7 ms·
The Cassette-Tape Revolution
- dist-epoch 3y agoRose colored glasses history and all that, but goddam, were cassettes awful, even when brand new.
- criddell 3y agoLate 70’s and early 80’s vinyl was pretty awful too.
- pupppet 3y agoJust going to crank up my favourite song… HSSSSSSSS
- resolutebat 3y agoIt's the second one, so FFWD FFWD, nope looks like it's the 3rd one, FFWD FFWD, crap too far, REWIND REWIND, shit, this is the wrong cassette, EJECT, aagh the tape got stuck and now it's everywhere, I need to find an octagonal pencil so I can spool it back
- Spivak 3y agoI think this argument is interesting because the people buying them are largely young people who never had them as kids so there's some aspect of it that isn't nostalgia. I have a modest collection of vinyl and it's mostly just me not needing another band t shirt and wanting to throw some money at bands I like.
- wilsonnb3 3y agoIt's just your standard back to basics, reject modernity part of the cycle that always comes after technological advancement
- the_third_wave 3y agoGood-quality cassettes on a reasonable cassette deck sounded "good enough", especially when played on the same equipment as they were recorded on. They may not have given 100% reproduction of the input signal and may have introduced some noise - although Dolby B/C noise reduction mostly dealt with that problem - but that did not matter. Cassettes made it possible to record what you heard - music from the radio, those LP records you borrowed from friends or the library, later even data - and reproduce it more or less as often as you wanted, when you wanted it. To this day I remember which song came after some random song I hear played somewhere because I happened to tape that on my cassette deck when I was in my teens, fingers poised on the play + record buttons on my cassette deck, waiting for that song to start. I do not remember the less than 100% fidelity, tape hiss, wow and flutter or other similar defects because they mattered far less than the fact that I got to record 'my own music'. I still have those tapes in the barn somewhere as well as the cassette deck I used to record it, it'll need new rubber belts before it can play anything again but one day I'll get those and play those old tapes again. Not for the fantastic reproduction but because of the fact that these are my tapes. Cassettes made that possible. Now pre-recorded cassettes, yes, those were less than optimal. They were not popular where I lived (the Netherlands) and I never got one, preferring to buy LP records which sounded better and came in nice sleeves etc.
- kevin_thibedeau 3y ago> the cassette “puts a smudgy fingerprint on everything it touches,” adding noise and hiss, the sound quality degrading with each playback. This applies equally to phonograph recordings. The only real virtue of LP vinyl is that it largely prohibits loudness war nonsense.
- lancesells 3y ago99% of the time I listen to music digitally but I buy LPs for the art and liner notes. My connection with the music I listen to is bigger when I see more of the art and design and read what went into making the album.
- dylan604 3y ago>The only real virtue of LP vinyl is I disagree. As a former DJ that played vinyl, it truly was a tactile experience. The loss of that with the switch to CDs and now digital media is truly something that's not appreciated.
- ano-ther 3y agoYes. Including the haptic + visual element of searching for the next one when going through the sleeves. CDs at least still had that, while digital file lists are just much harder to navigate. (This is also why I keep buying physical books despite enjoying the convenience of an e-reader)
- dylan604 3y agoctrl+f in the list is still a lot easier to find something even if just file name, but most systems use id3 tags so artist/track/album are accessible.
- nine_k 3y agoCtrl+F is efficient. Fingering through disks and books is visceral. The latter is a special pleasure for some, and an easier way to orient in a multitude. (Not for me, but I can appreciate the difference all right.)
- forinti 3y agoCassettes were perfect for 8 bit micros. They were a bit slow, but cheap and somewhat reliable. Ten year old me bought a metre of stereo cable and two male audio jacks so I could copy tapes using my dad's 3-in-1 and my tape player. You could get 7-minutes-a-side tapes that allowed one game on each side.
- tyingq 3y agoIt was also nice for cars at the time. There were 8-track car head units, but those were very bulky and only held ~80 minutes of audio.
- TacticalCoder 3y ago> Cassettes were perfect for 8 bit micros. My Commodore had a cassette reader/writer but I never managed to copy a cassette. I was only a kid and tried hard to copy cassettes at my best friend's place (his father had a back then insane Nakamichi stereo rack) but I never succeeded. Then I discovered 5"1/4 floppy disks and never looked back!
- hakfoo 3y agoI've heard the Commodore mechanism has a signal processing model that's pretty different from an audio deck, even if the tape transport and heads are comparable. I suspect this is a combination of "saving a nickel" and "the characteristics best for nuanced analog audio are irrelevant or worse for data"
- j-a-a-p 3y agoAccording Wikipedia (1), Lou Ottens, the inventor of the compact cassette also formed a team to develop the compact disc. (1): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lou_Ottens https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lou_Ottens
- dieselgate 3y agoI remember when having a cassette tape for something started being very uncool - when CDs were getting big. They still have a time and place for me, picked up some bargain cassettes a couple weeks ago - Hendrix and the B-52s. My car has an original tape player and I like listening to full albums
- jrumbut 3y agoI remember when I first saw one of those aux to cassette deck adapters, it was amazing to be able to plug in into an mp3 player or laptop and have your entire music collection available. The newer cars that only had a CD player seemed like such a downgrade.
- TacticalCoder 3y ago> I remember when having a cassette tape for something started being very uncool - when CDs were getting big. I was there... Thing is: the difference in sound quality was night and day between a typical cassette and a CD. It was as if I was born a second time and I still regard that Philips/Sony joint venture (creating that 16 bit/44.1 kHz/stereo format and the associated CD) one the biggest invention of my lifetime.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- MPlus88 3y ago[dead]
- beej71 3y agoRemember when we had a recording industry, back before cassette tapes destroyed it? None of the artists were able to make money, and now no one makes music anymore. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Home_Taping_Is_Killing_Music https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Home_Taping_Is_Killing_Music
- SoftTalker 3y ago> no one makes music anymore Certainly not true. Is this sarcasm?
- thsksbd 3y agoSlathered in sarcasm, see his link
- marttt 3y agoIn 2008, an Estoian artist and indie theatre house made a spinoff of sorts from this: a play and book entitled "Homefucking is killing prostitution": http://krismoor.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/raamatu-kaas.jpg http://krismoor.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/raamatu-kaas.... IIRC, the "play" was actually never performed (part of the concept was doing PR, interviews etc about a project that's never going to happen -- you can generate quite a bit of public fluff fairly quickly in a small society like Estonia). The book was real, though.
- sandworm101 3y agoCassettes were horrible. Anyone saying otherwise is likely too young to have ever lived with them. They sounded bad and broke easily. They got stuck in machines. They were slow to use. CDs were like getting starlink broadband after decades of dialup. We can salute them and give them pride of place in museums, but releasing them back into the wild is a big mistake.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- js2 3y agoYup, and even worse: the 8-track. https://youtu.be/XLZS0Sj9-1U https://youtu.be/XLZS0Sj9-1U
- brandonmenc 3y agoAt least with 8-tracks you could skip tracks with a button.
- noizejoy 3y agotracks yes, not songs, though :-)
- sourcecodeplz 3y agoActually the CD-players always seemed to skip and pause whenever I walked too fast, jumped or even in the car when going over some pot-holes. Cassette-tapes were also very easy to reuse. I also used them to save and load BASIC code.
- glxxyz 3y agoThat's why portable CD players added 30 second anti-skip or whatever, basically read a big chunk of the track into RAM so that the read head skipping around didn't affect playback. Tapes were definitely more stable.
- 3y ago
- jareklupinski 3y agoI bought an as-is cassette deck and have about 20 tapes of vaporwave and other synth-heavy music Just like tube amps add 'color' and 'warmth' to sound, so too do cassette mechanisms add 'wobble' and 'flutter' which really makes vaporwave come into its own
- eschaton 3y ago“Home taping is killing the music industry! We’ve left the other side of this cassette blank so you can do your part.”
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- agentultra 3y agoWe lost a pretty awesome record label in my city at the beginning of the pandemic. They released exclusively on cassette and hosted a lot of experimental music events. Cassettes and tape are my favourite medium right now. Nebraska was my favourite Springsteen album. The Beetles recorded on four track. It blends well with experimental/electronic music. It has become a symbol for the DIY/indie spirit in modern art. I hope it sticks around and I hope someone finds and licenses the recipe and process to make those Maxwell Type-II’s again.
- growingkittens 3y agoMy favorite way to listen to "While My Guitar Gently Weeps" is how I originally heard it via cassette. My tape was second-hand and well used by the time I got it, and often unravelled. The introduced distortion was amazing.
- maxbond 3y agoI've heard it said that people remember media not for it's fidelity, but for it's flaws. I've come to appreciate over the last several years that seeming imperfections often improve a medium in ways that are difficult to quantify or to convey. For instance I've noticed it's much more comfortable for me to read eink than to read from an LCD, and I think it may be because the eink has imperfections. I think the balls don't always rotate, and it creates a subtle noise texture in the background. It reminds me of comfort noise that's played on telephone systems.
- braunboffel 3y agoeink doesn't use rotating balls. You're confusing eink with gyricon from Xerox. That product died ages ago.
- maxbond 3y agoThank you for the correction, eink is a more diverse and interesting set of technologies than I was previously aware.
- sickcodebruh 3y agoCassettes are coming back in a big way. They never totally died in the underground metal world, especially black metal, but they’re bigger right now that at any time in my 20-ish years of recording and releasing music. They have a few benefits: extremely cheap to make and ship. Easy to store in a small apartment, car, pocket. More durable than a CD. Imperfect and grimy in a way that feels appropriate for underground music that celebrates rawness. My new album was released at the end of September and it’s selling well across all formats but the only ones where we’re sold out: limited edition vinyl colors and — you guessed it — cassettes. After years of fighting it, I’m finally getting a new tape player for Christmas. I’m a digital audio guy but so many albums that I want to listen to can only be found on YouTube or tape and I want to support the bands directly. I can get a modern unit complete with rechargeable battery and Bluetooth for $160. https://www.wearerewind.com/ https://www.wearerewind.com/ Finally, I can use my AirPod Max headphones to listen to a $6 raw black metal cassette as the Dark Lord intended.
- glxxyz 3y agoNew tape decks are poor quality, even wearerewind which puts it in a cool package uses the only new mechanism still manufactured, same as everyone else: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WleZGWAebsY&t=33s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WleZGWAebsY&t=33s . It may be fine for some genres though ;) The only way to play cassettes with high fidelity is to use a vintage tape deck, some of them are amazing.
- BLKNSLVR 3y ago> More durable than a CD This irks me. Not that it's not true, but that tapes come with protective packaging intrinsic to the tape itself, whilst CDs are the raw media that you actually touch with your fingers etc. CDs, way back when, were touted as the future not only because of their increased capacity for sound quality but also, ironically, their durability. Would CDs be actually more durable if they were also packaged with a small plastic exterior that was insertable into the player, like tapes? (Tape as raw medium isn't very durable if treated the same way as a CD. Tape needs that plastic exterior to even be viable).
- 3y ago
- mulmen 3y agoI recently built a new PC. For the first time it has no CD drive. I have a modest vinyl record collection. I lost track of my cassettes when we got a CD burner. But my dad still has a collection of tape media and the associated hardware. I wonder what will drive the nostalgic revival of CDs.
- doublerabbit 3y ago> I wonder what will drive the nostalgic revival of CDs When AI implants require you to submit biometric prints of your nostrils to launch Microsoft Windows 12?
- wilsonnb3 3y agoCDs have to fall out of favor first, it is still standard procedure for albums to come out on CD and they are still sold in most music stores.
- simondotau 3y agoPart of the magic around format revival is the inconvenience and imperfection triggering nostalgia. Vinyl is unwieldy, fragile, non-portable, requires maintenance, and the sound has a moderate noise floor. Cassettes require vintage equipment, need to be rewound, have fragile tape, and (except in ideal situations) are significantly audibly compromised. Compact disc is easy to handle, can withstand some abuse, has no format-induced artefacts, and compatible players are still available brand new for as low as $15. There’s about as much nostalgia to find in there as there is for a Parallel ATA hard disk.
- fzeroracer 3y agoActually, one of the more interesting things is that CDs are more fragile in many respects compared to records. Many records from 50+ years ago can still play fine even with a bit of scuff, but CDs from 20-25 years ago can be a gamble in my experience. Especially CDs earlier on that spectrum; disc rot can be a problem because of poor manufacturing not to mention damage from earlier CD players or general misuse. In comparison to cassettes I'd say they're about even when it comes to proper care if we're talking modern CDs. When you start really digging into the average lifespan and durability of the various formats, it starts to become apparent that CDs were fairly overstated even when stored and managed properly.
- stuart78 3y agoI grew up with tapes and have reconnected with them in recent years. I have plenty of vinyl as well, but tapes have a nicer nostalgic feel for me (and don’t require as much careful handling). I particularly like shopping for tapes. In most shops used vinyl is many times picked over and overwhelming. But tape sections are smaller and more efficient to browse. For me, there is a certain feel to the old tapes I want (and certain labels, particularly Moon Glyph, for the new stuff) and finding a fit has a very specific thrill I don’t get elsewhere.
- Projectiboga 3y agoI've heard that Heavy Metal fans like the official studio released cassette tape mixes of many 70s and 80s albums.
- palmfacehn 3y agoRemember when people played their digital audio through tape deck adapters? Why not build a digital audio player that has the cassette tape formfactor? Put whichever flash media directly into the cassette. Transmit audio over the cassette head like those old line-in to tape adapters. Use the wheels of the cassette to charge the device and control playback. All of the hipster cred of the cassette formfactor combined with the quality of digital audio.
- sintezcs 3y agoFunnytoday365 Retro Car Telecontrol Tape Audio Cassette Sd Mmc Mp3 Player Adapter Kit + Remote https://a.co/d/isD9VEg https://a.co/d/isD9VEg
- romwell 3y agoI've had this exact thing for years! It does work as described. I also haven't found a good use for it in the 10-15 years that I've owned it.
- theodric 3y agoHas existed for over 20 years: https://www.cnet.com/reviews/digisette-duo-review/ https://www.cnet.com/reviews/digisette-duo-review/
- lodovic 3y agoThere was never an issue storing digital audio on tape. In fact, tape is still quite popular as a digital backup medium.
- romwell 3y ago>Why not build a digital audio player that has the cassette tape formfactor? Put whichever flash media directly into the cassette. Transmit audio over the cassette head like those old line-in to tape adapters. Use the wheels of the cassette to charge the device and control playback. I've had a device like that for about 10-15 years. It did exactly that, except for charging (it had an internal USB-charged battery that lasted long enough to not care much about it). Ultimately, I didn't use it for the same reason I haven't used an MP3 player in a long time: if I wanted to play MP3s, I already have a device in my pocket that does it better, and has a screen. One of the appeals of the cassette and vinyl is the finiteness of it, and the idea of having a dedicated physical object for a particular piece of information. It's the idea of "I hold this thing to experince that sound". To get that, one could simply distribute music on cassete-shaped MP3 players that only hold one album... but at that point, might as well do an actual cassette tape. This could find a use for having entire compilations on a cassette; e.g. one magic cassete with all the albums by a particular band, or 12 hours of lofi chillhop to study to. But at that point, using your tape machine's controls to control playback becomes very tedious (do you really want to fast-forward through hours worth of audio, or hit the "next" button 236 times to get to the track you want?). You can limit yourself to, say, only 90 minutes worth of audio per physical medium... at which point you're back to the original cassette. Even my car's MP3 CD player doesn't run into the same problem, because its controls allow it to navigate folders: up/down scroll through folders, left/right scrolls throuh files. I can comfortably click through 10-20 items (which is how many songs fit on a standard audio CD), so I can easily navigate through 10-20 albums with 10-20 songs on an MP3 CD - which is the entire capacity at reasonable compression levels. Audio cassette players simply don't have enough buttons for that; so you're limited to about what the standard cassete can hold before you start putting things on a new cassette. Quality-wise, there's no gain either. But yeah, if you are so desperate to look cool while also going the extra mile to avoid being cool - sure, it would do the job. A bluetooth cassette adapter seems like an easier solution though.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- johncoltrane 3y agoThe 90s were awesome: https://www.mixcloud.com/chromeclass/ https://www.mixcloud.com/chromeclass/
- JR1427 3y agoI am looking forward to the CD revolution, USB stick revolution, mp3 revolution, etc.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 082349872349872 3y agoThe NYT won't let me see TFA, so I hope it mentions that cassettes, via samizdat, also shook things up on the other side of the Iron Curtain.
- Full_Clark 3y agoFWIW this publication is The New Yorker, not the New York Times, and the linked article didn't have any sort of paywall or preview feature when I clicked through. I don't think trying again will bring you any joy, though, since none of the words samizdat, iron, curtain, soviet, nor USSR appear in the text.
- aebtebeten 3y agoThanks, my bad. I'm still paywalled, so I went to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cassette_tape#Cassette_culture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cassette_tape#Cassette_culture where TIL tapes also played a role in the 1979 Iranian Revolution.
- dylan604 3y agoThe fax machine also played a role in bringing down the Iron Curtain
- OfSanguineFire 3y agoTapes indeed played a role in the Iranian Revolution, but it was largely a negative one in making Khomeini popular enough that he could return from exile and immediately marginalize the broad coalition that had overthrown the shah. But after 1979, smuggled cassettes also allowed Western-leaning Iranians to maintain contact with the pop culture that they had been cut off from due to the new regime.
- jay_kyburz 3y agoI was thinking the other week, I wouldn't mind having a nice physical copy of a lot of my data. There was something "human" about flipping through my CD collection looking for something to put on. Or browsing the bookshelf, looking for a book to read. I think it needs to be bigger than Micro SD, more surface area for art than a thumb drive, but a CD is too big I think. A game boy cartridge would be a good size I think, or perhaps a credit card. I would love a box of credit card size memory sticks. I could could flip through them, share one with a friend, carry them around. More physical that just moving files on and off my phone. One card for each band perhaps, or each author. All of Tools albums, or the collected works for G.R.R. Martin. It would be nice if you could just place the card on you phone and the phone just reads the data and plays the music. Or rest it on your laptop and browse it like it was a drive. It would never take off, but nice to dream about.
- dfex 3y agoI think the Minidisc[1] is what you're after - 68mm×72mm (2.7in x 2.8in), 80 minutes of audio/~300MB of data. I'm always confused by my desire for slightly inconvenient physical formats like this to make a comeback - I suspect it's some combination of 90s nostalgia (I'm mid-40s) and a psychological reaction to the enshitification of culture now being an endless subscription service. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MiniDisc https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MiniDisc
- mackrevinack 3y agothe good thing about miniDisc is that its relatively easy to get the tracks back off it again. like if you wanted to share a disc with a friend, they could copy the tracks onto their computer using webminidisc or some other software. all the software is a bit old and janky but it's quicker than having to copy a tape!
- jay_kyburz 3y agoIt's the right size for sure, but you can buy 32GB of Micro SD for about $10. And and an SD card reader is a lot easier to find. The are just a little too small. :) It's not just nostalgia. I think when you start looking for them there are a lot of good reasons to start doing this. Physical backups, privacy of not having so much life online, less subscriptions required (dropbox), easier sharing without gate keepers. SanDisk should make something. A credit card with a few small raised bumps for the connection so you can just rest it on a surface rather than having to plug it in. Then a simple little USB reader that is just a flat surface you can place on your desk.
- neonate 3y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20231119211253/https://www.newyorker.com/culture/cultural-comment/the-cassette-tape-revolution https://web.archive.org/web/20231119211253/https://www.newyo... https://archive.ph/ADJAW https://archive.ph/ADJAW
- madengr 3y agoWatch there now be a cassette renaissance like there was a record renaissance, despite the cassette having horrible audio quality compared to a CD.
- anarbadalov 3y agoThere's been a resurgence for a while! There are countless tape labels releasing interesting music (see: https://daily.bandcamp.com/tape-label-report https://daily.bandcamp.com/tape-label-report and Marc Masters' book "High Bias," which is mentioned in the piece).
- wilsonnb3 3y agoYou can buy them from Barnes and Noble and Taylor Swift is releasing her new stuff on them, I think the renaissance has begun (and possibly already peaked) https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/bleach-nirvana/29210673?ean=0098787003444 https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/bleach-nirvana/29210673?ean... https://store.taylorswift.com/collections/cassette-shop https://store.taylorswift.com/collections/cassette-shop
- spking 3y agoWithin seconds of loading the page, a giant toast taking up half the bottom of the screen, and a separate modal overlay with some other message to subscribe pop up and completely obscure the article. And that's with ad blocking. https://deathtobullshit.com/ https://deathtobullshit.com/ more relevant than ever.
- genewitch 3y agoThe blog is ironic a medium and a tumblr link, both of which completely obscure the content on load in landscape, with bullshit. For the price of a single cold brew grande at Starbucks you can use lightsail or whatever the darling tiny VM service of HN is this week, and if you can't afford that, then put a patreon up or something. Yes, a domain name can cost a bit, but you can get 5+ years at a discount some places, and it's cheaper than any driver's license I've had to renew, I believe.
- prmoustache 3y agoUsage of thi addon is becoming the only way to browse the web correctly: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/activate-reader-view/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/activate-read...
- noizejoy 3y agohowever this always gives me pause: > "This add-on is not actively monitored for security by Mozilla. Make sure you trust it before installing."
- prmoustache 3y agoYou can have a look at the code, and disable auto updates.