3 ms·
It's definitely a tricky fair use case, and obviously will depend on each country. IANAL but I'd say the main argument for it being free use is that subtitles
by crazygringo 3y ago
It's definitely a tricky fair use case, and obviously will depend on each country.
IANAL but I'd say the main argument for it being free use is that subtitles don't take away from movie/TV sales. There's no harm. To the contrary -- fan-made subtitles in languages the studio didn't produce might generate purchases where there were none before.
While the main argument against it is that it's part of and enables broader piracy -- if you can show that people are overwhelmingly using subtitles with content they downloaded illegally, then it is part of harming the studios.
(Also, subtitles are not scripts. They usually don't even indicate who's speaking, much less include all of the scene descriptions and instructions. Probably ~half the words in a script are not dialog.)
- em-bee 3y agoi don't follow that argumentation. do you think that people who want subtitles would pay for content if there were no subtitles available for it? subtitles either increase sales, or they do nothing. they may increase illegitimate sharing, but they won't do it at the expense of sales.
- crazygringo 3y ago> do you think that people who want subtitles would pay for content if there were no subtitles available for it? Pretty much. If you're Japanese and don't speak English, and a show you really want to watch is only available to pirate in English (no subtitles available) which means you can't understand it, but if you subscribe to Netflix you can watch it with Japanese subtitles that Netflix provides... I mean yeah? I'm presenting both sides of the argument. The question is really, which side will a court find to be stronger? And there may very well be a distinction here between fan-made subtitle translations, versus official subtitles.
- em-bee 3y agook, i was thinking of content that didn't have official subtitles.
- breakfastduck 3y agoI mean, lets not pretend that it's primary use case isn't to provide subtitles for pirated content.
- sonicanatidae 3y agoSure, but I don't know a single pirate that decided to purchase media because subtitles were made unavailable.
- jjulius 3y agoI've done it - twice, I think. Downloaded a film in a foreign language, couldn't find subs anywhere.
- sonicanatidae 3y agoI've done it zero and most of the people I know that pirate are also at 0. Like all things in life, YMMV. ;)
- starkparker 3y agoThere are also wrinkles in the distinctions between subtitles and captions, definitions of accessibility, the application of accessibility to fair use (and related restrictions on distribution), the definition or existence of fair-use exceptions in different jurisdictions, and on and on. The bottom line is that most of these points haven't been challenged outside of that BREIN case, nor do they cover some of the more valuable uses of authored or revised subtitles, such as subtitling and captioning works that never had them, or in languages that weren't translated, or to correct significant translation errors. The legal cases of subtitling are especially pertinent now that we have relatively accurate, low-cost, easy to implement realtime speech-to-text. If many devices that play video can now add subtitles, or even captions, locally in real time, how much value is there in paying lawyers to pursue cases to protect the copyright of _just_ the subtitles? Is editing a subtitle script generated by a speech-to-text engine also a copyright violation, and if so, who all is violating the copyright? The person who feeds the video to the engine? The editor, who could be a different person? The distributor of the resulting subtitle file?
- crazygringo 3y ago> realtime speech-to-text Oh boy. I mean, I frequently rewind turn on subtitles for 10 seconds because a bit of dialog is totally unintelligible. (Or it turns out to be perfectly intelligible but it's something with a proper noun like "Kantauganwe it is.") For people without accessibility needs, speech-to-text is the least help when they most need it...