5 ms·
You could say that just about any software development platform. If it makes building software easier, it makes competition easier. And if building apps is easi
by pron 15y ago
You could say that just about any software development platform. If it makes building software easier, it makes competition easier. And if building apps is easier, it really doesn't matter what stack your app uses - it's going to get easier to "clone", so you may as well use whatever platform gives you the best results.
Other than that, you could either make your business, rather than your technology, more competitive, or make your technology ever more sophisticated than what "commodity" development tools allow.
- nick_urban 15y agoIt's not that client-side applications are easier to reverse-engineer. If the application is all client-side, it can literally just be downloaded and reused by a would-be competitor.
- aidenn0 15y agowhich violates your copyright. Microsoft Word is entirely client-side so it too can literally just be downloaded and reused by a would-be competitor.
- pilom 15y agoDownloading Microsoft Word does not include all the source code in addition to the application.
- aidenn0 15y agoNeither does obfuscated and minified javascript.
- tnorthcutt 15y agoYes, it does. Where do you think the source code is?
- sjs 15y agoIt may not be at the same level as disassembling binary code w/ IDA or what have you, but un-minifying or un-obfuscating JavaScript is not a trivial exercise by any means. (If I were in a nitpicking mood I would also point out that the source is what is fed into the minifier or obfuscator, not what comes out.)
- rralian 15y agoun-minifying javascript is very trivial. you just copy and paste it into an online javascript beautifier. you won't get the original un-obfuscated source with original comments, but you'll get readable javasript that you can easily parse visually.
- chrisohara 15y agoas I said above, de-obfuscating a large javascript app that's been obfuscated/minified by proprietary tools is virtually impossible to decode. Try running some of google's code - gmail, docs, take your pick - through your beautifier ;)
- rralian 15y agoI don't know if anybody uses proprietary tools to minify and obfuscate their javascript. We all use the same minification tools, with different features selected. Seems like most people use YUI compressor, or one of the others listed here http://compressorrater.thruhere.net/ http://compressorrater.thruhere.net/. I assume Google is using their closure tools (which I've never played with myself). It's a lot easier to reverse-engineer the site than to build it from scratch yourself. You won't get all the comments, and some of the names of functions and variables and whatnot may lose their semantic meaning in favor of shorter names. But yes, it is trivial to unminify the source and work through it. If it's 10k+ lines of code, that's never trivial to understand and get it all in your head, but the concern is absolutely valid. If you think minifying/obfuscating is securing your code intellectual property, you're fooling yourself. It's like security through obscurity... it's not really offering you any protection.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- chrisohara 15y agohave you ever looked at code obfuscated by proprietary tools? By your logic it's easy to reverse-engineer and copy Gmail - good luck with that
- endtime 15y agoAre you saying you don't think Gmail has a backend...?
- chrisohara 15y agoOf course it has a backend, but so do the Firebase apps that this entire thread is talking about. Referring to a JS app as "client-side" doesn't imply that there's no backend logic. My point is that you can't just de-obfuscate a primarily client-side JS app and replace the Firebase (or whatever) endpoints. Proprietary obfuscation is more than just variable name munging and minification..
- endtime 15y agoThe Gmail backend isn't available in the same way as the Firebase backend.