3 ms·
> unscrupulous corporations I wonder why everyone is afraid of unscrupulous corporations, but are not concerned about use by unscrupulous governments. The latt
by WalterBright 3y ago
> unscrupulous corporations
I wonder why everyone is afraid of unscrupulous corporations, but are not concerned about use by unscrupulous governments. The latter are a lot more dangerous.
- jacquesm 3y agoIn the long term, but in the short term unscrupulous corporations far outnumber unscrupulous governments and they act much, much faster to adapt to new technology.
- WalterBright 3y agoUnscrupulous governments can easily take everything you have and destroy you, literally. History is full of examples. Heck, you'll see examples in the newspaper every day. The rookiest cop has more power over you than Bill Gates.
- jacquesm 3y agoAbsolutely. But the rookiest cop isn't currently trying to track my whereabouts, abuse my privacy, stick a bunch of AI down my throat and in general isn't trying to make my wallet any thinner. Bill Gates and the more modern versions of Bill Gates are doing that and more.
- WalterBright 3y agoThe rookiest cop can: 1. track you with license plate readers 2. pull up any information about you 3. fine you 4. force you to stop 5. detain you 6. confiscate your car and property 7. search you and your property 8. take your phone and search it Bill Gates can: 1. give you a free browser when you buy his operating system
- jacquesm 3y agoThis is getting silly.
- WalterBright 3y agoIt is? I suggest reading the newspaper.
- tonyedgecombe 3y agoIt would probably be better for you if you read a little less news.
- nickpp 3y agoReading less news does not shield you from the real world. I thought I can survive in the private world respecting the law and limiting my government interactions. That worked until my kids started school and my parents' health deteriorated. I was in for quite a shock. Crappy infrastructure was the least of the problems! Luckily there are private alternatives but they are crippled by law and they can't cover everything.
- tonyedgecombe 3y ago>Reading less news does not shield you from the real world. The news isn't the real world.
- amanaplanacanal 3y agoI suspect the issue here is that most of HN folks live in western countries with mostly working democracies. For the most part we haven’t experienced how bad governments can get. Whether or not western style democracies are immune to going really bad, remains to be seen. Some days I’m optimistic, some days not so much.
- jacquesm 3y ago
- hgfghui7 3y agoI think we need to recognize our privilege in living in well functioning western democracies. I'm very worried about what ai will bring for those less fortunate in that regard.
- lmm 3y agoBullshit. Bill Gates can easily afford to make me unemployable, which destroys my life a lot more effectively than locking me up for a few days. Worst case I can move to a different country and get away from the cop, but that won't make me safe from Gates.
- WalterBright 3y agoHow can BG make you unemployable? Who has he done this to?
- lmm 3y ago> How can BG make you unemployable? - He could drag up and publicise something you wrote at some point and make you one of the "today's twitter main character" people. (Last I heard Justine Sacco was still unemployed). If he did this by paying a competent PR firm, you'd never know it wasn't just something that happened by coincidence - He could get linkedin to quietly drop or deprioritise your job applications - He could get outlook to quietly drop your emails, or mark them as spam, or show an unprofessional profile picture. You'd never know why you weren't being hired. - He could put something bad on the "credit report" (different from your actual credit report, and no practical way to see it for yourself) that Experian etc. send to potential employers. Again you'd just silently not get hired and never know why - Given the silicon valley wage-fixing scandal happened and the punishment was minimal, there's probably an old-school blacklist he could put you on if he was feeling retro > Who has he done this to? We don't know. Unlike governments, private entities have no accountability (as long as they have money to burn); investigative journalists aren't going after them, FOIA doesn't exist for them...
- WalterBright 3y agoAny evidence Bill Gates did any of this? Even if true, compare this against the difficulty finding a job if you have a criminal record. Now there's a real blacklist. > Justine Sacco is still unemployed No evidence she was sabotaged by a corporation. Besides, she's employed as of 2018: https://www.vox.com/2018/1/19/16911074/justine-sacco-iac-match-group-return-tweet https://www.vox.com/2018/1/19/16911074/justine-sacco-iac-mat... > silicon valley wage-fixing scandal Is kinda nothing set against government wage fixing laws. > old-school blacklist I'm sure there are informal blacklists. But I've been in tech all my life, and nobody ever handed me a blacklist and said "don't hire these people". There are a zillion companies in the US, any such pervasive blacklist will inevitably become common knowledge.
- fzeroracer 3y agoThere are multiple examples of companies destroying someones life. Nintendo has gotten people thrown in jail for modding things that they purchased and owned, certain corrupt CEOs have sued people into bankruptcy oblivion etc. All of these are possible because they've created the government you live under.
- horrible-hilde 3y agoI think the former is far more dangerous particularly if a monopoly because there is no feedback loop.
- danShumway 3y agoHN does skew towards skeptical of government regulation and control of AI. People are concerned about government usage of AI, particularly in the realms of facial recognition, automated sentencing, algorithmic bias, and security (LLMs are pretty insecure right now and there are companies trying to sell the US government on using them in the military). There's obviously a lot to be concerned about on the subject of government abuse of AI, and that gets conversation on HN. However, given that this specific article is about selling access to an AI girlfriend, I think we're probably OK to talk more about the corporate angle than the government angle. Unless you're predicting that the 2024 election is about to get real weird, "what if the US government starts offering AI girlfriends" is not going to be at the top of my worry list any time soon.
- CamperBob2 3y agoHN does skew towards skeptical of government regulation and control of AI. Which HN is that? Certainly not this one.
- danShumway 3y agoQuite genuinely, I don't think I've ever posted a comment on HN where I've expressed support for open, locally running LLMs and had it been downvoted. Am I missing something here? You want to point me to all of the articles where people criticize Huggingface? But regardless of how you interpret HN sentiment towards uncontrolled AI access, it doesn't change the fact that "what about the government" is a profoundly weird thing to ask in the middle of a conversation about people doing erotic roleplays with a text bot. Is that something people are worried about? Do we think that the US Post Office is going to suddenly start advertising a sex bot service? Yes, government abuse of facial recognition exists, regulatory capture exists, etc. But that's not really relevant to a conversation about companies offering AI girlfriends; AI girlfriends do seem to be mostly a corporation thing.
- CamperBob2 3y agoNot so much against open-source local LLMs, but you can bet those will be on the list for regulation as soon as they become as good as GPT4 is now. Meanwhile, here on HN, take a look at the recent story where someone uses 100 lines of Python to instantiate David Attenborough. You'd be burned as a witch if you built the system behind that demo 10 years ago, and you'd be treated as a God-level hacker if you built it 5 years ago. Today, virtually the whole HN thread is full of comments advocating that regulators step in. "Buh..b..b..buhtwhataboutmahCOPYRIGHT?" It's fucking disgusting. Who are these people? They're not hackers; what are they doing here?