7 ms·
I feel like this is trying very hard to push a particular narrative but not actually bothering to substantiate anything. From the top... > Bad Bots are increa
by yjftsjthsd-h 3y ago
I feel like this is trying very hard to push a particular narrative but not actually bothering to substantiate anything.
From the top...
> Bad Bots are increasing dramatically — Arkose estimates that 73% of all internet traffic currently (Q3, 2023) comprises Bad Bots and related fraud farm traffic.
Note that "Bad Bots" are never defined, and that 73% will never be explained, either to say how they mean it (73% of connections is plausible, 73% of packets is not, not in a world with Netflix and YouTube), or how they would measure such a thing.
Then we get into little gems like
> Scraping, it must be said, is a legally murky area. It is not specifically illegal; but if it defies a website’s published terms of use, it is certainly immoral.
Which... that's a claim you can make, but if you just throw out terms like "certainly immoral" without bothering to substantiate them I get to laugh at you.
The tendency to cast aspersions without substantiating them gets substantially more pronounced later:
> This is a website you can use to make sure your bots aren’t getting prevented by a website,” [...] “You can purchase this software. It has enterprise support and so on. But it is purpose built to commit crime. That is what it does. And there are many other different websites like this, but they look like legitimate businesses. It is a good example of a product purpose built to commit fraud.”
I'll grant that businesses don't like people bypassing their protections, but that doesn't make it automatically illegal or fraud to scrape or even to programmatically interact with sites. I'm not naive enough to think that it's not being used for illegal stuff, but that doesn't mean you get to paint the tools with a single brush.
- JohnFen 3y ago> Note that "Bad Bots" are never defined This stuck out to me as well. What are "bad bots" and how do they differ from "good bots", and how are the authors determining which is which?
- PartiallyTyped 3y ago> world with Netflix and YouTube Not in a world where pron exists.
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y agoOkay, fine, a world where video streaming exists, in whatever particulars.
- egypturnash 3y ago"The top five categories of Bad Bot attacks are fake account creation, account takeovers, scraping, account management, and in-product abuse." - second paragraph, first sentence
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y agoThat's a description, not a definition. If they said that they classified a bot as bad if it engaged in one of five described behaviors, that would be a definition, but that's not what they've done. (And if that was the definition they were using, then I'm going to call out scraping and account management as not sounding like malicious behavior)
- swatcoder 3y agoThe actual report from Arkose (linked elsewhere in the comments) is much more detailed in what they’re measuring and reporting. That said, the language around the “73% of traffic” figure is still a little ambiguous but most plausibly means “73% of requests/sessions to the significant commercial properties we studied” Assuming that’s what they mean, it’s reasonable that bots are banging on major sites three times more often than legitimate users. I think the linked article is doing the sloppy sensationalizing and the report appears to be much less so.
- yunwal 3y agoWhat percentage of those “bad bots” are actually just crawlers for search engines and other internet indexes that aren’t actually bad?
- danShumway 3y agoTo build on the above, it's worth thinking about the transition that happens between those two quotes: > Scraping, it must be said, is a legally murky area. It is not specifically illegal There's already a jump happening here from "it's not specifically illegal" to "it's a gray area because it's immoral." Even if it was certainly and unambiguously immoral, that does not make it automatically a legally murky area. In fact, scraping seems to be reasonably established as specifically legal. So the article is already kind of edging away from reality, where they acknowledge "this is not a crime" but they want to blur that and say that it's legally dubious, even though what they really mean is that they believe it's immoral. Which, fine, I don't respect it but whatever. But then we jump to: > But it is purpose built to commit crime. Wait, no. Scraping is not specifically illegal. This is the emulator debate again; we have something that really is strongly implied to be legal and has won court cases before. It's not like it's an untested gray area, we know that there are scenarios where scraping websites against the permission of the website owner is not illegal. So the article pretends it's more of a gray area than it actually is, and then once it has thrown doubt on it, drops the pretense entirely and calls it illegal. Not all scraping is fraud and not all scraping is illegal, and it's pretty galling for the article to admit that scraping is not illegal and then to turn around and pretend that they didn't just admit that. > It is also a good example of crime-as-a-service. No, it's not. The article admitted that scraping is not specifically illegal. Tools to help scrape websites are not "crime-as-a-service" because objectively (and there is legal precedent backing this up) scraping is not a crime. ---- The propaganda strategy being employed here is to admit a piece of factual information (scraping is not illegal), however hesitantly, and then to pretend that it was never admitted. If anyone calls the propagandist out, they can point to their admission and say, "no, I acknowledged that it's not illegal, see". But then for every other part of the conversation, they just ignore that and act like it is illegal, even though at best all they've put forward is that they think it's more dubious than courts currently recognize. They concede the point only to the degree they're forced to and only to the degree that would prevent someone from saying that they're lying or ignoring reality. But as soon as the context changes, they go back to acting like the point was never conceded. This has the benefit of not only allowing them to make the same arguments they wanted to make before, but also sort of trains listeners to think of the original conceded point as more murky than it actually is. "Sure," the reader thinks, "it's technically not illegal, but at the point we're talking about crime-as-a-service and illegal tools, surely there's something legally dubious going on, this must be more of a gray area" -- even though not only has the article not backed up that idea, it's actually admitted that the idea is wrong.
- _lvbh 3y ago> Note that "Bad Bots" are never defined, and that 73% will never be explained, either to say how they mean it Arkose runs a bot detection service, OpenAI being one of their customers (check your requests on chat.openai.com). I’m guessing the 73% are the number of requests/sessions that fail their JavaScript fingerprinting. Not sure how reliable these numbers are as I have a Go library specifically for passing their fingerprinting in pure Go (No JS) and it has been working for a while without much change
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y agoAnd in the opposite direction, I disbelieve stats about bots because of the number of web sites that treat my real browser driven by an actual human as a bot:) (My personal favorite was being blocked by cloudflare, and then getting an email from cloudflare telling me how great they are because they block so many (alleged) bots)