3 ms·
>It's that the average American, in real terms, is increasingly broke. AFAIK inflation adjusted wages have been creeping up in the last decade, or at least rem
by gruez 3y ago
>It's that the average American, in real terms, is increasingly broke.
AFAIK inflation adjusted wages have been creeping up in the last decade, or at least remained flat. What statistics support the claim that they're "increasingly broke"?
- jrajav 3y agoThat is incorrect. They are at their lowest point in 75 years: https://www.statista.com/statistics/1065466/real-nominal-value-minimum-wage-us/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1065466/real-nominal-val... There is also deeper nuance to consider, like the fact that essential goods such as grocery items have been inflating much faster than other markets, especially in most recent years.
- creato 3y agoParent was talking about wages in general, your chart is for the federal minimum wage.
- jrajav 3y agoYou're right, I missed that in haste. I do think it's still worthwhile to consider the minimum wage since it applies direct upward pressure on other hourly wages, and the question is "how many Americans are effectively broke." The purchasing power of the absolute average American doesn't really answer that question with growing wealth inequality.
- gruez 3y ago>You're right, I missed that in haste. I do think it's still worthwhile to consider the minimum wage since it applies direct upward pressure on other hourly wages That's all true, but is there any reason why we should take the minimum wage seriously when we have median wage data, and only 1.5% of Americans are on the federal minimum wage? Clearly it's not a representative number at all. https://www.zippia.com/advice/minimum-wage-statistics/ https://www.zippia.com/advice/minimum-wage-statistics/ >the question is "how many Americans are effectively broke." The purchasing power of the absolute average American doesn't really answer that question with growing wealth inequality. Why don't you present your statistics then? Also, "broke" =/= "wealth inequality", unless you subscribe to the view that living in 1400s like conditions is not "broke" if everyone else is also equally poor.
- thaumasiotes 3y ago>> I do think it's still worthwhile to consider the minimum wage since it applies direct upward pressure on other hourly wages > That's all true You're conceding a lot; that claim would not generally be viewed as true.
- gruez 3y agoPointing out the points raised is hardly "conceding" when the points are of very little relevance to the claim of "Americans are broke", nor does it rebut the claim of "inflation adjusted wages have been creeping up in the last decade". It's not contradictory to admit that minimum wages have effects on economy wide wages, but also claim that wages have been creeping up.
- thaumasiotes 3y ago> Pointing out the points raised is hardly "conceding" when the points are of very little relevance to the claim of "Americans are broke" "Conceding" is when you stipulate that the points raised are true; it's especially egregious when they aren't.
- jrajav 3y agoWere you planning to actually contribute something to the conversation, in terms of a counterpoint with additional data to consider? Or just be an aggressive naysayer?
- underlipton 3y agoMedian. And my 20-30 years might have been inaccurate; compare to 1970, not 2000. It seems to be a "crime is on the rise" situation; a 50% gain after a 50% drop doesn't get you back to 100.
- gruez 3y ago>Median Employed full time: Median usual weekly real earnings: Wage and salary workers: 16 years and over (LES1252881600Q) https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LES1252881600Q https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LES1252881600Q >It seems to be a "crime is on the rise" situation; a 50% gain after a 50% drop doesn't get you back to 100. The statistics are recording absolute numbers, not "50% gain after a 50% drop".
- underlipton 3y ago>Employed full time: Median usual weekly real earnings: Wage and salary workers: 16 years and over So, a number of problems: >Since 1979. The drop you see at the beginning of the chart is the tail end of a plunge in the 70s as productivity decoupled from wages. This is where the "gain after a drop" is an issue: we are slightly up from rates that were massively down (and not shown on this chart). Then we see stagnation within a ~15% band until just before the start of the pandemic, where there is a dramatic spike that's already regressing. >CPI-weighted. CPI is flawed: https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/012915/what-are-some-limitations-consumer-price-index-cpi.asp https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/012915/what-are-som... Many of the increased costs are not reflected.
- gruez 3y ago>Since 1979. The drop you see at the beginning of the chart is the tail end of a plunge in the 70s as productivity decoupled from wages What "plunge" are you talking about? Even the famous (but flawed) graph from epi shows a very small dip: https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSDmFnpAuY4NMgP1rZfJn8qtZjNiDdqXIZShw&usqp=CAU https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSDmFnp.... Also that was in the 80s, not the 70s as you claimed. >Then we see stagnation within a ~15% band until just before the start of the pandemic, where there is a dramatic spike that's already regressing Again, im not understanding how this could be an issue when the chart is using absolute numbers. If it dips a little then returns to previous levels that does not cause a "50% gain after a 50% drop doesn't get you back to 100" situation because the graph isn't using percentage change. > Many of the increased costs are not reflected. Which specific components do you have issue with? Moreover, the cpi is supposed to represent the country as a whole, so depending on your life situation your true living costs will either be lower or higher than expected. College tuition makes up about 1% of CPI, but if you're a student it's probably your top 3 expense. That's fine, because it's canceled out by all the Americans that aren't in college. The same applies for housing. If you're just moving out and have to find an apartment at market rates you might think the CPI isn't accurately capturing housing costs, but keep in mind that most Americans own their homes and therefore aren't paying market rents.