2 ms·
The fallacy of the EA movement is that they persuaded themselves that it is possible to reason towards the most “effective” altruistic course action in a fully
by layer8 3y ago
The fallacy of the EA movement is that they persuaded themselves that it is possible to reason towards the most “effective” altruistic course action in a fully rational way. The reality is that there are serious philosophical-logical paradoxes, like the repugnant conclusion [0]. As a result, they reasoned themselves into conclusions that were most favorable to their own preferred way of life.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mere_addition_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mere_addition_paradox
- jschveibinz 3y agoInteresting point. I would argue that every collective movement has philosophical-logical paradoxes. Religious organizations are some that immediately come to mind. Political action and legislation is another example. Likewise, any attempt to "social engineer" for the benefit of some will in some way result in a loss for others. I can't argue any for any law of conservation of "benefit" here. I'm just suggesting that there are always pros and cons. And thanks for the link!