3 ms·
> A judge signing off on a warrant is essentially making a prediction that a party is guilty of something involving the target of the warrant. At best that's i
by kelnos 3y ago
> A judge signing off on a warrant is essentially making a prediction that a party is guilty of something involving the target of the warrant.
At best that's ignoring a lot of nuance, at worst that's just flat-out incorrect.
When a judge signs off on a warrant, they are only saying that they agree with law enforcement that serving the warrant would help move a particular investigation forward, and that the actions they'd need to take to serve the warrant are legally supportable. That's it.
- alphazard 3y agoI think you're taking the law as written, noticing it doesn't say anything about predictions, and then assuming that predictions aren't what judges are supposed to be doing. What I'm saying is that the system, as currently designed and implemented, reveals a judge's implicit beliefs, when they sign or veto a warrant. These beliefs paired with the result of a search directly reflect how good their "judgement" really is. And I'm suggesting that we make those beliefs explicit as predictions.