8 ms·
FCC Is Trying to Stop Discrimination in Broadband Deployment. Telecoms Are Mad
- mikewarot 3y agoFiber to everyone's home in the US was already paid for, it's obscene that cable internet with usage caps is a thing in urban and suburban areas. We need a repeat of the rural electrification act, but with regulatory teeth.
- appleskeptic 3y agoThe FCC admits they could not identify any intentional discrimination.[1] So they went further and adopted a "disparate impact" standard which means you don't even need to intend to discriminate. And unlike disparate impact in other areas of law, where having a "legitimate non-discriminatory interest" is a defense, the only defense here will be "economic or technical infeasibility," and they explicitly rejected profit maximization as a way to satisfy that standard. So say you're an ISP deciding whether to invest the same money into building fiber out to one of two areas, one where you'll make 1 million dollars a year and one where you'll take 2 million a year, and you make the rational decision to build out to the more profitable area. The FCC can fine you for that because it turns out the less profitable area was more black and the more profitable area more white, and it was economically feasible for you to make less profit, even though racial factors had nothing to do with your decision. If you think through the implications of this, it's a requirement to engage in discrimination/affirmative action in every single business decision you make. And even then, it's impossible to know whether you're ever in compliance. How much profit do you have to sacrifice in pursuit of racial equity? A quarter? Half? Two-thirds? [1] "As noted above, there is little or no evidence in the legislative history of the Infrastructure Act or the record of this proceeding that impediments to broadband internet access service are the result of intentional discrimination based on the criteria set forth in the statute." https://docs.fcc.gov/public/attachments/DOC-397997A1.pdf https://docs.fcc.gov/public/attachments/DOC-397997A1.pdf Paragraph 47
- jpalawaga 3y agodidn't ISPs take massive subsidies to build out that less-profitable infrastructure? seems fair that they, you know, build it.
- dolni 3y agoIf you wanna go down that road, compel them to build the infrastructure where it was promised. Or issue a fine for the amount they were given, plus interest. We don't need to play silly "affirmative action" games to keep them accountable.
- Chabsff 3y agoWhile I broadly agree with you at surface level, you are missing a piece of the puzzle. The issue is that FCC is, correctly, treating broadband as a utility at a level comparable to electricity/sewer/drinkable water. And as such, ensuring that underserved people get access to the service is more important than punishing contractors for failing to deliver it. I do agree that the discrimination hand-wringing is unnecessary, and a good "Deliver the service to everyone, assholes" should be plenty in theory. But if leaning on those laws is what it takes to get them to comply, then whatever. Results are what matters.
- dolni 3y agoEven from the "underserved people" standpoint, most of the people who have shit-tier internet are people living in very rural areas (read: overwhelmingly white). There is no valid reason to turn this into yet another performative piece of race-bait.
- parineum 3y agoThey sure did and there were no strings attached to that money. That's not their fault. This would be a bizarre and circuitous way to attempt the recover from that mistake.
- 3y ago
- Eumenes 3y ago[flagged]
- exabrial 3y agoThis has nothing to do with discrimination, per the FCC. Crappy time to be alive in the USA, where a private business can be forced by the federal government to do something against their will.
- 542458 3y agoI don't follow. The federal government has effectively always forced businesses to do things, such as paying taxes. Furthermore, the businesses in question agreed to build this infrastructure in exchange for funding and government protection, an obligation that they have failed to uphold their end of the deal on.
- crazygringo 3y ago> where a private business can be forced by the federal government to do something against their will. Like fulfill their side of the bargain in exchange for already-received subsidies and tax breaks...?
- vel0city 3y agoAnd its not even just subsidies and tax breaks. They also often own the utility poles or conduits and can often restrict/delay attachments preventing any competition from actually rolling out in the area. And that's assuming they don't have a monopoly franchise agreement for the area! If they don't want to serve everyone in the community, they need to give up rights to have any say over utility corridors and any franchise agreements.
- dml2135 3y agoThese are utilities we are talking about, not your local bodega.
- banannaise 3y agoIf you're running a utility, it is your responsibility to serve all customers. The water company can't refuse to build pipes in a poor neighborhood. Private ownership of that utility doesn't remove that responsibility. If they don't like it, I'm sure we would be happy to nationalize them.
- tbrownaw 3y agoThis sounds like it's saying that ISPs aren't following existing universal access rules where it's not profitable, so those rules are being restructured to look at things through the lens of race and "disparate impact" to see if maybe that'll help?
- netbioserror 3y agoIt still bamboozles me that tech journalism is acting as the PR arm of the government and failing a basic "misleading name" test. I can't wait for them to do apologetic retrospectives on the Patriot Act informing me that mass surveillance is, in fact, patriotic.
- Eumenes 3y agoThey think they'll get a job in a future regime ... I suspect press/communications czar is a title alot of tech "journalists" have dreamed about since they were on the high school paper. You don't get that job being critical of the government. You think Seymour Hersh would take a gig with George W, Trump, or Obama?
- Mountain_Skies 3y agoThat might be their way of thinking but sometimes things go in the other direction. The most critical voice against the city government where I lived in the early 2010s got hired by the mayor to become a "special advisor". That shut her up completely. Instead of scathing columns about government corruption, she put out the occasional press release for the mayor over his two terms. IIRC, there was a similar storyline in the tv show 'Spin City', which makes me think it is a somewhat common thing to happen.
- tbrownaw 3y agoIt's not just tech journalism.
- shin_lao 3y agoDon't think it is constitutional.
- chmod600 3y ago"The FCC Is Trying To Stop Discrimination In Broadband Deployment. Telecoms Are Mad" That title could be more neutral.
- ipsin 3y agoI'm really surprised at the number of people on the side of the telecoms here. I think it's reasonable to want consistent pricing and quality of service, particularly in cities. Redlining doesn't have to be because of racism or classism, but the result is the same. There are underserved populations that can't get better internet, even if they want it. Isn't fixing that a reasonable policy goal? If we can't get it from companies, I'd be down to treat the internet the same way we treated rural electrification & phone service. That is, setting a high standard and deploying it to everyone. No more multi-billion dollar giveaways with no consequences for delivery. If we aren't getting results, fund municipal broadband and other schemes.
- zmgsabst 3y agoPeople are objecting to racializing business decisions: that’s a reasonable and laudable goal. If we want to address “underserved populations that can't get better internet”, we can do that directly without adding racism.
- kayodelycaon 3y ago“Protected classes” already exist and have been tested in courts. It’s a lot easier to use that than to come up with completely different criteria businesses will find loopholes in or create loopholes through lobbying. Personally I don’t like that our best option is to use protected classes to enforce better behavior. But most of the time it’s a good equivalent, and it’s a good example of those nasty compromises that allow democracies to work effectively.
- appleskeptic 3y agoThere's a big difference between banning discrimination against protected classes and mandating discrimination in their favor, which is what this basically does, see the comment and discussion here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38304639 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38304639
- deleted 3y ago
- lexicality 3y agoI'm confused as to why the comments are getting so heated on this, typically I see people complaining that the USA has very inconsistent and bad broadband, with people being forced to switch to satellite services to get any kind of reasonable connectivity. Could someone explain to me why forcing the broadband companies to provide better service isn't a net positive action please?
- omginternets 3y agoMaybe read the dissenting comments? Some of these are rather articulate.
- zmgsabst 3y agoThis is forcing telecoms to make business decisions with a racialized lens, ie rebuilding systemic racism. People are objecting to that. If we want to help (as another commenter put it) “underserved populations that can't get better internet” — we should do that directly, for people of all races. How does mandating racialized thinking help that problem?
- lexicality 3y agoI have now read the PDF and struggle to understand how you've come to that conclusion. Could you point me at where in the PDF it mandates that ISPs make their decisions based on only the race of the customers?
- Spivak 3y agoYou do have to actually acknowledge that classes of people exist to know whether systematic biases exist between them. Why would you hide pieces of data with an extremely high degree of predictive power? Surely more sunlight is better? It doesn't have to come with any judgement, no one is saying look at these blatantly racist telecoms clearly they hate... checks notes the Vietnamese, but instead, "hey your policy of where you decide to roll out internet has a blind spot." How do you know if the track you're on is inadvertently disadvantaging particular populations if you never look? > we should do that directly, for people of all races And this bill does that, you seem to be arguing for the exact same effect but just worded differently. If you require everything be equal then a rising tide for inner city black folks also comes with a rising tide for rural white folks. It means that a person of arbitrary demographic makeup can be sure that better internet will come to them which is all people all races.
- a1o 3y agoWhy side with the Telecoms? Their service is terrible and they have state sponsored monopoly. That is not a healthy market.
- tempodox 3y agoLacking regulation combined with a monopoly position will naturally produce the worst abuses.
- AlgorithmicTime 3y ago[dead]
- fwungy 3y ago[flagged]
- hackermeows 3y agoI'm currently in the process of buying a house in a major U.S. city, ideally located near a school and in the heart of the city. However, The house, despite its central location, only has access to a 4-7 Mbps max speed CenturyLink twisted pair connection, which is astonishingly slow. My attempts to resolve this issue have led me into a frustrating loop between ISPs. When I contacted Comcast, hoping for a better service, they informed me that it was CenturyLink's territory and they couldn't provide a connection. However, when I reached out to CenturyLink, they countered by saying it was actually Comcast’s area for broadband service. It's bewildering to me that in 2023, in a major U.S. city, there are still areas where you can't get a decent broadband internet connection. To provide some context, this area was an old red-lined district, which has recently been gentrified, partly due to the tech boom in the city. Had to give up on a perfectly good house that my partner and i loved because of this
- appleskeptic 3y agoStarlink is probably your best bet for now, which is ~100/~20 depending on your area. I believe you can also multi-home two (or more) Starlink services and get double (or triple etc.) that.
- kelnos 3y agoYep. I live in San Francisco, one block away from a major fiber trunk, and my "best" option for broadband is cable Internet from Comcast. Right now the max upload they offer is 35Mbps, even with their 1.2Gbps download tier. It's absolute garbage. The only positive is I'm not limited to something even more useless in the download side like you are.
- devaiops9001 3y agohttps://www.monkeybrains.net/ https://www.monkeybrains.net/ probably can help you.
- atlgator 3y agoThe article mischaracterizes the FCC's position. The Biden Administration is pushing this agenda, not the agency. In fact, the Commissioner of the FCC is ardently against it [0]. [0] https://docs.fcc.gov/public/attachments/DOC-398244A1.pdf https://docs.fcc.gov/public/attachments/DOC-398244A1.pdf
- enragedcacti 3y agoAh yes, THE commissioner. The one single commissioner that the FCC has. Anyone who says there are 5 commissioners, three of whom are democrats, are just trying to deny Mr. Carr's supreme authority.
- nerdponx 3y agoSide note, but let's all take the time to appreciate that the FCC publishes plain-text versions alongside DOCX and PDF. I really appreciated the ability to get right to the text.
- enragedcacti 3y agoI think a lot of comments are missing a crucial aspect of the situation, which is that the same law that empowered the FCC to do this also allocated $42 billion in grant money to assist Telecoms in rolling out to "high cost" areas. The government is forcing a private business to consider discrimination in decisions about where to roll out, but they simultaneously have created a scheme to compensate them for doing so. In that light, hand wringing about the effects on Telco profits doesn't really make much sense to me. It's like a child saying that their parents aren't feeding them by citing the "you can't have ice cream" of the sentence "you can't have ice cream until you finish your dinner".
- alexb_ 3y agoThe biggest politician on the side of the telecoms is Ted Cruz, who has this to say on the matter: > Despite admitting there's 'little to no evidence' of discrimination by telecommunications companies, Democrats are hoping to convince the American people that broadband Internet is so racist they need to plow ahead with government-mandated affirmative action and race-based pricing. The only beneficiaries of this Orwellian 'equity' plan are overzealous government regulators who want to control the Internet
- hn_acker 3y agoHere's more about Ted Cruz from Karl Bode on Techdirt. > We’ve also noted how Republicans voted against the infrastructure bill, then have turned immediately around to take credit for the broadband deployments it enables among local constituents. Texas Senator Ted Cruz has been no exception; he’s repeatedly tried to take credit for highway projects only made possible by the infrastructure bill, while simultaneously criticizing the bill’s very existence. ... > If there’s a real problem with BEAD and other federal subsidy programs, it’s that giants like AT&T and Comcast — with long histories of taking taxpayer money for projects they half-complete — will almost certainly nab a disproportionate amount of funding using unreliable maps whose improvement they’ve long opposed. But Cruz doesn’t mention — or care about — that. > Cruz is silent when a Texas-based company like AT&T gets a $42 billion tax break for doing absolutely nothing. He’ll routinely have nothing to say if AT&T is accused of ripping off taxpayers and the nation’s school system. [1] https://www.techdirt.com/2023/09/19/senator-ted-cruz-pretends-to-care-about-wasteful-broadband-subsidies/ https://www.techdirt.com/2023/09/19/senator-ted-cruz-pretend...
- RevEng 3y agoUp here in Saskatchewan, Canada, we have a crown corporation that provides broadband access to the entire province. The legislature has mandated that they provide access to a very large portion (90? , 95?) of the population. They are treated as a utility, so maximizing profits is not the benchmark, but rather providing a reasonable level of access and ability at the lowest cost. There's no mention made of race, wealth, or any other demographic. They simply need to make sure everybody* has broadband Internet access. This simple metric works wonders. Whether rich urban areas or tiny rural communities, nearly everyone has adequate broadband access. The speeds aren't equal everywhere, but the minimum levels of service are enough for video streaming, so the minimum standard is plenty to give everyone an ability to participate in our online society. Part of providing this access also includes reasonable pricing. Again, less dense areas aren't always as cheap as the most dense areas, but the difference isn't much. Even in poor, remote communities, you can afford to use a mobile phone with adequate broadband capability. This price equality despite cost inequality does mean that technically the more dense areas are partially subsidizing the less dense areas, but again, the differences aren't that large. We still have private broadband providers in the dense urban areas and their rates aren't much cheaper. What they could save on costs, they continue to charge anyway to increase their profits. This is all to say that you can have equal access throughout a huge area with widely different densities - it's entirely practical and feasible. The only reason it doesn't happen in most places is because it's left up to private corporations whose primary concern is profit. This means they fight over the low hanging fruit of high profit dense urban areas and don't bother to invest in the less profitable, less dense areas. Regulations or other mandates that put availability above profits fix this. You can still run a profitable business while serving everyone equally, but if you only care about maximizing profits, then you will inherently prioritize dense areas over sparse areas. And while that may not be intentionally discriminatory in any legally protected way, there are strong correlations between race, wealth, and population density, which leads to the kind of incidental discrimination that the FCC is trying to address here.
- i8comments 3y agoBringing Internet to more people is supposedly good for them, but is bringing more people to the Internet supposed to be good for the Internet?