6 ms·
> In the 1950s, at the height of McCarthyism, 13.4 percent of Americans reported that “felt less free to speak their mind than they used to.” In 1987, the figur
by Animats 3y ago
> In the 1950s, at the height of McCarthyism, 13.4 percent of Americans reported that “felt less free to speak their mind than they used to.” In 1987, the figure had reached 20 percent. By 2019, 40 percent of Americans reported that they did not feel free to speak their minds. This isn’t a partisan issue, either. Gibson and Sutherland report that, “The percentage of Democrats who are worried about speaking their mind is just about identical to the percentage of Republicans who self-censor: 39 and 40 percent, respectively.”
That's a scary number. And it's probably not wrong.
- pavel_lishin 3y agoI certainly keep my mouth shut about certain things, lest the people whose beliefs I find vile and unconscionable (and who view mine the same way) ostracize me, or worse, my child in the community. Far better to gently feel people out before revealing my beliefs entirely.
- rayiner 3y agoAnd you gotta socialize your kids to keep their mouths shut too. My daughter attends a progressive school, and she’s intuited that there’s a de-facto racial hierarchy that she’s none too happy about. (She was recently invited to attend a school-sponsored weekly lunch for black girls, but once a month because she’s half white and half south Asian and I guess that’s how the math works out.) I pointed out that she needs to keep her mouth shut about it if she doesn’t want to get cancelled. Funny thing is, she already kinda knew that. Even at 11 she had an inkling about the possible social consequences of complaining about that.
- sgu999 3y agoWhat a strange society you live in... I don't see how any kind of racial segregation can help the next generation do better than the previous one. Having to explain to your kid that they can't do X because of their phenotype feels simply wrong.
- pen2l 3y ago[flagged]
- forgingahead 3y agoHis daughter is getting discriminated against, and you have word salad justification for that?
- rayiner 3y agoIt was easy for me to have theoretical ideas about culture when I wasn’t trying to raise three mixed kids in that culture.
- selimthegrim 3y agoI grew up mixed just fine, we just didn’t have TikTok and smartphones.
- zlg_codes 3y ago[flagged]
- wheresthebeef 3y ago[flagged]
- selimthegrim 3y agoYou realize in the UK no one would bat an eye at that (see Southall _Black_ Sisters)
- rayiner 3y agoI don’t see the relation between racially segregated activities in a US school, and a UK non-profit that helps minorities and migrants facing domestic violence. (One that, looking at the Wikipedia page, seems kinda racist insofar as it focuses on domestic violence among Asians specifically, as if there isn’t plenty of domestic violence among white Britons.) And I disagree that people in the UK wouldn’t take exception to segregating students by race and declaring half south asian people to be 1/4 of a black person for purposes of such activities: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/10/23/right-is-winning-everywhere-except-britain/ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/10/23/right-is-winning...
- tptacek 3y agoI live in an ultra-progressive big blue city suburb, spend a fair amount of time in local politics (which revolve around our schools, and particularly equity) and I don't know anyone who wouldn't say that was deeply fucked up. You worry about cancellation, but you could probably get news coverage for that decision. It is deeply not normal.
- fasthands9 3y agoI'm not sure the solution. The problem seems to be a less homogenous society with less homogeneous viewpoints, rather than society getting actually less accepting of speech. It's pretty easy to speak your mind (both then and now) when your opinion is in the majority.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lapcat 3y agoI'm not sure that it's scary. After all, casual racism and sexism used to be a lot more common in the past. Now people are called out and criticized on those. Is that bad? The other factor is the rise of internet social media, which didn't exist back then. When people spoke their mind, it wasn't broadcast publicly to the whole world, so there was less fear of backlash.
- patrick451 3y agoYes. Just like sexuality, racisism and sexism are part of what it means to be human. They are all natural instincts. Suppressing them is leading to the same sort of dysfunction that sexual suppression lead to in the Victorian age. That said, in the same way it's not healthy for society to be full of sexual deviants, it's also not healthy for it to be full of flaming racists. Moderation in all things, but nothing wrong with a little here and there.
- lapcat 3y ago> Moderation in all things, but nothing wrong with a little here and there. Would you say the same about rape, violence, and murder? Those seem like "natural instincts". Nothing wrong with a little here and there? I would dispute that racism and sexism are "just like" sexuality, and I would also dispute that all "natural instincts", you might call them animal instincts, ought to be accepted and encouraged. One of the great accomplishments of humanity is to rise above our animal instincts and become, at least temporarily, rational and enlightened. Sex is necessary for the propagation of the species, and when done right, it's consensual to all parties and also pleasurable, harming nobody. Can you say the same about racism and sexism?
- intalentive 3y agoNot sure how you define sexism, but more traditional patriarchal groups have higher birth rates and more social cohesion. In the long run those traits propagate themselves. The stereotypical cat lady, not so much. As far as racism, it may not propagate the species but surely it helps propagate those genetically closer to oneself. Isn’t in-group preference pretty common? Don’t need to be EO Wilson or Richard Dawkins to see why.
- xyzelement 3y ago[flagged]
- astockwell 3y ago[flagged]
- yoniyoniyoni 3y agoI wouldn't even consider these 'extreme left' or 'far left' people to really be on the left, they're like a whole other ideology separate from that. For instance, someone whose advocacy is fixated mostly around demolishing women's spaces for the pleasure of men, or is obsessed with manifesting racial divides everywhere they look, has really missed the point. They're not even attempting to achieve a society based on egalitarian ideals, all they want to do is set up and maintain new identarian hierarchies.
- jLaForest 3y agoI don't find that number scary or surprising... I'm less likely to overhear racial slurs being thrown around in casual conversation now compared to the past, some selfcensorship is good Not everyone thinks political correctness is bad
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]