4 ms·
There are some people going to such meetings that have the habit of contradicting the speaker in the hope of sounding smart. Yehuda Katz has proved that he's sm
by bad_user 15y ago
There are some people going to such meetings that have the habit of contradicting the speaker in the hope of sounding smart. Yehuda Katz has proved that he's smart already and I hope he ain't one of those people.
That said, this story doesn't have the right context, ignoring the actual talk and the actual arguments brought by Katz. Maybe the mistakes done by the speaker were too great to be ignored - and this is very unlike the Dale Carnegie story quoted in the article, because such presentations are attended by people that want to learn something.
I have been feeling embarrassed myself when other people corrected me in public and it feels awful, however it's a lot better to accept and acknowledge valid criticism and valid counter arguments and actually thank the person that stood up to you, because you know, you learned something new.
- deong 15y ago> Maybe the mistakes done by the speaker were too great to be ignored Still not appropriate behavior. Ideally, you bring up your point, have a brief discussion, and then, if you still feel the speaker is wrong, you take it offline. You don't have to pretend to agree with him or her -- you can say, "Well, I disagree, but let's talk more about it when you're done."
- fredoliveira 15y agoGetting criticized in public is like getting criticized in private - you feel bad, you swallow hard and eventually you understand it's for your own good. Unless, however, it is done this way. You are being basically made fun of in front of an audience. Instead of using constructive criticism and manners to show he had a better way to do things, Yehuda took the bully stance and made the speaker look bad - much worse than he should.