3 ms·
Nit pick: The article explains why many years have passed from the development of efficient steam turbines until the development of efficient gas turbines, due
by adrian_b 3y ago
Nit pick:
The article explains why many years have passed from the development of efficient steam turbines until the development of efficient gas turbines, due to the differences between the Rankine Cycle and the Brayton cycle.
Even if the Americans like to name the Joule cycle as the Brayton cycle, the American name does not have any justification.
While George B. Brayton has patented his engine in 1872, James Prescott Joule has published already in 1851, 21 years earlier, a scientific paper (“On the Air-Engine”) describing what is named now as the Joule cycle, a.k.a. the Brayton cycle.
While the Brayton patent contained very little information, the paper published by Joule was very important and it described in great detail how to design an engine using this thermodynamic cycle and why this is useful.
Moreover, in 1859, 13 years before Brayton, William John Macquorn Rankine has published a very influential manual (“A Manual of the Steam Engine and other Prime Movers”), where all the thermodynamic cycles used in engines known at that time were classified, and he already referred to this cycle as Joule’s cycle.
Therefore there is no doubt about the priority of the term "Joule cycle" over "Brayton cycle".
An interesting fact that is usually not mentioned in most manuals is that at equal maximum temperature and maximum pressure (which are typically limited by the materials used for the engine), the Joule cycle is more efficient than either the Atkinson cycle or the Otto cycle, so the fact that it is the easiest thermodynamic cycle to approximate in a gas turbine is favorable for its efficiency.
- p1mrx 3y agoWe already named an SI unit after Joule. His legacy will be fine.
- scratcheee 3y agoEinstein already has special relativity, his legacy is safe. let’s give general relativity to someone else who had a similar idea 20 years later. I found the preceding argument more compelling.
- Retric 3y agoBy that metric go back to John Barber’s 1791 patent for a gas turbine. Brayton needed to solve actual hard core engineering problems to make the device practical, thus it wasn’t the same idea only similar. There’s little comparison as Brayton was selling commercially viable engines vs writing a paper on a much older idea.
- jasonwatkinspdx 3y agoBrayton Cycle is the established term and it's not some unique American proclivity. This seems like unnecessary nationalistic nonsense.
- rootusrootus 3y agoAnd of course it is the top voted comment in this discussion right now. Europeans have the biggest ongoing case of butthurt I've ever experienced. Is it some kind of inferiority complex because the US is a superpower?
- networkchad 3y ago[dead]
- adrian_b 3y agoI am neither an US citizen nor British so I do not have any personal interest in this. However I care deeply about historical truth and about remembering to whom we are indebted for the things we use every day. In this case there is an indisputable temporal priority, as the term "Joule cycle" had already been in use for a long time before Brayton invented his engine. Even if the priority would not have been so evident, between two people, one who has made some money by building and selling a thing and a second one, who has taught everybody how to build such things and why they should build them, I believe that the reasons to remember the second are much more important, even if it is not unusual for the American spirit to honor more the first.
- jasonwatkinspdx 3y agoI think Joule is doing just fine reputation wise. Language and history is messy. If you don't accept this you'll spend your life tilting at windmills in the most pointless way. Another example, Von Neumann did not invent the architecture named after him. It's named after him because he wrote a very influential report on ENIAC.
- User23 3y agoDid Joule ever actually ever build a Brayton engine? It's one thing to publish papers about how a thing might be done, but it's another entirely to actually create an invention.
- defrost 3y agoHe had grease on his hands - he came up in the days of tinkering with steam engines and his papers came late in life after paying close attention to the financials of running the family brewing business (coal costs) and working with Manchester engineers Peter Ewart and Eaton Hodgkinson. His papers are based on observations and measurements of heat, force, cooling, etc based on comparing multiple engine design types .. at scale and with models.
- westurner 3y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33431427 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33431427 : > FWIU, heat engines are useful with all thermal gradients: pipes, engines, probably solar panels and attics; "MIT’s new heat engine beats a steam turbine in efficiency" (2022) https://www.freethink.com/environment/heat-engine https://www.freethink.com/environment/heat-engine "Thermophotovoltaic efficiency of 40%" (2022) https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-022-04473-y https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-022-04473-y https://scholar.google.com/scholar?cites=14197364440245631757&as_sdt=5,43&sciodt=0,43&hl=en https://scholar.google.com/scholar?cites=1419736444024563175... "Capturing Light From Heat at 40% Efficiency, NREL Makes Big Strides in Thermophotovoltaics" (2022) https://www.nrel.gov/news/program/2022/capturing-light-from-heat-at-40-percent-efficiency-nrel-makes-big-strides-in-thermophotovoltaics.html#:~:text=Careful%20Design%20Yields%20World%2DRecord,slightly%20different%20wavelengths%20of%20light https://www.nrel.gov/news/program/2022/capturing-light-from-.... : > The 41%-efficient TPV device is a tandem cell—a photovoltaic device built out of two light-absorbing layers stacked on top of each other and each optimized to absorb slightly different wavelengths of light. The team achieved this record efficiency through the usage of high-performance cells optimized to absorb higher-energy infrared light when compared to past TPV designs. This design builds on previous work from the NREL team. > Another crucial design feature leading to the high efficiency is a highly reflective gold mirror at the back of the cell. Much of the emitted infrared light has a longer (less energetic) wavelength than what the cell's active layers can absorb. This back surface reflector bounces 93% of that unabsorbed light back to the emitter, where it is reabsorbed and reemitted, improving the overall efficiency of the system. Further improvements to the reflectance of the back reflector could drive future TPV efficiencies close to or above 50%. Thermoelectric effect: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermoelectric_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermoelectric_effect Thermophotovoltaic energy conversion *: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermophotovoltaic_energy_conversion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermophotovoltaic_energy_conv... Thermophotonics: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermophotonics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermophotonics Gas turbine: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gas_turbine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gas_turbine : > gross thermal efficiency exceeds 60%. [100] (2011) GE-7HA https://www.ge.com/news/press-releases/ha-technology-now-available-industry-first-64-percent-efficiency https://www.ge.com/news/press-releases/ha-technology-now-ava... (2017) : > that its largest and most efficient gas turbine, the HA, is now available at more than 64 percent efficiency in combined cycle power plants, higher than any other competing technology today. How do TPV operating and lifecycle costs differ from gas turbine's costs?
- AtlasBarfed 3y agoThe good news is that even with those economics and of course a mountain of unfunded externalities from dumped CO2, Solar/wind are STILL cheaper than it, and there is runway for solar/wind to drop in price even more. Combined storage + solar/wind I believe is currently at LCOE parity with natural gas. With Sodium Ion batteries coming online for storage (no lithium, no cobalt, no nickel), the writing is on the wall for fossil fuels.