4 ms·
> Manufacturing in the US will never be as good as china. There's a very entertaining book called "Poorly Made in China" that will quickly disabuse you of such
by matheusmoreira 3y ago
> Manufacturing in the US will never be as good as china.
There's a very entertaining book called "Poorly Made in China" that will quickly disabuse you of such notions.
- corethree 3y agoSummarize the findings here and cite the actual evidence if you can. Throwing a random book recommendation that I have to purchase to read is something that just doesn't move the conversational needle if you know what I mean.
- discard124 3y agoHow about you go first. You didn’t even provide a book recommendation to support your claim.
- corethree 3y agoNo I provided reasoning. Better to provide reasoning then cite some reasoning that can't be read because I'm not going to spend money to buy a book.
- discard124 3y agoActually you didn't provide any reasoning. You just made a statement without any supporting logic.
- corethree 3y agoStatements are reasoning. You can't transfer logical information without making a statement. Anything is better then a link that can't be read. That offers nothing it's even lower then just a "statement" This is getting into combative territory here. We both need to end it.
- discard124 3y agoI see nothing combative here, and nobody is forcing you to write replies you don’t want to. I disagree that simply making a naked claim is ‘reasoning’. “The moon is made of cheese.” is a statement, but isn’t reasoning. Here’s a link to a book you can’t read: https://www.amazon.com/Views-Moon-Reviews-Mineralogy-Geochemistry/dp/0939950723/ref=sr_1_3?crid=GJG31V4QRNI7&keywords=Moon+geology&qid=1700243908&sprefix=moon+geology%2Caps%2C224&sr=8-3&ufe=app_do%3Aamzn1.fos.17d9e15d-4e43-4581-b373-0e5c1a776d5d https://www.amazon.com/Views-Moon-Reviews-Mineralogy-Geochem... I think it’s fairly clear which is more valuable if you want to know about the composition of the moon. Similarly, the linked book is clearly more valuable than your unsubstantiated statement about US manufacturing.
- corethree 3y ago>I see nothing combative here, and nobody is forcing you to write replies you don’t want to. I disagree that simply making a naked claim is ‘reasoning’. This is false. Read what you wrote: >Actually you didn't provide any reasoning. You just made a statement without any supporting logic. This is just rude. And you know it. You're just trolling now. I literally said not to post book links and you just did. I'm ending this thread. I don't appreciate statements like this.
- saturn8601 3y agoWhile its a great book, its really just a tour of the tactics used by Chinese manufacturers to gain the upper hand. It does not definitely prove that Chinese manufacturing capability is inferior, just that they have a mindset of squeezing every last drop of blood out of you and have many strategies to do so. And to be fair, Bernie was really squeezing what he wanted from his manufacturer. Overall the whole business relationship was miserable on both sides and probably shouldn't have happened but how else do you expect Chinese companies to get the business in the first place? Its clearly backfiring these days since now some of the largest markets(US, & EU) are taking their ball and going home.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- matheusmoreira 3y ago> they have a mindset of squeezing every last drop of blood out of you and have many strategies to do so Yeah. Even leaving the untrustworthiness aside, among those strategies is quality manipulation. Steel, for example: first batches are good, then they'll gradually tamper with the chemistry without anyone noticing, pocket the money, pass the risk along to the westerners and nobody knows or cares until somebody dies because a scaffolding collapsed or something. There's a steel industry in my city, it doesn't do stuff like this and it can't compete with chinese steel even with import taxes.
- saturn8601 3y agoI wonder if this occurs less often if you are providing a good deal to the Chinese side. Like I mentioned, the main character in the book: Bernie really seemed like he was squeezing his Chinese supplier hard. I gathered that they were making no margins on his deal but took his business so that they could get him into China and then make up the margin with these tricks. Would this have happened if he had just considered the other side's POV?
- matheusmoreira 3y ago