3 ms·
"While this was happening, the civic and religious institutions that Americans traditionally relied on to manage their own affairs were quietly disappearing. So
by Animats 3y ago
"While this was happening, the civic and religious institutions that Americans traditionally relied on to manage their own affairs were quietly disappearing. Some organizations, like religious boards, unions, and bowling clubs, declined in number; others, like charities and NGOs, switched from a model of mass participation to a model of mass donations. Add it all together and you find that the percentage of Americans expected to be familiar with Robert’s Rules of Order shrunk precipitously."
This is a good point. Do you belong to any non-governmental organization where the members can vote to fire top management, and this happens once in a while? A golf club? A maker space? A gym? A homeowners association? A mutual insurance company? A savings and loan? A school? Anything? Such institutions used to be common for non-profits. Now they are rare.
Robert’s Rules of Order is for meetings where the members hold the power. Motions are voted upon and then are binding on the organization. Unless the members have power, it's just a talk shop.
When someone set up a local maker space, they set it up as a nonprofit with a self-perpetuating board. That is, the management chooses its own successors. I declined to contribute.
- kiba 3y agoMy makerspace is member elected.
- svnt 3y agoThe management isn’t the board, that’s the point. The management is overseen by the board and the board entrusts the function of the organization to management while they help set direction. Separately, I can’t find the example but Robert’s Rules for Order can be trivially DDoSed and have been in order to bring down or paralyze organizations. I think there was a conversation here about it some time back. Nonprofits are legally required to have boards, AFAIK. What would you have preferred the nonprofit do?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]