4 ms·
if this is what passes for 'academic rigour, journalistic flair' > Their batteries make them heavier than a traditional car, and draw heavily on the extraction
by kragen 3y ago
if this is what passes for 'academic rigour, journalistic flair'
> Their batteries make them heavier than a traditional car, and draw heavily on the extraction of rare earth elements
i think your academy is a diploma mill
quoting https://www.sneci.com/blog/are-rare-earths-an-issue-in-the-production-of-ev-batteries/ https://www.sneci.com/blog/are-rare-earths-an-issue-in-the-p... which actually does have something resembling academic rigor
> 15 years ago, the first hybrid vehicles, notably the Toyota Prius and the Honda, were equipped with NiMH (Nickel Metal Hydride) batteries whose negative electrode (anode) was made of a lanthanum-pentanickel alloy (LaNi₅).
> These batteries in the first generation of hybrid vehicles contained about ten kilos of lanthanum, which is a rare earth.
> However, today this battery technology has been replaced by the family of lithium-ion (Li-ion) batteries with much higher performance.
> While some Toyota hybrids sold in Europe are still equipped with NiMH batteries, the vast majority of hybrid and electric vehicles today are equipped with Li-ion batteries… which do not contain rare earths.
> Of course, they contain lithium, cobalt and nickel, but as mentioned above, these metals are not rare earths and do not pose the same problems.
most of the rest of the article explains why rare earths are a red herring and the historical background on why people were concerned about them 15 years ago
> In short, rare earths are not rare at all, the world’s reserves are large, well distributed in the 5 continents and no shortage is to be feared for a long time.
- cogman10 3y agoYup, lots of anti-battery stuff is propaganda pretending like we still drive around with NiCd batteries. Even the weight argument is wrong! A model Y weighs up to 4,555 lbs. A Ford edge weighs up to 4520 lbs. As it turns out, ICE are really super heavy. Strip that out and have a steadily increasing battery density as we've seen over the years and it really won't be long before EVs are in fact lighter than ICE counterparts (and certainly lighter than hybrids). These articles are all written with anecdotes from 2000.
- tomtheelder 3y agoThe weight thing is absolutely real. You can’t just compare two completely different cars! Equivalent models usually gain a few hundred pounds in the EV version.
- cogman10 3y agoThe ford edge is the same class of car as a Tesla model y. They are, in fact, the same dimensions (off by and inch or two). I chose it specifically because it's an equivalent model. If you want to complain, you should be pointing out the fact that I used the model y, which is (currently) best in class for EV weight. That's primarily due to Tesla's use of the battery as a structural component. Equivalent cars from the same companies are often gaining hundreds of pounds (or more) because they are using the same platform as their ICE counterparts rather than using a more obvious skateboard design. The older ford focus being one of the worst examples of this.
- jxcl 3y agoIt's worth noting that Cobalt is now the problem element for BEVs [1], though there is a lot of work that is being done and has been done to reduce the amount of cobalt in Lithium Ion batteries. [1]: https://apnews.com/article/congo-mining-human-rights-73b3edcc2d485d07281db34dc3dcad2c https://apnews.com/article/congo-mining-human-rights-73b3edc...