5 ms·
Apple files legal challenge to EU's Digital Markets Act
- seec 3y agoTotally expected nonsense from current greedy psychopathic Apple. They are absolutely gatekeepers and have an absolutely unreasonable amount of control on devices they are not supposed to own anymore because people bought them. I think they also should look into their behavior of forcing update, in order to make devices obsolete earlier by making them run slower even though they worked completely fine for everything that was required of them. I thought it was conspiracy theories but right now, just after the annual release and just after a mysterious new update with little information on what it is supposed to fix; my iPhone 12 Mini is starting to seriously lag both in Apple apps and 3rd party apps. Thats a very disturbing coincidence, especially since it's not the first time it has happened. By the way I am still on "old" iOS 16.7.2 because I don't trust Apple release anymore. In fact, if I could, I would go back to the iOS the iPhone was sold with; but you can't because Apple is selling their update bullshit narrative in their marketing. From where I sit there are a lot more cons than pros for the average user...
- anonymouse008 3y agoGood. Where’s the filing though to see the reasoning?
- dhimes 3y agoApparently it's not public yet.
- grishka 3y agoI'm 99% sure it's their usual BS about "security" and "safety".
- fmajid 3y agoMost likely they will attack the EU's definition of the relevant market as being "iOS App Store" and claim they only have a sliver of the larger "Mobile app store" market, even though iOS and Android apps are not substitutes for one another. How you define the market is usually the crux of antitrust battles. The European legal system has not been captured like the US was by Robert Bork (yes, that Robert Bork) and the Chicago School (dogma: monopolies are a logical impossibility because markets are infallible). Thus this will likely only stall for a few months, I'm sure Apple knows that, but it's a few more months of those juicy App Store margins that are so essential to Apple's financials under the "Services" rubric.
- jncfhnb 3y agoI hope we see this act cut billions out of these platform rent seekers bottom lines
- pb7 3y agoWhy?
- smoldesu 3y agoFor one, it would return us to the status-quo where the user decides what to install on the hardware they own. That seems pretty important to me, even if you hate Europe or Apple.
- tinus_hn 3y agoIf only there were hardware where you could install whatever you want. If only that hardware had a very large majority market share in the EU. Ah. One can dream.
- smoldesu 3y agoWell, now it will be the only market in Europe. Apple is welcome to leave if they disagree.
- Kim_Bruning 3y agoThat would be nice, wouldn't it? I have a feeling the majority market share may have shifted a bit since 1999. (edit: I mean from PC to IOS and Android)
- realusername 3y agoLike what? The Nokia N900 or the Pinephone? There's never been any realistic choice to make.
- ribosometronome 3y ago
- clever-leap 3y ago[flagged]
- t43562 3y agoThe other way to look at it is that the EU isn't in thrall to big tech companies and the world is lucky that there's somewhere that their power doesn't reach. The US has many reasons NOT to limit the power of companies that employ Americans and help balance the trade deficit.
- thedaly 3y ago> The other way to look at it is that the EU isn't in thrall to big tech companies and the world is lucky that there's somewhere that their power doesn't reach. I'm inclined to agree when you look at things like privacy regulation/GDPR, but the recent draft legislation that weakens encryption leaves me doubting their ability to regulate.
- shortcake27 3y agoI really don’t understand why it’s taking so long to recognise Apple/Google as a monopoly. I develop internal apps for small companies. Apple still forces each update - to an unlisted app - to go through a review process. Google on the other hand have just told me they need to collect my address, phone number, and ID documents next year or they will delete my developer account. I shouldn’t have to jump through hoops, wait weeks for reviews, and have my personal data collected & sold, because I distribute private software to people who use one of the two vendors that make up 99.99% of the market. “Ohh it’s not a monopoly because your clients could just carry around a lenovo running linux instead of a mobile phone”. How is this argument still passing the bar?
- etchalon 3y agoWell, the word "mono" generally means, "one". Apple/Google are a duopoly, and at least in the US, being a duopoly is legally fine so long as you don't collude on pricing.
- downWidOutaFite 3y agoMaybe we should change that law.
- RandomLensman 3y agoDepends how you view them. If you consider them to be each rather separate ecosystems with limited exchange between them, they could perhaps be two monopolies?
- kemayo 3y agoI'm unconvinced by the argument that "iPhone apps" and "Android apps" are the relevant categories, rather than just "smartphone apps". It seems like it leads to a slippery slope where every company that's not selling in a completely-generic category holds a monopoly over its own products. Ford holding a monopoly over F-150 pickup trucks, etc.
- 3y ago
- mrtksn 3y agoIMHO Apple will thank EU for this because Digital Markets Act will save Apple from itself. I'm a huge Apple fanboy and I'm happy with the walled garden HOWEVER Apple begun engaging in rent seeking and missing out on innovation and I really, really want Apple to succeed because they are the tech company that cares about user experience over false metrics like megapixels and screen to body ratio. Apple's rent seeking on NFC already causes me bad user experience because when I'm not somewhere where Apple Pay is supported, I miss out on banking apps that support NFC. Also, governments(UK, EU, USA - all of them) are eager to turn the tech companies into a police and there's a war in Europe and political turmoil all over the world where you and hundreds of millions are at risk of falling at the wrong side of the aggressive dominant political movements. I'm sure Tim Cook and anybody at Apple wouldn't want to be the tech suppliers who helped governments to enforce policies that some time in the future might be viewed just as badly as the German policies around 1940s. At this very moment, Apple might believe that they are on the right side of the history but what happens if Trump wins in a year? What happens if the far right in EU begins dominating the politics? They are angry and they want vengeance, they go after people all the time. Maybe Apple was able to say F.U. to the UK and said it will not implement spying into its iMessage&Facetime services and leave UK if they have to but can they do the same in USA for example? Can Apple say no to Trump admin and leave the US markets if they decide to ban encryption so they can hunt down the "enemies of the state" and "dry the swamp". Very dangerous times, no company should be in position to become the police.
- seec 3y agoI understand where you come from, but I believe it is way too late for that. I used to be an Apple "fanboy", way more moderate than the term suggests but up until 2016-2017 I thought their approach made more sense and was seeking the best compromise possible. But now they are too far gone in the money making, empire building side. I believe the culture that built the Apple we loved is completely dead now and all the people that were the keepers of that have either moved out themselves or got pushed out by management to make way for the new culture of ultra greed rent seeking. I think it is naive to believe we can go back to what Apple was. It is a shell of itself and even the hardware products are somewhat nice but feel very bland and uninspired for the price (they also have a lot of performance/durability problems because of cost cutting, margin chasing). And this time there is not Steve Jobs to come back. In my opinion it is better to see the objective truth, cut your losses and move on to another cheaper and more open platform. There is not much to expect from Apple, it's all downhill from here...
- dostick 3y agoChallenging the law makes Apple look like they know better which laws should be obeyed.like they consider themselves as ultimate authority on any question..