4 ms·
> This sounds like an insane conflict of interest. It would be, but: this company hasn't been formed yet and this sketch does not justify the haste with which
by jacquesm 3y ago
> This sounds like an insane conflict of interest.
It would be, but: this company hasn't been formed yet and this sketch does not justify the haste with which they kicked him out, there were all kinds of boxes that needed to be checked before they could do that without risking damage to OpenAI, this is a founder and the CEO we're speaking of.
Besides that: stupidly enough the contract that Sam has with OpenAI does not have a non-compete in it (this has been confirmed by multiple sources now I take that as true) and I don't see how it directly would harm OpenAI other than that his attention might be diluted and that it should be clear which cap he is wearing. But until that company formed and Sam named himself CEO of it (or took up some other high profile role) it leaves him so many outs that it only makes the board look like bumbling idiots. Because now he can simply say: "I would only be an investor" and that would be that, just like the rest of the investors in OpenAI (and, notably some members of the board) have conflicts of interest at least as large.
So if this was it they're in even more trouble than they were before because now it is the boards' conflicts of interest that will be held up to the light and those are not necessarily smaller.
What a complete circus.
- sangnoir 3y agoDo you think there's a problem with him pitching his hardware side-gig to investors who approached him with an interest in OpenAI's tender offer? That gives the appearance of quid pro quo; with the hope that the investors get to skip the next line at the next OpenAI investment opportunity. Imagine someone high up on the Nvidia sales org telling a customer they are all out of H200 graphics cards for the half, but they have a fantastic timeshare investment opportunity they are selling on the side while the customer waits for the next batch.
- jacquesm 3y agoNot necessarily, unless he proposed to run it himself. I don't see any evidence of that. Just tons of speculation.
- murakamiiq84 3y agoI thought non-competes are not legally enforceable in the state of California anyway.
- whatwhaaaaat 3y agoWhy do you keep calling him a founder? Is my history wrong or did he jump from leading THIS very website to OpenAI when they came through for a round of sweet hn bucks.
- jacquesm 3y agoFrom the caption right underneath his picture on this page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OpenAI https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OpenAI "Co-founder and former CEO of OpenAI, Sam Altman" as well as countless news articles repeating this as if it is a well known fact, for which to date I haven't seen any contradicting information.
- wmf 3y agoLooks like he was originally "co-chair" which sounds pretty foundery. https://web.archive.org/web/20170729172845/https://blog.openai.com/introducing-openai/ https://web.archive.org/web/20170729172845/https://blog.open...
- jacquesm 3y agoHe also committed a chunk of the initial funding. And it's not rare for capital providers who are there on day #1 to call themselves and be referred to as co-founders. Essentially it is a short-hand for 'those that were present on the founding day of the company and whose names appear on the founding documents besides the lawyers'. If you get added later on then you are technically not a co-founder, though even there sometimes (and sometimes rightly) exceptions are made.
- pyb 3y ago> And it's not rare for capital providers who are there on day #1 to call themselves and be referred to as co-founders. I believe the opposite, never heard of any hands-off investors calling themselves co-founders.
- s1artibartfast 3y ago
- jibe 3y agostupidly enough the contract that Sam has with OpenAI does not have a non-compete Does it really matter? If the behavior appears to be in conflict with OpenAI, and the board doesn’t like it, then that’s enough to let him go. It doesn’t need to be a contract violation, he just wasn’t doing the job they wanted him to do.
- jacquesm 3y agoYes, details like that really matter, and if the party you let go can pull half the company out from under you then you may have won the battle but you've just lost the war. On top of that you'll be in lawsuits until the third generation or so given who else sits at that table (Sequoia, YC and Microsoft to name a few).