4 ms·
Is it possible for anyone to review your application without buying it? If not, then I think it's bad form to ask HN to review it.
by scott_s 18y ago
Is it possible for anyone to review your application without buying it? If not, then I think it's bad form to ask HN to review it.
- davidw 18y agoI don't know if it's "bad form" per se, I mean, part of what people here aim to do is make money off of their work. However, I certainly am not going to pay to help you out with your app. But I don't own an iPhone anyway. I would simply say that you shouldn't expect too much help if you don't provide an 'early access' version to users of this site or something like that.
- scott_s 18y agoI say it's bad form because it's disguising an advertisement as a community-based request for feedback.
- davidw 18y agoIt could be. I didn't vote it up, even though I usually do vote for this kind of posting, because I can't review his app (and wouldn't anyway unless he made it available to me for free). It probably depends on the user in question. Looks like this guy's had an account for a while, even if he hasn't participated much.
- staunch 18y agoI agree. If you're asking for free reviews here you should be giving free access (even if it's limited in some way).
- there 18y agoi still don't understand why apple won't introduce some sort of trial period for apps. they already have the code signing/drm framework in place and can control what can run and can't run on your iphone. how hard can it be to allow it to only run for x number of days like their downloadable itunes movies? and even without that framework, there are thousands of non-drm trial apps for mac os x, windows, and other phones that are time-limited and stop working after 30 days or 30 runs. i understand they are probably banking on the fact that users have to fork over money to try anything now, but can it really be that much more money than would be made by additional sales from users that now won't buy apps before they can try them?
- tjr 18y agoIt seems they are relying on the developers to offer free "lite" versions of their applications in order to provide a "trial period" sort of thing. And I suspect this might be better overall for the developers. Consider, if you released an application that someone might plausibly only want to use for 30 days or less, and then have no more use for it. If Apple forced all non-free applications to have a 30-day trial period, then you may be losing out on many sales from people who only need your program for a short time. (E.g., a city travel guide for a one-week trip.) On the other hand, surely Apple could let the developer choose if they wish for their applications to participate in such a trial program or not.
- icey 18y agoAgreed, this just seems like marketing spam to me.