5 ms·
Ex-IBM sales veteran sues for access to health benefits
- stefantalpalaru 3y ago[dead]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- neilv 3y agoOne of the things I like about some tech companies is that they seem to care how employees feel about the company. I haven't gotten that impression from IBM in a long time, however.
- ChuckMcM 3y agoIn my brief tenure at IBM after they acquired Blekko I quickly came to realize that the near death experience in the 90's fundamentally changed the company. It gave their Finance team an iron lock on all decisions and all of their decisions were based on 'how much will this cost?' and 'how much will this save?' It made corporate politics easier, if you pitched a project all you had to do was code the language that Finance wanted to hear and even if people didn't "want" it, it could get approved. Quite sad in a way.
- namdnay 3y agoI think that’s an indirect consequence of tech companies being profitable and operating in a tight labour market. As soon as investors worry, the whole care-bear thing goes out of the window, and it never even existed for those cleaning the offices
- toast0 3y agoI would rather honesty. I don't want to be told to bring my authentic self to work, when that's not really what they want. I'm also not a fan of the company providing food, laundry, transportation, travel arrangements, etc, etc, etc and claiming that they want to ease my life or whatever, when really they just want to make it harder to leave to another job.
- neilv 3y agoOn those little lifestyle perquisites, those can be good for morale, and can also mean a person spends more time and attention working. Before dotcoms, I worked places that would pay for delivered dinner for anyone working late (otherwise, as soon as you leave the office, you call it a day, plus company is feeding you like parent, plus little social camaraderie break with other people working late), or would provide cab vouchers for people who worked late (no going home only because don't feel safe walking home after dark), etc. I don't think anyone has illusions about the motives there, and there's some alignment. The "make it harder to leave to another job" I dislike is things like stock options that must be exercised within 90 days of leaving, before the stock is liquid and before you know whether it'll be worth anything. Or health insurance situations for some people (improved since ACA). Or bonus or retirement contribution schedules that mean waiting until the end of the year (and with no guarantee there won't be layoffs shortly before, especially given that a sociopathic company has incentive not to pay). (One of the big reasons I didn't take a nice non-blockchain fintech job offer with FAANG-like TC level was because of all the complex structuring of the compensation, with several kinds of bonuses and shares and retirement contributions, which supposedly were all but guaranteed, but all on annual schedules, and the salary alone wasn't going to elevate my lifestyle from an early startup. Contrast with a company that routinely deposits so much money into your bank account that you don't much have to think about money -- that's a nice way to retain people and let them focus on the work.)
- ChuckMcM 3y agoI wish him luck. I had a very humbling discussion with an employment attorney when I was dealing with some clearly illegal stuff going on at work and their advice was "First, people don't keep employed people who are suing them so ask yourself how much money you'll have at the end of the next two years if you just quit and work somewhere else, or spend $15K - $30K on a lawsuit that may or may not result in a severance package?" And then the kicker, "Then ask yourself what a hiring manager of a company you are applying to work at will feel when they find out you sued a previous employer?" It really is stacked against the worker here. That he is already retired is a good thing, one hopes there isn't a clause buried in his pension that cancels it if he ever sues IBM.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoThe best people to file these claims are those near retirement who have much less to lose. Otherwise, the situation for workers remains…suboptimal in perpetuity. It is full of peril as you mention.
- kshacker 3y agoI think the amounts are big enough to warrant a lawsuit. He is retired. The program is for retirees so they have nothing to lose in terms of future employment. The article hints at annual damages being 15-20K per retiree, and mentions impact on 3000 people (without actually calling it so precisely), so if 60 M is the annual savings to IBM, it is a lot of money to find lawyers and arrive at a retired-employee friendly outcome.
- recursivedoubts 3y agoi can see both sides of the public/private healthcare debate but tying healthcare to employment is just incredibly stupid
- lotsofpulp 3y agoTechnically, it is giving employers and employees a tax break if the employer buys the health insurance and sufficiently subsidizes it to incentivize sufficient employees to opt into the subsidized health insurance such that it passes the non discrimination testing. Roughly worth at least couple thousand dollars per year for individuals and quite a few thousand dollars per year for families. Basically, a way to give bigger/better funded businesses an advantage over smaller businesses who cannot afford all that employment overhead, especially HR paperwork. Plus it helps obfuscate labor prices so labor sellers have a harder time shopping around for a better offer. Retiree healthcare coverage is beyond stupid though, I would value it at zero as an employee unless it was the federal government offering it. I don’t think there are any protections for it either, so the employer holds all the cards. I would prefer if all these tax advantages were nixed from employers and offered directly to all individuals, if that.
- ghaff 3y agoMy dad had some retirement healthcare through an employer. As I recall, it wasn't especially cheap and then, to his surprise, it turned out there was a cap. So basically was a pretty lousy deal. I agree with the broader point. There are historical reasons in the US for good health insurance benefits being so tied to, mostly, large employers. But it's just bad policy.
- phpisthebest 3y agoPeople need to understand the historical significance of why these things came into being. Especially since we are on the verge of WWIII on multiple fronts. History should not repeat itself if we find ourselfs in a world war again WWII price controls are directly responsible for Employer Benefit plans, it was illegal to raise wages, but it was not illegal to offer employee's health care, at the time this was direct health care, companies were employing nurses, doctors, etc that would not only see the employee but their entire family often free or very low rates. This morphed over time into the employer insurance model we have today.
- anonymouskimmer 3y ago> But with Medicare Advantage, "once you're in a Medicare Advantage plan for more than 12 months, you cannot then buy a Medigap plan unless you meet insurance requirements," he claimed. So if you have a preexisting condition, they can deny you coverage and the retiree then has to pay that 20 percent. > Kadereit argues this state of affairs is being allowed to happen by Congress to avoid tough decisions about how to deal with spiraling healthcare costs. And business accounts departments like it because there's profit to be made. But what we should really worry about are Obamacare death panels.
- fragmede 3y agoIn hindsight, the argument about Obamacare death panels should defer to the fact that they already existed, the question is do you want insurance adjusters on your panel, or doctors?
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoNeither, really. Doctors are famous for not wanting heroic measures taken.
- nativeit 3y agoWho said anything about heroes? We just need choices about medical necessity to be made by something other than how it might benefit some company’s bottom line. It’s not exactly donning a cape.
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoIn case you didn't know: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heroic_measure https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heroic_measure And yes, it's far better for triage to be done by trained medical people than by insurance adjusters. But if given the option, I'd prefer just me and my loved ones making medical decisions about me. Of course we don't have this option, but it should still be something to strive for.
- Beijinger 3y agoYou were not there for me when I looked for a job. Why should I care for you now? Good riddance.
- bigbillheck 3y agoAs workers we owe it to each other to stick together.
- 1letterunixname 3y agoIt's not a surprise that corporations prioritize financial interests over the lives of employees and retirees because they can. The mistake employees make is depending on hollow, unenforceable promises for financial and health security. The current only recourse is a lengthy, costly gamble in the courts that could be delayed until the plaintiff runs out of money or dies. It behooves potential employees to instead form worker-owned co-ops, that like credit unions, have different interests aligned to serve their members.
- taurath 3y agoIt’s little known but when a retiree or on COBRA a company can functionally force you onto a drastically worse plan at any time, whenever they want, to save money. I was paying thousands to stay on my previous companies COBRA and suddenly my low ($1000) deductible plan had changed overnight to a plan with a $7000 deductible. Suddenly I was paying for the privilege of paying. This is devastating to a lot of people.
- DANmode 3y agoLinking a vital need such as healthcare to something so fungible as an employer seems poorly thought out in this era.
- yummypaint 3y agoYeah its absurd that people's employers effectively make medical decisions on their behalf. Death panels indeed.
- theGnuMe 3y agoCobra makes you eligible for the health plan but you have to pay both the employer and the employee portions which is why it jumps up.
- ericjmorey 3y agoAccess to healthcare should not in any way be tied to an employer or employment. Please let's stop this system and replace it with a functioning one with proper incentives.