6 ms·
Richest 1% account for more carbon emissions than poorest 66%, report says
- simmerup 3y ago[flagged]
- sherry-sherry 3y ago>They must be happy they managed to get a ‘white man bad’ comment in there. What a strange way to phrase ‘reported a fact’.
- simmerup 3y agoPrefacing the fact by calling it ‘a growing problem’ isn’t just reporting a fact.
- throwaway290 3y agoAh, the mental gymnastics of the privileged to convince the rest that inequality is not a problem
- pipes 3y agoI thought climate change was about the environment. Now it's a social justice tool.
- sherry-sherry 3y agoCould you explain to us what a 'social justice tool' is?
- pipes 3y agoI think it's pretty self explanatory but ok: in this case pushing a political agenda via an environmental concern. The problem with this is a lot of people don't agree with this political agenda but do understand the real problem of climate change. It would probably serve the environmental cause to not mix the two together.
- throwaway290 3y agoNow this group of people who are all about environment but also think that inequality is fine (presumably because they are on top of it) will hopefully realize that these issues turn out to be connected in interesting ways ;)
- sherry-sherry 3y agoOk, I couldn't find any time it's been used to mean that. What political agenda do you think is being pushed here?
- throwaway290 3y agoYou forgot the part where the privileged are found to be polluting the most, aka TFA.
- sherry-sherry 3y agoIt didn't say that, it said: "A less discussed but faster-growing problem is inequality within countries.". The reports linked in the article show the growing inequality, please feel free to present your sources showing otherwise.
- joegibbs 3y agoThey could report any number of facts if they wanted. They could spend all day writing about what their dog had for lunch today and it would be purely factual. They only include specific facts for a reason. They could probably do an analysis and find that e.g. gay people cause a disproportionate amount of carbon emissions (which they do, since they're far more likely to live in higher-income economies) but never would since that's homophobic.
- mrmanner 3y ago_Openly_ gay people, possibly. Within an economy you could make the opposite point - openly gay people are underrepresented in the economic and political elites.
- PM_me_your_math 3y ago[dead]
- Pigalowda 3y agoThe Chinese list has more Chinese billionaires than the American list has of American billionaires. I guess it depends on which facts are truthier. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_number_of_billionaires https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_number_...
- _s_a_m_ 3y agoIt is always surprising to know for the minority how poor people actually are ..
- Arnt 3y agoIMO it's because the stock photo of "the 1%" is a superyacht or a private jet, which makes people like HNers think that they themselves are far below the threshold. A private jet in the case of this article. I bet that's not how HNers would illustrate us as a group. Quite a nasty rhetorical trick, really.
- FooBarBizBazz 3y agoIt depends on whether you're talking about the top 1% of the US, or the top 1% of the world. The latter is a much lower bar.
- SenAnder 3y ago> They must be happy they managed to get a ‘white man bad’ comment in there. They also dedicated a whole article to complaining that it's whites doing the most for environmental movements. Their conclusion is always the same, no matter the facts. Why are so many white men trying to save the planet without the rest of us? Climate change affects minorities and women, the elderly and the poor. But the leadership of the environmental movement is pale and male. That doesn't look like progress - https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/may/08/white-men-environmental-movement-leadership https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/may/08/white-...
- throwaway290 3y agoYeah it's totally fine that a group of people that took upon itself to get everyone else to not take airplanes to not eat meat to buy less to recycle more etc. also turns out to be polluting the most...
- simmerup 3y agoThe fact that you’re willing to stigmatise the people trying to make a difference just because theyre white and male is exactly why racist rhetoric is bad
- throwaway290 3y agoWhen you point out that some minority is committing most of the crimes it doesn't make you racist if it helps you solve the problem of crime. If you point out those at the top of increasingly inequal world are of one race and gender it's not racist or sexist if it helps you solve the problem of inequality. Labeling things that are inconvenient for you as "racist" is lazy.
- SenAnder 3y agoMuch of environmentalism is aimed at developed, mostly white countries. You frame it as whites lecturing others, but much of it is whites lecturing other whites. Any tortured logic will do, so long as it finds the right culprit.
- tonyedgecombe 3y agoGood luck convincing the proletariate to lower their emissions when they can see the great and good living it large.
- cronin101 3y agoI’m all in favour of lowering emissions for the 1% but it’s a strange place to draw the line when their calculations suggest ~70% of emissions come from “the Everyman” that is 1st-33rd percentile. Cheap and plentiful access to lower carbon technology will be 4x the impact of focusing on the top percentile alone, even if it doesn’t fit the narrative. Personally, I believe that those with the capability to do so are obliged to make ecological purchasing decisions (I hold myself to this standard) so I’m not trying to pass the buck either.
- PM_me_your_math 3y ago[dead]
- throwaway22032 3y agoThe richest species probably accounts for more carbon emissions than every other species combined too.
- RecycledEle 3y agoBanning all civilian air travel until the airplane meet the efficiency standards the trucks junked in Junker Clunker already met would be a start.
- gruez 3y ago1. So no ban? SF to NY is about 2900 miles. Wikipedia says "Generally, trade-in vehicles must get a weighted combined average rating of 18 or fewer miles per gallon" to qualify for the Car Allowance Rebate System. The EPA says there's about 8.9kg of co2 per gallon of gas, which means driving such a distance would emit approximately 1434kg of carbon. On the other hand Google flights says the same trip by direct flight only emits around 400kg, depending on the airline. 2. I'm not really sure why a ban is needed when mandated sequestration will have the same effect, and won't kill half the travel industry.
- RecycledEle 3y agoI should have said: until commerical aircraft meet ALL fuel economy and emissions standards that old trucks have had to meet in their lifetimes. If your jet engine does not have a catalytic converter, it must not fly. What's good for old trucks is good for aircraft. If for airplane burns leaded fuel, it must not fly. If your airplane does not meet CAFE standards, it must not fly without paying fines. Here are a few of the standards: https://www.epa.gov/emission-standards-reference-guide/epa-emission-standards-light-duty-vehicles-and-trucks-and https://www.epa.gov/emission-standards-reference-guide/epa-e...
- RecycledEle 3y ago> The EPA says there's about 8.9kg of co2 per gallon of gas, which means driving such a distance would emit approximately 1434kg of carbon. On the other hand Google flights says the same trip by direct flight only emits around 400kg, depending on the airline. There is no law concerning the emission of CO2 from old trucks. Look into the laws governing emissions and fuel economy on old trucks. What's good dirty for old trucks is good for shiny new aircraft. > I'm not really sure why a ban is needed when mandated sequestration will have the same effect, and won't kill half the travel industry. Say you're in the 1% without saying your in the 1% by claiming aviation is "half the travel industry."
- alx_the_new_guy 3y agoPersonally, I call BS. The report itself is fine, but the article is misleading, sort of implying that it's those billionaire's lifestyles that are ruining the climate for everyone else. But only in the end, it outlines, _how_ they do it, arguably with less attention than it deserves. Having read the report, the overwhelming proportion of CO2 is generated with so-called "Polluting shares", basically, stock in polluting companies. Guess what, that means we need to adress those companies' CO2 output, not private jets and yachts. That makes solving said problem a whole lot more complicated than eating the rich, though.
- pauldenton 3y agoThose are out of sight out of mind companies As long as those rare earth mines are in Africa and they are assembled in China it doesn't count as environmental damage. It's only if those mines or factories are in our country do we need to shut them down for the sake of the Earth
- KyleBerezin 3y agoAfrica produces 0.32% or the annual supply of rare earth metals, and nearly all of it comes from Madagascar, and it is a Chinese owned mine.
- polski-g 3y agoThey should look at net pollutants produced. If someone "emits" X pollutants per year, but they cure the pollutant ebola, the two numbers should be subtracted to get the individual's net contribution to the planet.
- lapinot 3y agoIndeed, just like committing homicide and having a baby cancels out.
- superduty 3y agoLast week over the span of 2 days at least 106 private jets carrying 2-12 people each flew in to Las Vegas - rich folk heading in to watch F1. I’d like to see Democrats ask their wealthy donors to give that up.
- monkeydreams 3y ago> I’d like to see Democrats ask their wealthy donors to give that up. What about Republican's wealthy donors, or Green's wealthy donors? Or are you suggesting this is just a problem with the others?
- kderbyma 3y ago.... obviously.....
- KyleBerezin 3y ago"The corporate shares of many super-rich are highly polluting." this article is deceptive. What is the suggested solution here, those companies shouldn't exist? If the companies were owned by the average person would that somehow make them pollute less? This article opens with a picture of a private jet like that is the cause of this pollution, that their extravagance is polluting the planet. "‘Polluter elite’ are plundering the planet to point of destruction" I guess I should have realized this article had problems from that first line.
- KyleBerezin 3y ago"Despite being massive, the personal consumption of the super-rich is dwarfed by emissions resulting from their investments in companies.17 Investments of the top 1% are estimated to account for between 50% and 70% of their emissions.18" Their source is equally bad, and I have no faith even in that number. I see double counting too, if you blame pollution for buying a car on the customer, and blame that same pollution on the person who owns the shares of the company that made it, you are double counting.