6 ms·
The industry laughed it up as Falcon 9 failed landing repeatedly. (https://youtu.be/bvim4rsNHkQ https://youtu.be/bvim4rsNHkQ) Then they shifted to “ok but do it
by ceejayoz 3y ago
The industry laughed it up as Falcon 9 failed landing repeatedly. (https://youtu.be/bvim4rsNHkQ https://youtu.be/bvim4rsNHkQ) Then they shifted to “ok but do it 10x”. They aren’t laughing now.
They’ve lost as many Starships as NASA lost Space Shuttles so far, with no deaths. It’s a test program for now.
Ask the “rest of the industry” about how Boeing’s Starliner is going. That’s what failure looks like.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mechhacker 3y agoThen they got the double heavy landing, which was mindblowing seeing it the first time: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lw3KEg6b6bE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lw3KEg6b6bE
- hackeraccount 3y agoThis. Especially with NASA. The more infrequently you launch the more the expectation is that there are no failures so the more time you take to avoid failures and so it recurses into launching SLS once every year and half or taking 10 years to launch J. Webb. I understand a lot of it is politics and government spending but it would be nice if NASA could get a case of go fever every once in awhile. So long as humans aren't involved. I understand if there were more failures there'd be less money for big projects -but I think we should take the chance to see if that money would end up being spent on more smaller quicker projects.
- honeybadger1 3y agoNaysayers offer a problem for every solution, can't stand these types. This is an enormous achievement for SpaceX.
- x86x87 3y agoMove fast and break things, amiright?
- ceejayoz 3y agoIt's good enough for NASA. https://www.nasa.gov/centers-and-facilities/white-sands/destructive-testing/ https://www.nasa.gov/centers-and-facilities/white-sands/dest... We've crashed production probes into Mars, we've burned astronauts alive, we've had the supposedly "safe" options like Boeing's Starliner have fundamental problems even making it to orbit. Space has always been this way. Starship's more akin to taking the Bell X-1 up for a spin than flying a 787 around, for the time being. Problems are expected at this point in the program, or we'd be sending people on them already.
- x86x87 3y agoThis is a false dichotomy. On one side we are talking about how the "space industry" is most moving slowly and how spacex is doing great things. On the other side we are saying that this is good enough for nasa (who is the establishment when it comes to space) and yolo bro. On one side we are defending nasa because priorities, but on the other side we're cheering on spacex who is ultimately sucking at the big fat government tit. i'm not sure anyone is aiming at burning people alive and just because it happened does not make it a justification moving forward.
- hparadiz 3y agoI don't know why you're being a contrarian here. Booster completed it's primary mission. Main vehicle survived long enough to show viability. Multiple technologies were proven beyond a reasonable doubt to work. Shuttle was 1.6 billion a launch. This is gonna be 100 million a lunch even if you let the booster blow up every time. This test is in line with how every new rocket is developed. You really need to Google the 50s and 60s of space flight and see how many rockets were lost in those days. Yet they still got to the moon.
- avmich 3y agoQuite reasonable incremental testing program.
- x86x87 3y agoThis is not about laughing or not. This is about if it was objectfully a successful test or not. If you want to take the stance that any test is a success that's fine but remember this depends on what your definition of success is. The other thing to keep in mind is that past success is not always a good predictor of future success.
- ceejayoz 3y agoThere's no "objectively" here. It's all feels. Objectively, this test successfully demonstrated the water deluge system, an intact launch pad, all engines on the first and second stage igniting and staying lit, stage separation, hot staging, and a long burn nearly to orbital speeds. That's a pretty good list of ticked boxes. They very openly stated they didn't necessarily expect it to get all the way to splashdown. You can argue that's PR, but their history has objectively been one of incremental progress (again, see Falcon 9's landing attempts) via repeat testing. Personally, I'd consider a mission failed if a) it carries a real payload it's supposed to get somewhere and doesn't, b) it breaks due to a previously known issue, or c) it breaks sooner than the last test. I'd also consider it entirely fine to have "reach goals" in a test. They went longer, faster, further, and more successfully than the first test. I'm happy calling that a win, and I suspect SpaceX will as well.
- x86x87 3y agoObjectively, for any test to be judged a failure or success you have to define the outcome you want upfront. If you do not any amount of mental gymnastics you you after the test does not matter. It does not matter you call it a win if you are not respecting other opinions that this is a fail.
- sbuttgereit 3y agoSpaceX very clearly stated just prior to launch that their goal was for the rocket to get through hot-staging because the hot-staging process they had large unknowns. Sure their flight plan went well beyond that, but I don't see how having an aspirational plan that goes beyond "we'll blow it up after hot-staging", also likely required for the FAA, defeats the "successful" qualification of the test.