3 ms·
To be pedantic, ritual solves the common knowledge problem (as three-way handshake does for TCP: ensuring both sides know the other has seen a SYN) and adding r
by 082349872349872 3y ago
To be pedantic, ritual solves the common knowledge problem (as three-way handshake does for TCP: ensuring both sides know the other has seen a SYN) and adding rationality to ritual allows one to assume that beyond the core of actual common knowledge, there is an extension of potential common knowledge: things that parties may not be intuitively aware they agree upon off the tops of their heads, but would indeed find they'd arrive at a common (and unique?) solution should they start from the actual common knowledge and apply rational inferences.
In principle, adding rationality should allow one to allow one to reduce the ritual content to a minimum (eg "we hold elections every 4 years whose results determine the leader of the executive branch"?)...
- mistermann 3y ago> In principle, adding rationality should allow one to allow one to reduce the ritual content to a minimum (eg "we hold elections every 4 years whose results determine the leader of the executive branch"?)... Surely you're not implying our current political systems are rational are you?
- 082349872349872 3y ago(a) the political system example was meant to be of the shared, ritual, content (b) events of 6.i.2021 in the US suggest that although such knowledge is certainly common, belief in it may not exactly be universal
- mistermann 3y agoWhich is a sign for hope imho.
- 082349872349872 3y agoI'm not sure I understand; care to explicate?
- mistermann 3y agoThe January 6 people, like most Americans (and even more so: observers of America), realize what "democracy" is described/implied to be, is not what it actually is: a mirage, an illusion, a magic act. And their.....unique personality types did not prevent them from doing "the right thing", which is to simply complain about it endlessly online, expecting the illusion to fix itself, to put itself out of business. What resulted was a hilarious debacle of course, but at least they're trying.
- 082349872349872 3y agoOK, I was guessing half right then — so what should we replace the illusion with, if anything?
- mistermann 3y agoConsider the rise of science in society. And yet despite us now having science, so many problems remain. Perhaps science isn't the end game after all, as scientists and their fan base would have us believe.
- 082349872349872 3y agoOK, stipulated: let's replace democratic politics and scientific research. With what?
- mistermann 3y ago> let's replace...scientific research That doesn't seem like a very good idea to me - I will vote to object. > let's replace democratic politics...With what? Consider how all problems in the world are solved: analyze the problem, develop a solution. Bad news though: analyze democracy and suggest solutions, you just became an employee of Putin (or, some other meme), and no one will be able to take you seriously. So it seems we have nested problems here.