4 ms·
> Your consumer can query the API on its own, and download 5 subtitles per IP's per 24 hours, but a user must be authenticated to download more. Users will then
by crazygringo 3y ago
> Your consumer can query the API on its own, and download 5 subtitles per IP's per 24 hours, but a user must be authenticated to download more. Users will then be able to download as many subtitles as their ranks allows, from 10 as simple signed up user, to 1000 for VIP user.
> If you wish to offer subtitles without prompting for an opensubtitles account, please contact us and tell us about your project... For an easier development process, you can set your consumer as "Under Development", this will allow you to perform up to 100 downloads per day without user authentication temporarly. [1]
Downloading tiers are listed at [2].
It's a question I've never considered before -- should "open" mean "you can API-download everything all the time anonymously no limits", or "you're free to API-download a reasonable amount for consumer purposes with an account, and the more you upload the more you can download"?
Do they offer any kind of bulk download or mirror?
[1] https://opensubtitles.stoplight.io/docs/opensubtitles-api/e3750fd63a100-getting-started https://opensubtitles.stoplight.io/docs/opensubtitles-api/e3...
[2] https://www.opensubtitles.com/en/support_us/ https://www.opensubtitles.com/en/support_us/
- toomuchtodo 3y agoLike some open source projects moving to a "source available" or "fair code" licenses, it is going to be bumpy finding equilibrium as to what is reasonable. Tragedy of the commons for sure. There are costs to cover, and usage profiles can vary wildly.
- clarionbell 3y agoAnd when they do that people just fork and go along with their own. Tofu being a great example, opensearch somewhat less.
- dartos 3y agoBy “people” you mean organizations with budgets and stakeholders. Very few people, even few programmers, would be able to take on maintaining complicated software like tofu alone, for example.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoMore like Reddit. The contributors will just leave and you'll be left with a corpse of content to rip going forward. Tofu is different because of the broad contributor base around the Terraform ecosystem. Lots of people's jobs (or companies even, Spacelift for example) depend on Tofu not only existing, but improving into the future. If you have a benevolent dictator with deep pockets, throttling usage and retrieval is less of a concern. The Internet Archive comes to mind, as does Wikipedia. Reddit's outcome happened because they were a discussion board utility masquerading as a 10-100x VC funded business, and their actions drove away the concentration of mods and contributors who were putting in all the free work (broadly speaking).
- miki123211 3y agoDid anybody (outside of the tech/HN open-source-die-hard bubble) actually leave Reddit? From what I saw, there were protests which most Redit users barely noticed (the front-page just served content from the subreddits that didn't go private), and then there was nothing. The long-term impact seems to be small to nonexistent. Maybe if the users organized better and started posting "brand unsafe" content everywhere instead of just going dark, the effects (and especially the effects on advertisers and Reddit profitability) would have been different. One can dream, though.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoHard to say without Reddit showing their traffic cards, just anecdotal evidence. Admittedly, if you're consuming big subs similar to what you'd consume on Tiktok (r/funny, r/worldnews, etc), likely little impact to traffic. I know the mods from some of the subs I follow fled (admittedly smaller readership, r/econmonitor and r/machinelearning for example). Reddit will have to show their hand when they attempt to IPO, as they then tread into securities fraud territory if the metrics are not accurate. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36289290 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36289290 (Ask HN: Anyone at Reddit can confirm a traffic dip?) (n=1, I consume Reddit now with a Lemmy mirror of the subs I'm interested in)
- 3y ago
- MrStonedOne 3y ago[dead]
- atrus 3y agoThis is why I love technologies like BitTorrent and IPFS, where it's not a single server bearing the brunt and costs of being popular, everyone is contributing. The more popular it is, the more performant it is.
- efsavage 3y agoWhen I see "open" I read it as "I can do what I want with it". I don't read it as any obligation on the part of the provider/creator to incur ongoing costs on my behalf.
- iudqnolq 3y agoLooks like they offer a full data dump: https://dl.opensubtitles.org/addons/export/ https://dl.opensubtitles.org/addons/export/ I haven't actually tried to use it. So long as they offer a dump you could use I think it's entirely reasonable to require payment for the API. I think it's reasonable to consider them morally open even if the web UI is closed source if the subtitles are open. It feels to me like a project selling a shiny hosted app around an open source project. I think in this sort of project the core "source" is the subtitles, not the web UI. If OpenAI let you download their models but didn't provide the tooling you'd need to run them I think their name would be much more reasonable.
- red_trumpet 3y agoThat's not a full dump of subtitles, but rather of list of which subtitles they have, with download links. Here are the first lines of the `subtitles_all.txt` file: IDSubtitle MovieName MovieYear LanguageName ISO639 SubAddDate ImdbID SubFormat SubSumCD MovieReleaseName MovieFPS SeriesSeason SeriesEpisode SeriesIMDBParent MovieKind URL 1 Alien3 1992 English en 2004-10-31 23:54:23 103644 sub 2 Alien.3 11.000 0 0 0 movie http://www.opensubtitles.org/subtitles/1/alien3-en 2 Identity 2003 Slovenian sl 2004-10-31 23:54:23 309698 sub 1 Identity.DVDRiP.XViD 0.000 0 0 0 movie http://www.opensubtitles.org/subtitles/2/identity-sl 3 Ghost in the Shell 2: Innocence 2004 English en 2004-10-31 23:54:23 347246 srt 1 Innocence.2004.DVDRip.XviD 23.980 0 0 0 movie http://www.opensubtitles.org/subtitles/3/ghost-in-the-shell-2-innocence-en
- fundatus 3y agoYeah, I was wondering if that could be the full dump. I know how far compression algorithms have come, but 318MB for all the subtitles of the world? Would be interesting to know though how large a full dump would be.
- jck 3y agoMy guess is not by much. Text doesn't require a lot of storage. After looking at a few random files my estimate is that the size of the full compressed dump would be about 30x (~10 GB)
- michael1999 3y ago"Open" means if you already have a copy, you are free to share it as you like. It doesn't mean someone is obligated to spend money giving it to you. The FSF always charged a profit rate on Emacs tapes.
- chrismorgan 3y agoI feel like every time something has started with the name “Open”, the promise that lured people in (sometimes implicit, sometimes explicit) has been broken. Open Exchange Rates: the fact that you didn’t need an API key was an important part of their gaining popularity. Of course, this fell down at some point, at least partly due to stupidly-coded clients, and so they started requiring an API key, and completely hobbled the free plan for many previously-recommended uses (only hourly updates and 1,000 requests per month; a month is up to 744 hours, so they really are just saying “if you want to use this broadly, either pay us $97/month, or cache it yourself hourly, proxying it if you have multiple access points”). Not very open. OpenAI: eh, you probably already know the story. They broke their word and premise thoroughly.
- danShumway 3y ago> It's a question I've never considered before -- should "open" mean "you can API-download everything all the time anonymously no limits", or "you're free to API-download a reasonable amount for consumer purposes with an account, and the more you upload the more you can download"? Neither, Open should mean that the resources are publicly licensed such that they can be freely rehosted or redistributed. It should mean that the resources are owned by the community rather than the website operator, and that the website should be selling coordination, not access. Whether or not there's an API limit is irrelevant provided that: A) the website does not claim ownership over resources it hosts B) the website is not going to go after people hosting or distributing those resources outside of the site -- ie, users have explicit permission to distribute any and all of the subtitle content on the site C) there is a way to get the resources off of the site, ie it's not impossible for someone to set up a rehost. If OpenSubtitles still allows a bulk download or has a mirror, then honestly I don't see a problem with them making this change -- I'm not a fan of it, but if the subtitles are still downloadable in bulk and if OpenSubtitles isn't claiming ownership and would have no issue with someone setting up a separate service or rehosting those subtitles and if (to the degree they can be licensed openly, given that they're subtitles of copyrighted films) they are licensed openly using an OSI-compatible or comparable license in the case of the GPL, then I don't have a problem with them using the word "Open" and I think it still applies. Having said that, I can't immediately find any information on their website about what copyrights they do or don't try to claim, and it's not clear to me how I would go about building a full dump of the content (a sibling mentions a dump but that it doesn't contain the full subtitles). But that would be my bigger beef. I'm less concerned about whether the website is Open and I'm more concerned about whether the subtitles are Open (again, as open as movie subtitles can be).
- Taek 3y agoExactly. Open doesn't mean "we will pay all of the bills so that you can enjoy these resources for free". Open means "we will not take any legal action against sharing and/or modifying these files". Open projects can have all the ratelimits and paid APIs that they want, as long as they are okay with people setting up mirrors and re-hosting content for free.
- al_borland 3y agoIn an age of companies looking to cash in wherever they can on AI plays based on free data, tiers start to make sense to keep the services viable. For consumers with normal usage, on-demand downloading of subtitles for 5 movies in a day seems pretty good. For TV, not so much. Even rate limits would be fine. A movie can be downloaded every hour, a TV show every 15 minutes. For a media server that wants a local cache of the subtitles, it could still run through with those rate limits in the background while you’re not watching. It could be a slight annoyance when first setting it up, but would be a one time thing and not much of an issue for one-off adds over time. I was messing around to mass download stuff from a wallpaper site with an API about a year ago, just because I’m a data hoarder and was worried about it going away at some point. The API required auth and had a rate limit, but as a consumer, it was fine. I just added in a 2 second wait between downloads and had no issues. It took longer, but what do I care? After a week of screwing around with it I saw I downloaded about 50gb of wallpapers, which was more than I wanted. I felt kind of bad about it and stopped. I decided to be a bit more intentional on my downloads after that. The tool I made let me put it a tag and download all the results. That was a bit too greedy.
- MrStonedOne 3y ago[dead]