6 ms·
I'm generally pretty supportive of new typefaces, but this one strikes me as... not very legible. The x-height is so uncommonly high it makes it genuinely diff
by crazygringo 3y ago
I'm generally pretty supportive of new typefaces, but this one strikes me as... not very legible.
The x-height is so uncommonly high it makes it genuinely difficult to distinguish between uppercase/ascending and lowercase letters at a glance (e.g. 'U' vs 'u', or 'h' vs. 'n'), and similarly the descender is so tiny it makes it hard to distinguish certain letters at a glance (e.g. 'q' vs 'p'). The whole point of large-enough ascenders and descenders is to recognize the shapes of whole words before looking at their letters, which these dimensions destroy.
The extremely square aspect of rounded segments similarly makes them harder to distinguish from straight segments at a glance (e.g. 'U' vs 'O' are far more similar than you want for legibility).
Not to mention, italic cursive is particularly difficult to read. Handwritten-style cursive was never designed for legibility -- it was designed for speed in writing. Adopting it in a body-text typeface meant for reading adds work for the reader to decipher it.
I don't want to be so negative, but typeface design has certain principles that the creator is simply ignoring. They're not arbitrary or aesthetic, but rather are directly about functional legibility.
At the end of the day, this typeface goes out of its way to be surprisingly difficult to read. You can read it, but it simply takes more effort. Which is generally the last thing you want in a typeface for coding (or anything body text).
- johnsillings 3y agoSame reaction here. Legibility is below-average, and I don't love the look & feel either.
- rubjo 3y agoThat’s ok, thank you for having a look!
- mikeortman 3y ago[flagged]
- rob74 3y agoBeing supportive of new typefaces doesn't mean you have to like everything you see? Personally, I'm biased because I prefer the "good old" typewriter-style monospace fonts with serifs, which already eliminates around 90% of "programming fonts". My current favorite (not only for Go) is Go Mono (https://go.dev/blog/go-fonts https://go.dev/blog/go-fonts).
- DrammBA 3y agoI don't think the 3-4 well-presented arguments that the OP is making would be considered an 'essay'. Do you have any counter-arguments or you just feel offended by their comment?
- rubjo 3y agoTypeface designer here. Thanks for trying the font and having lots of thoughts about it. I guess the point is that it wasn’t first and foremost designed to follow as many font design principles as possible. If that’s what’s important to you, pick a font that follows as many of these principles as possible. :D In the end, I guess I don’t really care whether I use 157ms to parse a sentence instead of 158 - although to me, the font is absolutely super-legible.
- redleader55 3y agoI'm surprised you as a typeface designer are not interested in what end-users(aren't they the customers?) are saying about the font. This means, assuming good intent, that's not where the money is coming from. Can someone shed some light on who pays typeface designers and what are the incentives like?
- nilamo 3y agoCan it not just be something that's done for fun, for the benefit of whoever made it?
- tokai 3y agoThe supporters listed on the page pays.
- admax88qqq 3y agoI think he meant he's the designer of _this_ typeface. Not in general. And for _this_ typeface as a labour of love why shouldn't they disregard user feedback when they made it for their own purposes.
- cosmojg 3y agoSometimes, people do things for fun.
- zare_st 3y agoWell you made it explicitly for programming purposes. I am not a poll house or a public opinion evaluator. But handwritten cursive and programming I wouldn't put in a same sentence. The ligatures and the height you choose really don't go well with a lot of popular programming languages. I'm not sure what aspect of programming do you believe is "inhumane" so you have desire to introduce "humanity" through design choice.
- junon 3y agoThis is exactly my thought. I can't tell what's uppercase or lowercase without really analyzing each word.
- rubjo 3y agoWow, that’s really surprising to hear. I hope you have found a different font where this is super-clear.
- aaarrm 3y agoYou seem to know what you're talking about, so do you have any suggestions for good font choices for programming in particular?
- doc_gunthrop 3y agoNot OP but there were some decent ones in the comparison box w/ the slider (such as Source Code Pro). Deja Vu Sans Mono is another good one.
- tentacleuno 3y agoI daily Inconsolata (well, technically the ligaturized version). I find it extremely legible, and most importantly, it's easy on the eyes. A lot of programming fonts tend to be too angular for my tastes (I've tried SF Mono and plenty others, and settled on Inconsolata.) Really, programming fonts are down to taste -- there's not objectively a best one; for an example of that, look in this thread: some people like Victor Mono, whilst others dislike it, and that's fine!
- rubjo 3y agoThank you for being a voice of reason :) +1 for Inconsolata, by the way, lovely font!
- layer8 3y agoLarge x-height is beneficial for low DPI (cf. Lucida Console for example), but this font doesn’t seem to have the necessary hinting for low-DPI use.
- galkk 3y agoI used victor mono as primary font everywhere (vscode, idea, terminal) for very long time, and disagree with your opinion of its readability. It successfully replaced Fira Code to me. Anecdotal evidence, of course, but I want to counter the authoritative tone of your comment. Although I’m using Iosevka now, Victor Mono was reliable work horse for me for very long time. I found that font through coding font tournament style selector (codingfont.com). I may miss some, but my history was Courier New - Consolas - Dejavu Sans Mono - Anonymous Pro - Azeret Mono - Fira Code - Victor Mono - Iosevka - Iosevka Slab, and if I will decide to go back, Victor Mono is going to be first choice
- romwell 3y agoTo add to that, my expectation of fonts is that the italic version follows the same style as the non-italic version (same goes for bold). Having a typewriter-like font whose italics version looks like handwritten cursive breaks this expectation. If it was meant for code comments, the solution is to configure the IDE to use a different font and not to hack the format. Victor Mono is two fonts in a trenchcoat for no good reason.
- tln 3y agoVerdana also has a high x-height, in fact for legibility, many road sign fonts have a high x-height as well. This font does have an unusually high x-height, but IMO its very well done. Capitals and lowercase are very distinct. The cursive thing isn't my cup of tea, but there are oblique versions too. Overall I think this font has a lot of character. Kudos to the designer, nice work!
- Dutchie987 3y agoI find the italic cursive very pleasing and not hard to read at all. It looks exactly like the worksheets I had in elementary school when learning how to write. My handwriting was never that neat but many people in my class had exactly this 'font' when writing. That was a long time ago...