3 ms·
Slack is not some backwater cottage industry. It's a big company with thousands of employees and millions of users - many of whom are paying good money for thei
by userbinator 3y ago
Slack is not some backwater cottage industry. It's a big company with thousands of employees and millions of users - many of whom are paying good money for their software.
...and therein lies the root cause underlying the majority of these useless changes: Too many people for the amount of required work.
In much the same way that "design by committee" often leads to horribly complex abominations, I've noticed that the bigger the development team (and perhaps the company behind the product), the worse the software turns out to be; and usability is no exception.
At the other extreme, products of a single developer very rarely make hostile UI changes, because they mostly can't afford to. Then sometimes they get bought out by a bigger company, and the useless changes start showing up shortly afterwards.
- pmontra 3y agoI saw this happen many times: 1. We have to add this feature, we need an icon, menu item, anything, for it. 2. It doesn't fit well in any of our menus, we should stop a moment and think about the UI, maybe like this and that. 3. Great but it takes too long, we need this tomorrow, on this Friday, or at any very demanding deadline. 4. Ok, so we add an icon there or into the options and people will figure out. We'll fix it later. 5. Later never happens because we're again at step 1 very soon.
- quickthrower2 3y agoFirebase seems a case in point. You have to do all this weird Google cloud shit to get something basic working. I posit that using Firebase is more complicated at the outset than installing an ORM and using postgres. And being nosql it gets worse from that point on. So it’s raison detre of making it easy to build apps is lost.
- rob74 3y agoSlack gets a lot of flak, but in my experience they're far from having the worst web app UI. For instance, have you tried the abomination that is the AWS management console? Not sure about the pricing for Slack and for AWS, but I bet companies tend to pay a lot more for AWS, so you'd think they would be able to come up with an acceptable interface - but no, it's a Rube Goldberg-esque monstrosity where even the simplest tasks require you to traverse at least five slow-loading pages...