3 ms·
> For a country which produces a large number of really outstanding economists (including great macroeconomists!) Argentina is surprising disaster. I'd assume
by ethbr1 3y ago
> For a country which produces a large number of really outstanding economists (including great macroeconomists!) Argentina is surprising disaster.
I'd assume that it's a disaster is why it produces a lot of outstanding economists.
- dyeje 3y agoFunny, I assumed it’s a disaster because all of the great economists.
- ploum 3y agoI would argue that producing influential economists is what lead to disaster. ;-) (remember that an economist is someone that, if you ask him to study horses, sit down and think really hard "what would I do if I was a horse?")
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Arnt 3y agoPlease go on, do argue that. Don't just tell us that you would. I'm quite curious to what your actual arguments would be.
- stanford_labrat 3y agoWell clearly, the first thing to do is think very very hard about "what would I do if I were a world-renowned economist".
- Arnt 3y ago"Not have been born in Argentina?" perhaps? Or "Have been born in Argentina"?
- ploum 3y agoWell, a good example is given by Yanis Varoufakis (which is, ironically, an economist himself) in his book "adults in the room". In this book, Varoufakis, which was Greece Finance Ministry at the time, explains how he was tasked to negotiate with EU institutions and IMF to alleviate Greece debts. While he proposes restructuring plans after restructuring plans, nobody even try to argue with him on the plans. They all say that there should be a strong austerity, it is the way to go. At one point, he managed to get a glimpse of what is presented to him as a very complex economical model that he (phd in economy) could not understand and, by looking into the code, discover that it is utterly stupid: the whole agenda of austerity is based on the fallacy that you could raise taxes without affecting consumption. You could say that my example is only saying that there are good and bad economists and that things go wrong when politicians listen to bad economists. Well, it turns out that politicians only listen to bad economists (because that’s what they want to hear) which make any influential economist a bad one (because you can’t really make a career as a good one who say things like "give more money to the poor" or "tax the rich"). Varoufakis is an exception here but not so much: he was quickly removed from office once people understood that he would not agree to become a bad economists to stay in power.
- AniseAbyss 3y ago[dead]
- rstuart4133 3y agoI took a couple of courses in economics at Uni, because you are forced to do a few electives. The micro economics looked similar to physics applied to money to me, meaning it was mathematical models applied to very simple situations. It was interesting but the world is not simple. They term their attempts to expand it to real world models macro economics. That worked about as well as using physics to predict the weather which is to say not bad, but you wouldn't bet your life on the predictions. The math and logic was pleasingly rigorous, but the models were either too simple or beyond the most powerful computer. That was Uni. Then I started read pieces by "economists" in the popular press. They written "pop science" style, where the science being discussed is economics. But where pop science is often a genuine attempt to educate, these articles by "economists" were invariably little better than opinion pieces. To this engineer they often read like near pure bullshit. Worse, after a while, it because obvious it was paid by the word bullshit. As in, if you look at the job description for "Chief Economist" at a bank it reads like a PR position, not someone paid to predict economic outcomes. I do feel sorry for the academic discipline. The tarnish painted by the brushes held by the colleagues paid by politicians and PR services reeks, which in turn means they go through life wearing the snide comments you see about their efforts here. Balancing that is things like the current interest rate. If I believe what I read, the worlds reserve banks kept interest rates low because the worlds top economists told them the COVID cash bazooka would not lead to inflation. WTF? I have no idea if this was just another case of economists saying what they were paid to say, or it really was the underlying academic consensus. But the independent reserve banks acted on that advice, and if they can't pick the paid bullshitters from the those doing true research then I've got no hope.
- FabHK 3y agoMacro economists say that there are 4 kinds of economies: developed economy, developing economy, Japan, Argentina.
- sidmitra 3y agoNot sure where that quote originates from, but it's also seen here. The Argentina Paradox: microexplanations and macropuzzles by Taylor et al https://latinaer.springeropen.com/articles/10.1007/s40503-017-0051-8 https://latinaer.springeropen.com/articles/10.1007/s40503-01...
- saiya-jin 3y agoHaven't heard a lot about Zimbabwe economists though