4 ms·
> Because the state couldn’t fund a massive energy programme alone, it ran a series of clean power auctions, where it offered project developers 20-year contrac
by mschuster91 3y ago
> Because the state couldn’t fund a massive energy programme alone, it ran a series of clean power auctions, where it offered project developers 20-year contracts to sell electricity into the national grid at guaranteed rates.
This is a carbon copy of what Germany did prior to the infamous "Altmaier-Knick" and "Gabriel-Tief [1], both named after the utterly incompetent ministers responsible for cutting back on these programs. Prior to that, our solar industry was world leading in competence and production capacity, it all shifted to China afterwards.
[1] https://www.fraunhofer.de/de/forschung/aktuelles-aus-der-forschung/energie.html https://www.fraunhofer.de/de/forschung/aktuelles-aus-der-for...
- CalRobert 3y agoYour car industry will be headed there next it seems.
- mschuster91 3y agoThat's not due to incompetent politicians for once. The crisis of the German car industry is entirely of its own doing - they completely ignored electric power for years, and instead focused on lobbying to get rid of emission limits, which obviously left them stranded in a ditch after Dieselgate. On top of that, everyone but Volkswagen was/is focused on high-margin SUVs and luxury vehicles, which aren't really a thing outside of corporate "luxury" for upper level management and new-rich in China, and Volkswagen completely dropped the ball in software quality.
- spaniard89277 3y agoIt's a disgrace that we're not able to buy cheap and light cars in the EU anymore. I just want a ~2010 Fiat Panda :(
- V__ 3y agoRenaults Zoe also seems great, I see quite a lot of them on German streets.
- archi42 3y agoThe Zoe is EOL and IIRC replaced by the Clio E-Tech. Also, Renault is french? (Not to talk badly about the specific car or the move to BEV in general - I applaud that and am at the same time disappointed how our [German] manufacturers ignored the shift)
- CalRobert 3y agoThe Zoe has pretty horrendous crash ratings, sadly.
- hkt 3y agoThere are cute little things like the Citroen Ami: https://www.citroen.co.uk/ami https://www.citroen.co.uk/ami They're nearly compelling enough for me to learn to drive. Nearly..!
- la_oveja 3y agojust fyi, a citroen ami (2020+) is not a car is a quadricycle; it does not need a driving license, is like a electric bike. id not want to use it to stay in traffic tho, crashing that does not seem safe
- CalRobert 3y agoEven in Europe cars are becoming bloated and shoving everyone else off the streets. The Economist had a piece about the death of small cars in Europe a few months ago. https://archive.ph/KxzUK https://archive.ph/KxzUK There's really no escape, it seems.
- cpursley 3y agoThat’s only part of it (China is eating and will continue Germany’s EV’s lunch), the other part is energy prices. Like it or not, cheap natural gas from a certain country was the backbone of a competitive German industrial economy. Can’t make an Bosch appliance or VW with solar power that can compete with Korea’s LG or Chinese brands. Energy is EVERYTHING.
- hef19898 3y agoThenonly EV lunch Chinese OEMs aren't eating is Hyundais.
- cpursley 3y agoHopefully not, really looking to the competition!
- RandomLensman 3y agoGermany could have cheap own energy, but usually any new infrastructure or whatever attracts huge opposition.
- cracrecry 3y agoAs a Spaniard myself that have lived in several cities in Germany like Hamburg, I will tell you a secret: There is no sun in Germany. My eyes have to adapt to the luminosity change every time I go to southern Europe or north of Africa. I have always believed that putting solar panels in Germany was a wrong solution. I have also lived in Argentina and travelled to Uruguay. Those countries have a massive amount of natural resources compared with Germany for a population that is much smaller.
- blkhawk 3y agoyes, but panels can be made cheap enough and there is plenty of surfaces you can plaster them on. To just put them on roofs was very much the right choice compared to say Desertec. When you look into it then Desertec would have been a huge waste of resources. The issue at this point is not generation - its storage and to a lesser degree transport.
- audunw 3y agoYour personal impression doesn't really matter though. What matters is the statistics. Of course there is sun in Germany. Yes, there's less. But then it's also cooler which makes the solar panels more efficient. What matters is if it's economical to use solar panels there, which it is. In summer, where some areas will use quite a bit of AC, there's more daylight hours than regions further south. In winter, if you have vertically mounted panels, a nice effect you can get is that the snow reflects extra sunlight from the ground to the solar panel. Fun fact, even the airport in Longyearbyen in Svalbard, Norway - an island close to the north pole - has solar panels. They're mounted vertically on the walls, since the sun is never very high in the sky. There's no sun at all in winter, but in summer there's sun 24/7. https://sunpower.maxeon.com/int/case-study/energy-arctic-circle-moving-coal-solar https://sunpower.maxeon.com/int/case-study/energy-arctic-cir... It's surprising how much production they get even that far north: "the PV system produces as much as 70 percent of what is typically produced in Germany" So please don't use your subjective impression about how bright you feel it is to gauge the viability of solar. I can tell you from personal experience, it's not very bright in Svalbard even in summer. BTW, much of the energy need in winter in northern climates is for heating. It's surprisingly effective to store thermal energy over several months. So it's actually viable to dump heat from excess solar in a thermal reservoir in summer, and use that heat in winter.
- thworp 3y agoYes, if your only concerns are the %age of renewables in the electricity mix and the health of an industry that could only continue to exist with direct subsidies it was incompetent. Personally, I think the Energiewende is one of the most expensive failures ever. It cost about €500 billion in direct subsidies and indirect damage in the trillions due to lower economic growth. Not to mention the waste that was the installation of solar panels and wind turbines that were less efficient and became uneconomical to even upkeep. And what was gained by this sacrifice? Today solar is the cheapest form of energy generation to build (even with storage and even in Sweden) and we got exactly nothing for being first. Imagine if the Energiewende was a framework of laws and some light subsidies that allowed for an actually decentralized energy market. You sell your 10kW solar installation's power to your local farmer while you're at work and he sells you the power from his combo natgas and biogas reactor at night. All proceeds from this tax-free with no bureaucratic BS and guaranteed access to your local grid. Pretty soon there would have been small towns that were net exporters and the system would be extremely resilient. Instead, because of lobbying by the privatized monopoly companies but mainly because politicians are allergic to self-orgazing and self-regulating systems (they cannot imagine them and they resent that they don't need their involvement) we got high prices, centralized and fragile generation, communities opposed to wind turbines because they did not see any benefits.
- hef19898 3y agoWow, the Energiewende caused lower econic growth... Strong claims require strong evidence, especially if the come with specific numbers.
- thworp 3y agoStrong claims? So you want proof that an increase in the price of energy, which is an input into absolutely every good and service, causes less goods and services to be produced? I don't think we have a basis for discussion here.
- hef19898 3y agoUnless you bring studies from actual economist making the same claim I agree, we don't have a basis. Posted from the freezing, deindustrialzed, immigrant over run Germany.
- cbmuser 3y ago»This is a carbon copy of what Germany did prior to the infamous "Altmaier-Knick" and "Gabriel-Tief [1], both named after the utterly incompetent ministers responsible for cutting back on these programs.« Germany installed more wind and solar capacity per capita than any other country in the western world. Besides that, if an economic program heavily relies on subsidies, it’s not sustainable in the first place.
- the_why_of_y 3y agoWould you say fossil fuels are not sustainable, given they are subsidized with trillions of dollars every year? https://www.statista.com/chart/31016/volume-of-global-fossil-fuel-subsidies-timeline/ https://www.statista.com/chart/31016/volume-of-global-fossil...