4 ms·
Gas stations have attendants. When payment doesn’t work, a person can go tell someone and still pay. When a pump has an issue it can be switch off when it first
by al_borland 3y ago
Gas stations have attendants. When payment doesn’t work, a person can go tell someone and still pay. When a pump has an issue it can be switch off when it first happens. If it’s an easy fix, it can be done right there. If it’s not an easy fix they can schedule a repair.
These charging stations were built with a business model of set-it-and-forget-it. This doesn’t work. It should have been obvious this wouldn’t work, but I’m sure companies were blinded by the apparent simplicity of the business and the idea of being first to market.
This seems like a fairly easy problem to solve for charging stations that are in the parking lot of a business. Provide training and resources for people at those business, and it can work much like the gas station model.
This reminds me of the roll out of NFC payments. Companies had it, but it was always broken and they didn’t bother to fix it right away, as it wasn’t deemed critical, since everyone had another form of payment and people using NFC was rare. It was years before I felt comfortable enough to go somewhere without a physical credit card as a back up. It seems electric chargers are treated with the same, “nice to have, but not critical” attitude.
- rcbdev 3y agoIn Germany and Austria many gas stations do not have attendants... (Avanti, Turmöl, etc.) I have never once experienced an issue with these in my entire life.
- RamblingCTO 3y agoTo be fair, this technology is probably simpler and way more mature than EV.
- fragmede 3y agoway more mature, sure, but simpler? it has to vend a liquid and measure its amount and then charge you at the pump a specific amount. whereas the EV chargers are a cable and an Internet connection.
- matt-attack 3y agoDon’t forget gas pumps also have to remove and store vapors from the vehicles’ tanks. So I agree, waaaay more complicated. Other than contractors, I’d imagine there are no moving parts on an ev charger.
- ozim 3y agoIt is much more complicated for end user. You have to properly fit the plug into socket and tolerances are small so connector wear is bigger as people most likely just shove it in or force it connecting or disconnecting. Gas pump for user still can go wrong but tolerances on user just putting it in a bit wrong are much bigger. Tear and wear on gas pump for me is almost non existent.
- Guvante 3y agoAre we talking about Level 2 or fast chargers? Level 2 is similar in complexity to gas stations (beyond the handshake process being more finiky than trusting the user installed it correctly). High speed chargers are incredibly more complex than gasoline. You need to delivery a specific voltage and amperage to the car and both of those numbers change continuously as the battery charges. Note the article is about high speed not level 2. While physically it might not be much more complicated (note pulling off that kind of charging at almost a kW is no small feat) certainly the software is more complicated.
- underdeserver 3y agoI believe the first gas stations were built after the first power plants.
- rasz 3y ago>person can go tell someone and still pay No need for people. EV chargers are all online, you have logs and automation can easily flag unusually unused chargers, or ones with high rate of engagements without completed charge.
- underdeserver 3y ago> These charging stations were built with a business model of set-it-and-forget-it. This doesn’t work. Except it does work for Tesla chargers. I never had any issues when using superchargers. But connect to a fast charging station operated by one of the other vendors - payment doesn't work, it's out of order, handshake issues. I have no other explanation except the hardware and software are low quality.
- rcxdude 3y agoIt could also be faster maintenance response. If Tesla actually fixes their chargers quickly then you would tend not to see it even if the base reliability is lower.
- Waterluvian 3y agoYeah, maybe. I’ve seen out of order gas pumps all the time. But never for long. They fix them fast.
- underdeserver 3y agoThis is easily measurable. Measure handshake success rate, station usage, station availability. Keep them high. It's not hard, just expensive.
- mensetmanusman 3y agodoubtful, because they have the data on costs to repair, and would be minimizing that, whereas competitors just let it stay broken since that is cheaper than fixing.
- matthewdgreen 3y agoTesla chargers have instantaneous telemetry that tell drivers exactly how many charging stalls are functional. Presumably this information is available to Tesla employees, who seem to take action immediately when a charging station reports trouble. Excluding the entire card payments industry from the process (thus excluding a garbage-fire of non-functional third party technology) takes care of the rest.
- VyseofArcadia 3y agoSet it and forget it doesn't work, but we also don't need need full timrtime attendants. Regular (weekly? Monthly?) inspections would be fine. Infrastructure always needs maintenance. You can't get away with it. If you build it, you should regularly inspect and maintain it.
- jopsen 3y ago> Gas stations have attendants. Some do, where I live most are unattended. You can only pay by card. The difference is that running a gas station is a known quantity. Large franchise have been doing it for years. These things will resolve themselves with time.