3 ms·
Obviously and that is true literally every time someone uses that sentence. And speaking about obfuscation: > But here, whether the “side effects” are “detrime
by watwut 3y ago
Obviously and that is true literally every time someone uses that sentence. And speaking about obfuscation:
> But here, whether the “side effects” are “detrimental” depends on how much you value individual freedom, which is part of the debate.
And how much you value human rights. And how much you value people not being tortured for this. The way muslim countries do it rely on systematic excessive cruelty and control in many private aspects of life.
Since we are at "we need to spell it out" maybe we should not hide behind soft euphemism like "valuing individual freedom" which suggest something much softer.
- rayiner 3y ago> And how much you value human rights. There is no such thing as “human rights.” If you autopsy someone you won’t find any human rights in there. It’s just a party trick that allows Europeans to insist that their cultural emphasis on individualism is superior to other cultural values. > And how much you value people not being tortured for this. The way muslim countries do it rely on systematic excessive cruelty For the most part, it’s aunties chiding you, which is only figurative rather than literal torture.
- watwut 3y agoThen there is not such thing as "other cultural values" either. There is no such thing as morals or ethics. No abstract concept ever exist. And speaking of these, muslim countries are much more picky, demanding much more and mistreating people (especially women) in much higher numbers. > For the most part, it’s aunties chiding you, which is only figurative rather than literal torture. Sure, there is a lot of that too. And then, there is the rest of it, like, actual literal torture.
- rayiner 3y ago“Human rights” don’t exist not because it’s abstract, but because it’s self-contradictory. “Cultural values” and “rights” can exist with respect to a particular society, or by reference to a particular legal code. But “human rights” implies rights that are universal to humans, and there is no such thing. “Human rights” is a religious concept that makes sense if you have a God that provides the source of universal values. But presumably we are having a secular discussion here, not a theological one.
- watwut 3y agoThat is some nice sophistry, but that is all there is to it. Human rights and cultural values exist or not in the exact same level. If anything what you call "cultural values" are almost purely religious ones as they exist within the context of one faith and the reason for them is religion. > “Human rights” is a religious concept that makes sense if you have a God that provides the source of universal values. This is not true. Atheists frequently like and agree with this concept. The rights that we apply to all humans. I dont need god to believe in morals.
- alphabettsy 3y ago“For the most part” is doing some extraordinarily heavy lifting.