might as well blow it all up".
- mediaman 3y agoThe problem with this analysis is the premise: that it "takes time to hire someone." This is not an interview process for hiring a junior dev at FAANG. If you're Sam & Greg, and Satya gives you an offer to run your own operation with essentially unlimited funding and the ability to bring over your team, then you can decide immediately. There is no real lower bound of how fast it could happen. Why would they have been able to decide so quickly? Probably because they prioritize the ability to bring over the entire team as fast as possible, and even though they could raise a lot of money in a new company, that still takes time, and they view it as critically important to hire over the new team as fast as possible (within days) that they accept whatever downsides there may be to being a subsidiary of Microsoft. This is what happens when principles see opportunity and are unencumbered by bureaucratic checks. They can move very fast.
- slavik81 3y ago> that's the real loss here: any chance of governing this properly got blown up by incompetence If this incident is representative, I'm not sure there was ever a possibility of good governance.
- bart_spoon 3y agoWas it due to incompetence though? The way it has played out has made me feel it was always doomed. It is apparent that those concerned with AI safety were gravely concerned with the direction the company was taking, and were losing power rapidly. This move by the board may have simply done in one weekend what was going to happen anyways over the coming months/years anyways.