9 ms·
Apostrophe Protection Society
- kstrauser 3y agoOh wow, brace yourself for the flood of copy editors. Here it come's.
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 3y agoIts really not such a big deal.
- coldpie 3y agoI always suggest people who aren't good at apostrophe rules to just leave them out entirely. Better to seem lazy than wrong, I figure.
- kibwen 3y agoThe irony is that smartphone keyboards seem to randomly replace correct "it's"s with incorrect "it's"s, so it actually takes more work to appear lazy by going back and correcting them.
- xigoi 3y agoAuto-correct is trash. I don't understand why people use it.
- russellbeattie 3y agoThis is fantastic. I never noticed that's exactly how I interpret the total absence of appropriate punctuation. Bonus points if you ignore capitalization as well. I saw some guide to Zoomer communication recently which talked about how ... is perceived as "aggressive", which blew my mind. Better to just stick to lowercase letters. (Autocorrect makes this a pain though - I had to go back and fix the capitalization of "is" in the last sentence.)
- teddyh 3y agoA contrarian view: <https://angryflower.com/495.html https://angryflower.com/495.html>
- cantSpellSober 3y agoIn this case, saying "I emptied the trashcans trash" and there are multiple cans, wouldn't clearly indicate that I only emptied one vs all of them.
- teddyh 3y agoPer the link, the answer to your (and any) objection is “SILENCE!! OBEY!!!”.
- whoopdedo 3y agoWhich is a followup to https://angryflower.com/bobsqu.gif https://angryflower.com/bobsqu.gif
- teddyh 3y agoWhich is also available as a poster: <https://angryflower.com/aposter.html https://angryflower.com/aposter.html>
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y agoThe backtick`s better.
- mnw21cam 3y agoThis is most wonderfully lampooned by Terry Pratchett in Going Postal and Making Money. https://wiki.lspace.org/A._Parker_and_Son%27s https://wiki.lspace.org/A._Parker_and_Son%27s https://www.reddit.com/r/discworld/comments/tyyo47/one_of_my_very_favourite_discworld_jokes_from/ https://www.reddit.com/r/discworld/comments/tyyo47/one_of_my...
- AlbertCory 3y agoI want to hear the pronunciation difference between sons and son's.
- mnw21cam 3y agoThere's an audiobook version... Edit: And a TV version, apparently.
- kzrdude 3y agoI think there's a small difference in intonation
- drpixie 3y agoPerhaps ' is pronounced as a small tongue click?
- AlbertCory 3y agoLike in some African languages? I like it.
- easeout 3y agoWhat's the word for the vision equivalent of misophonia?
- AlbertCory 3y agoIt figures this is English. I sympathize, but I'm afraid that war's been lost. If I were to send in every example I see, it would be a full time job.
- yakubin 3y agothere’dn’t’ve https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CkZyZFa5qO0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CkZyZFa5qO0
- cantSpellSober 3y agoDoing god's work. There used to be a sign posted in a parking lot near me that said "METER'S TAKES QUARTER'S ONLY" that used to drive me nuts. Someone (likely an APS agent) even typed up a list of the grammatical errors made on the sign, and taped it to the bottom of it: https://i.imgur.com/y5ENADH.jpg https://i.imgur.com/y5ENADH.jpg Now we just need an agency to safeguard us against misusing "less" when "fewer" would be correct (like Avril Incandenza in Infinite Jest).
- jancsika 3y ago> There used to be a sign posted in a parking lot near me that said "METER'S TAKES QUARTER'S ONLY" that used to drive me nuts. Right, a meter's coin slot takes a quarter's unit of value. :)
- cantSpellSober 3y ago> a meter's There were multiple meters, the intent was to pluralize "meter." Which makes "takes" incorrect (vs "take"). Maybe I should get out more.
- dragonwriter 3y ago“Each meter’s..." Just a poor choice if which words to elide for space. :)
- cantSpellSober 3y agoPerhaps there was a single meter which only took dimes? :)
- dduugg 3y ago> Now we just need an agency to safeguard us against misusing "less" when "fewer" would be correct Genuinely curious, is this for pedantry, or does the word choice matter? Since the opposite of both is "more", why is there a need for a distinction in one direction and not the other?
- hlandau 3y agoI have an almost, but not quite, completely unrelated anecdote about this. I got on the internet in the early 2000s as a teenager, and would often be in various online chatrooms. Tricking people into visiting "shock sites" (most famously goatse.cx) seemed to be a common habit of certain denizens of these communities, either to people they didn't like or just because they thought it was funny. Somehow I managed to avoid ever falling victim to this, but there was one exception I recall, in which I was linked to a website purporting to be website of the "Apostrophe Protection Society". After only a moment some kind of JavaScript kicked in to instead change the contents of the page to some goatse.cx-style shock image which I don't recall. In other words, the "Apostrophe Protection Society" page just existed as a kind of bait-and-switch cover. I quickly closed the page, and ironically what I ended up remembering is not anything about the shock image but the notion of the "Apostrophe Protection Society". I think at the time I assumed that the notion of the "Apostrophe Protection Society" was intended to be part of the joke - that nobody would ever actually make such an organisation. I never bumped into that site again, but for heaven knows why (my memory is scary sometimes) I still remember the existence of this site pretending to be about an "Apostrophe Protection Society" (or some similar title). So, TIL it actually is real - and actually a legitimate organisation. Presumably whoever made the above website must have picked the website at random and copied its contents. Well, I hope this random anecdote about what the web used to be like is of interest to someone...
- fsckboy 3y ago>(most famously Goatse) No! speaking of lost punctuation marks, even more humorously goatse.cx it's pronounced "goatsex". get it? get the leet joke? the joke doesn't work if you misinterpret the semantic versioning "point" as a full stop. full stop.
- hlandau 3y agoFixed ;)
- caseyohara 3y agoFirst sentence from Wikipedia: "goatse.cx, often spelled without the .cx top-level domain as Goatse, was an internet domain that originally housed an Internet shock site."
- bobsmooth 3y agoI dont think theyre that important.
- joegahona 3y agoThe omission rules are what I see bungled most these days, as well as typographical things like the wrong version of the smart apostrophe appearing in the wrong place. Errors like "They want to outlaw Christian's" are easily avoidable; just stay away from Facebook comments.
- taylorbuley 3y agokill the curly quote
- cantSpellSober 3y agoIn favor of the neutral single quote (')? Are you using a typewriter?!
- fbdab103 3y agoWhen the name ends in an "s", you either add an apostrophe and "s" or just an apostrophe. - James's pen or James' pen - Mr Jones's van or Mr Jones' van Who accepts the first style? I thought this was a non-negotiable error. Edit: American
- kstrauser 3y agoI was taught the former. You'd pronounce the "'s" if you were speaking it, rather than saying "Mr Jones van" or "James pen".
- moribvndvs 3y agoI use s’ and it’s one of the more frequent corrections suggested to me, but that’s what was taught to me in grade and high school.
- ghaff 3y agoBoth AP (usually--unless the following word starts with an s) and Chicago prefer s-apostrophe-s for singular nouns. Though, on their website, Chicago seems fairly ambivalent about it. The bottom line is that a copyeditor may correct you but it's pretty far away from grammatical faux pas territory. (Personally I go with just s-apostrophe.)
- tom_ 3y agoThe rule is there to eliminate a 3rd -s noise. James's is fine. Moses's or Jesus's is less so (but you can do it if you want).
- LegibleCrimson 3y agoI only accept the first style, because I pronounce it "Jameses pen", not "James pen". If there are multiple choices and one more closely resembles the spoken language, I don't see any reason to save a written letter. Otherwise you have "James' pen" being pronounced "Jameses pen", but "the voters' choice" for some reason is not pronounced "the voterses choice". You end up with one specific circumstance where an apostrophe is actually pronounced, and I really don't like that. I'm also American.
- alecnotthompson 3y agoPeople care about the darnedest thing's
- philk10 3y agoMaybe by coincidence but a missing apostrophe was in the news today - https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/nov/17/hampshire-villagers-bring-streets-apostrophe-catastrophe-to-a-full-stop https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/nov/17/hampshire-vi...
- Freak_NL 3y agoProbably not a coincidence. I read that article today too; the submitter could very well have done that and went to the linked website afterwards.
- OscarCunningham 3y agoI like to interpret these kinds of names as though the word was a plural noun. Kings Cross: monarchs have to get to the other side of the road just like the rest of us. Herons Court: a description of avian mating behaviour. I don't think St Marys Terrace really works though.
- sowbug 3y agoRelated reading: https://begthequestion.info/ https://begthequestion.info/
- benrutter 3y agoI found it interesting to learn that possessive apostrophes are more or less an English language only thing. Possessive word endings ("Tomes pen") used to be a thing, but I guess got abbreviated so much (Tom's pen) they no longer exist.
- etothepii 3y agoThis is very interesting, do you have a source? In eats, shoots and leaves I recall the claim being made that apostrophes can be used for plurality with borrowed words. A particular example would thus be the "potato". Therefore, a so-called grocer's apostrophe to pluralise potato would be ok, while to pluralise turnip it would not. Similarly it was considered appropriate for pluralising numbers and days of the week. "There are fifty-two Wednesday's in a normal year." However, if the contraction argument were correct then "Tomes Pen" -> "Tom's Pen" could also allow "Potatoes" -> "Potato's"
- benrutter 3y agoI said it from memory, but googling looks like meriam webster has a nice article: https://www.merriam-webster.com/grammar/history-and-use-of-the-apostrophe https://www.merriam-webster.com/grammar/history-and-use-of-t...
- eszed 3y agoA professor of mine used to say that the original form (don't know what time period; he never explained that) was "Tom, his pen", so therefore the apostrophe still indicates elided characters. I don't know whether his example is correct, or yours, or both, but they're clearly pointing in the same direction.
- pge 3y agoSince English is a Germanic language, it seems more likely to me that the possessive ‘s’ is a carryover from the German genitive case. Pure speculation, but perhaps the apostrophe was added as case endings disappeared from English (except for the rare exceptions like who/whom)
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoRelated: John Richards, self-confessed pedant and founder of the Apostrophe Protection Society – obituary, 24 April 2021 https://www.telegraph.co.uk/obituaries/2021/04/24/john-richards-self-confessed-pedant-founder-apostrophe-protection/ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/obituaries/2021/04/24/john-richa...
- tragomaskhalos 3y agoIn the UK a misplaced apostrophe (in a plural or in possessive its) is called a "greengrocers' apostrophe", presumably due to folks in that trade being particularly susceptible to errors in their signs, in turn partially due to the slightly unusual nature of the nouns they are pluralising; "bananas" is slightly teasing you to stick one in, but "mangos" more so as just looks like a Greek island otherwise, unless you opt for the -oes form.
- crazygringo 3y agoHa. That makes sense, I wonder why or how that became a thing? It's the same case in the US -- you see it most in locally owned mom-and-pop style stores, especially ones that have been around for a while. It genuinely makes me wonder if it's out of ignorance, or if it's intentionally keeping a kind of old-school charm. "If apostrophes were good enough for my grandfather, they're good enough for me!" Of course, there's also a store local to me that has "&" on its big sign instead of "&", so I don't want to read in too much intention. (And you can tell it's not the kind of business that can afford to have a replacement sign made.)
- justincormack 3y agoFond of signs saying things like "sparrowgrass" at greengrocers or market stalls too.
- chrismorgan 3y agoThree on the page: > If you’re looking for guidance on the correct use of apostrophes, … > It's free, so why not join today! > Do please have a browse and see if there’s anything you want to purchase. I’m genuinely disappointed at this inconsistency: the first and third use curly quotes, the second uses straight quotes. They should pick one style (which, for such an organisation, should I think fairly clearly be the curly, unless they go bizarre and decide that U+0027 APOSTROPHE’s name is enough to warrant protecting it despite its inferiority to U+2019 RIGHT SINGLE QUOTATION MARK) and stick with it assiduously. They’ve also got a pair of double quotes on the quotation at the end, and they’re straight.
- cxr 3y agoI have to object to the recommendation to fix an error that results in a "corrected" form that reads > 1000s of bargains here! The problem with a sentence that says "1000's" isn't just the presence of the apostrophe. "1000" is not a substitute for the word "thousand". It means "one thousand". "1000s" therefore is a nonsense construction, apostrophe or not, unless you're talking about years or other number ranges. The same goes for "millions", etc, as well as "hundreds". (This doesn't apply to 10; "10s of thousands" is acceptable and correct.)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- readthenotes1 3y agoSo the Apostrophe Protection Society is the apostrophe's protection society?
- o11c 3y agoThe "use" page is missing several details, some important: * 1 The non-ASCII apostrophe is always ’, so programs that automatically insert smart quotes do the wrong thing for apostrophes at the start of a word. Some better examples IMHO: ’tis (it is), ’nuff (enough), ’cause (because), ’em (them), ’fraid (afraid), ’n’ (and), * 2 The "name ends with s" rule also applies to names ending with "x". * 3 is arguably just a special case of 2 (e.g. we can say "a holiday of two weeks"), but note that this is very similar to the attributive use (7) which never† uses the plural or an apostrophe but does use a hyphen (a two-week holiday). * 5 There are, in fact, grammatically-valid uses of "its’", when "it" is a noun rather than a pronoun. A non-derogatory example, in some variants of tag (the children's game), the its’ advantage increases over time. * 6 Whether apostrophes are used for plurals of non-words is a matter of style, not correctness. * 7, † Some apparent exceptions are due to words that are actually collective instead of plural for the particular use case. For example, "arms industry" is like "clothes industry". More often, people use errors and omit the required apostrophe. "farmers market" is an abomination.
- mminer237 3y agoTechnically, ’ isn't an apostrophe at all, but a right single quotation mark. I honestly thought this post was going to finally be some validation of my annoyance at everyone using the wrong Unicode character just because font makers make the apostrophe more “ugly”.
- geesh 3y agoAbsolutely not, the Unicode Standard explicitly states that U+2019 (’) RIGHT SINGLE QUOTATION MARK “is the preferred character to use for apostrophe”. You can see this in the code chart at https://www.unicode.org/charts/PDF/U2000.pdf https://www.unicode.org/charts/PDF/U2000.pdf and it is restated in section “Apostrophes”, 6.2 General Punctuation.
- mminer237 3y agoHuh, TIL. That's kind of annoying but good to know, thanks!
- kibwen 3y agoOn the other hand, given the marginal utility of the apostrophe (relative to, say, the comma or the parenthesis) as well as the fact that so many people seem to have a hard time keeping it straight, Im tempted to conclude thats evidence that we should just get rid of it outright.
- gwbas1c 3y agoFYI: The translucent background on the text makes https://www.apostrophe.org.uk/apostrophe-use https://www.apostrophe.org.uk/apostrophe-use hard to read. Perhaps bump up the opacity one more notch?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gavinhoward 3y agoSort of OT, but the list of uses (https://www.apostrophe.org.uk/apostrophe-use https://www.apostrophe.org.uk/apostrophe-use) matches what I do except for "6. Apostrophes are NEVER used to denote plurals!" I was taught that for numbers and acronyms, you do use apostrophes. Was anyone else taught that? Or am I the only one?
- owlstuffing 3y agoWho taught you that? It is not proper use. I cringe when I see ABC’s and 123’s. Worse than fingernails on the chalkboard.
- gavinhoward 3y agoFunny, because I feel the exact opposite. And the answer is every English teacher I had growing up.
- hollerith 3y ago>every English teacher I had growing up. I doubt that.
- gavinhoward 3y agoWell, there were some that didn't talk about it, but the ones that did all said the same thing.
- hollerith 3y agoHuh. All the style manuals were saying something quite different last time I checked. Strange!
- thaumasiotes 3y agoIn modern use it is apparently common to write e.g. 40ties or 90ties. I'm not sure what the thinking is, or why 40s or 90s aren't "enough".
- Vinnl 3y agoHeh, I have two related pet peeves. The first is kinda the opposite of this website's problem: people using apostrophes to denote possession in Dutch. That's supposed to be wrong, but people have adopted it from English. (Though supposedly, it was also already fairly widespread before English was. I'm also not so sure whether it can realistically be considered wrong nowadays, given its prevalence.) The other is should've. That's a contraction, and the original is should have, not should of. Funnily enough this is a mistake no Dutch person (or non-native speaker in general, I think) makes, but I see it a lot online. And finally, I wonder how many mistakes I made in this comment
- arp242 3y agoConversely, a lot of Dutch people use apostrophes for plurals in English, probably more so than the average non-native speaker, because that's considered correct in Dutch. Mixing languages is hard. I've lived abroad for a few years I can no longer tell the time in Dutch. Does "half two" mean "half past two" (14:30) or "half of two" (13:30)? From where I'm sitting now, I'm genuinely not sure; in (British) English it's usually the latter, although that's confusing as well because Americans usually mean the former (or was it the reverse?) Maybe I'm just stupid – I've never been able to recite the alphabet either (always get confused somewhere after O/P).
- Vinnl 3y agoFor plurals in Dutch it's only correct if the pronunciation of the letter before the s would change, I believe, whereas English just changes the spelling. So in Dutch it's baby's, in English babies, but both say computers. But yeah, I think it's just compensation because people have memorised that English uses more apostrophes than Dutch. I can tell the time in Dutch, but having to switch between British and American English makes that I indeed have no idea which interpretation of half two is correct when. I just make sure to say half past two.
- technothrasher 3y agoI was ranting one day a few years ago at work about all the laminated signs such as "clean your dishes" or "flush the toilet" around and why they were useless at actually altering behavior. I came in the next day and one of my co-workers had had the great idea to stick a laminated sign in my lab that said, "Do not place lamanated sign's in this lab". I have left it up to this day because of the misspelling and misuse of the apostrophe, it always makes me laugh.
- olddustytrail 3y agoThat's very Fight Club
- pseingatl 3y agoHow an Apostrophe Almost Landed Me in Jail: https://mu7ami.micro.blog/2023/01/02/how-an-apostrophe.html https://mu7ami.micro.blog/2023/01/02/how-an-apostrophe.html
- arp242 3y agoI don't get why people get all bothered by this kind of stuff. The reason people make these mistakes is because it's all pronounced exactly the same, and no one is confused by what "It's wrong" and "Its wrong" means, when pronounced or when written. The "Correct Use of the Apostrophe in the English Language" page claims that the rules are "very simple". If they're that simple then why do you need 8 bullet-points and five screens of text to explain these "very simple" rules? I wish people were more relaxed about this kind of thing. Just accept "its" and "it's" as correct, and "Two week's time" and "Two weeks' time", etc. No one gets confused by this sort of thing. Our brains are geared towards spoken language, not written language. My main take-aware from this is that we should change the spelling to be less error-prone, or just accept both as correct. The problem is with the spelling, not the people.
- easeout 3y agoThe problem is not that it's confusing but that, because the rules exist and set our expectations, we mentally trip over violations of them. We stop absorbing what was intended to be communicated and have to back up and try again. I don't disagree that changing the rules would solve this, but we haven't done that. So in individual instances of written communication which each of us does have the power to affect, it's on the writer to ensure the reader has no unnecessary trouble. I could wear boots inside your house, but I'd rather you clean up the Lego.
- arp242 3y agoYou're only bothered by it if you let yourself be bothered by it. "Mentally tripping over it" is something entirely within your own control. Unlike some other languages the English language doesn't even have "official rules"; it's a loose consensus of the speakers of the language (i.e. you and me). You can quite literally set your own rules.
- easeout 3y agoOK, but I notice you're still using apostrophes in all their accepted right places, and I assume that's because you intend to accommodate me and other readers who haven't discarded the rules and would still trip. Earnestly, thank you, and please keep it up, because unless new rules emerge (whether official or just usage), we'll continue to be tripped up when the existing scheme isn't followed. I customize more than enough things in my life for the sake of "better". It's not worth the tradeoff to deviate and be the pioneer every time. Some things you gotta run stock because compatibility is a major benefit.
- damiante 3y ago>It's free, so why not join today! Evidently their passion for punctuation does not extend to the question mark.
- xigoi 3y ago> Depending on the context, a rhetorical question can end in a question mark or an exclamation mark. https://www.stylemanual.gov.au/grammar-punctuation-and-conventions/punctuation-and-capitalisation/question-marks#rhetorical_questions_end_in_a_question_mark_or_exclamation_mark https://www.stylemanual.gov.au/grammar-punctuation-and-conve...
- karaterobot 3y agoDespite the best efforts of the APS, I have to assume syntax and style guides will have to just update their rules eventually, rather than everyone else learning to do it their way. Language evolves by knuckleheads making mistakes so often they become standard usage. The realization of that fact offended me, until I realized the snapshot of the language I thought was so precious was also the result of that same process of gradual knuckleheadification. Instead, it just terrifies me now, knowing it's been rule by knuckleheads all the way back into the misty dawn of mankind.
- appplication 3y agoThe only rule that never changes is that all the rules are subject to change. We’re just flying along on our temperate little rock fighting wars and dying on our hills about the rules that were never rules at all.
- LorenDB 3y agoAt one point, my local dump featured a sign that read, among other things, "No Mattresse's".
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoReminds me of this old comic: https://www.angryflower.com/247.html https://www.angryflower.com/247.html
- eru 3y agoBtw, using an apostrophe to mark possessives in English is a fairly newfangled affection. So, it started off as 'wrong' not too long ago.
- Xorakios 3y agooh golly don't get us started on "wrong" denoting morality vs incorrect/inaccurate/imprecise!
- fruit2020 3y agoNon english speaker here. One use which I’ve encountered recently and seems off to me, is when people say something like: I’ve apples in my bag. Is this correct? I’ve grown up using ‘ve only for shortening the past perfect (or whatever verb form is that, excuse my grammar, school was a long time ago)
- Hemospectrum 3y agoIt's a regional thing. Common in Britain, but sounds strange to Americans, and looks even stranger in writing. Not sure about other parts of the anglosphere.
- n8cpdx 3y agoWhere? Reads UK english to me, I’ve never heard that in the US. I googled and the internet seems to agree with me. https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/8/is-it-appropriate-to-use-short-form-of-have-ve-when-it-means-possession#29 https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/8/is-it-appropri...
- timthorn 3y agoYes, it is correct: "I have apples in my bag"
- hubbins 3y agoI have an Irish name, such as O’Donnell, and even in 2023 it’s not unusual for a web site to say “Invalid last name” when entered. Like it’s 1996 and I’m doing a SQL injection attack.
- snypher 3y agoI've seen my name show as eg O#&36;Donnell. Thinking of changing it to droptables.