5 ms·
The existing statements seem like slander no? Not issuing the statement would be putting a lot of potential liability on them.
by lazide 3y ago
The existing statements seem like slander no?
Not issuing the statement would be putting a lot of potential liability on them.
- Zak 3y agoThe existing statements would be libel if false. It's a little surprising they put something like that in a press release at all; it would be shockingly inept if they did so without the sort of documentation that would make a lawsuit futile. Of course, tho whole situation is a little shocking so maybe all bets are off.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y ago> The existing statements would be libel if false. Libel isn't really an issue here, because the statement from the board hardly made any factual assertions in the first place: > Mr. Altman’s departure follows a deliberative review process by the board, which concluded that he was not consistently candid in his communications with the board, hindering its ability to exercise its responsibilities. The board no longer has confidence in his ability to continue leading OpenAI. There are a ton of possible interpretations of "he was not consistently candid". However, there are lots of things that people can sue for besides outright libel/slander. I made the argument elsewhere that the legal nitpicking here isn't really that significant, because it's pretty easy to argue that the tenor of the board announcement would at least make it sound to a reasonable observer that Altman did something egregious.
- nostrademons 3y agoTechnically the only sentence in the statement that might be false is "Mr. Altman’s departure follows a deliberative review process by the board, which concluded that he was not consistently candid in his communications with the board, hindering its ability to exercise its responsibilities." And presumably this is why they used the "not consistently candid" weasel-wording. For that to be true, they only need to point to one material action that he didn't inform the board about (perhaps his chip startup, or Developer Day, or API access), and then point to the board meeting minutes, and then say "See, it's true. You did not inform us, the board, about these other actions you have taken, they matter to OpenAI's adherence to its mission, and therefore your inaction hindered our ability to exercise our responsibilities." Everything else in the statement appears to be completely factual. It's a bad statement because it unnecessarily burns bridges and implies potential wrongdoing (because every other executive departure statement is so tame), but it didn't, strictly speaking, say anything untrue. https://openai.com/blog/openai-announces-leadership-transition https://openai.com/blog/openai-announces-leadership-transiti...
- Sebb767 3y agoOn the other hand, these words are widely understood to mean "he lied" and judges (or juries) aren't stupid. Going for this kind of strong wording and then trying to weasel out by a minor technicality seems like a risky strategy, especially against someone having sufficient money to fight this until the bitter end.
- 15457345234 3y agoAin't a risky strategy if it's a true statement.
- layer8 3y agoI hope we live in a world where judges don’t consider this to be "strong wording".
- Sebb767 3y agoI hope we do. If these words would be on your recommendation letter or said by one of your job references, basically any HR person would understand it as "this employee was caught severely lying" and see it as a big warning not to hire you under any circumstances. I agree that in a casual context, this would be mild, but we're talking about professional press releases and judges acting oblivious to this context is not a good thing in my book.
- 15457345234 3y agoThe strength of the wording is irrelevant if the statement is accurate.
- mcpackieh 3y agoCommon people generally don't get the "spend more time with family" treatment when they get fired. Therefore rich people shouldn't be entitled to it.
- 3y ago
- akerl_ 3y agoThere would need to be a probably false statement of face. The press release doesn’t seem to contain any of those.
- mcpackieh 3y agoThe board said "he was not consistently candid in his communications with the board". That could mean little more than he once neglected to inform the board of something the board felt was important, which is almost certainly true. It's almost certainly true for any CEO; if you take it literally and don't read between the lines it's a very mellow accusation. On HN and twitter people read that line and interpreted it to mean "he's a liar" or even "he raped his sister", but the board didn't actually say those things. He could try suing the board but I think he'd lose.
- paulddraper 3y agoOn HN and Twitter and everywhere else
- mcpackieh 3y ago[flagged]
- junofan 3y agoOkay but taking corporate comms absolutely literally is kinda irrelevant in the context of… corporate comms.
- mcpackieh 3y ago[flagged]
- 15457345234 3y ago> The existing statements seem like slander no? I haven't read them, but if they're accurate then they're not slanderous. I know that if I was slandered I'd be quietly fuming and instructing lawyers, not posturing on twitter and taking pictures of myself 'back in the office' but then again I'm not a tech sector CEO and they seem to be made of different stuff. What do they say? If the facts support you, pound the facts. If the law supports you, pound the law. If neither support you, pound the table.
- ethbr1 3y agoModern growth tech is 80% perception, 20% reality. Because with the capital that good perception affords, you can build a different reality. Ergo, Altman seems to be spending more effort on managing perception than reality.
- 15457345234 3y agoYeah but people who engage in that type of behaviour usually aren't building a different reality, they're just bullshit artists.
- ethbr1 3y agoThat's my point: bullshit artists who raise more capital (and spend it wisely) will outdeliver earnest engineers who don't. Because with capital, you can hire (mercenary) engineers.
- mcpackieh 3y ago"Building different realities" only works to the extent that you surround yourself with sycophants. As soon as the people near you no longer care to play make believe, your alternate reality will *poof* away. Revealed to be nothing but smoke and mirrors.
- lazide 3y agoBut then this thread isn’t about Elon Musk.
- Sebb767 3y ago> Not issuing the statement would be putting a lot of potential liability on them. They need to proove that Sam wasn't candid once Sam dragged them into an actual court room. Shutting up might not be the winning move in the court of public opinion, but legally, it's probably not a bad move.
- function_seven 3y agoThe board issuing an apology could easily be the settlement that ensures this stays out of court. "If you retract your statement, I won't sue." "Ok, we retract it." Just like that.
- mcpackieh 3y agoThey could, but they don't have to.
- layer8 3y agoI'd assume they would be able to prove that he wasn't consistently candid. Then it's not slander.