6 ms·
Amazon is blocking promotions of employees who don't comply with RTO policy
- eschneider 3y agoI suppose that's Amazon's prerogative, but wow, they're really hanging out the "please recruit from our employee base" sign. I mean, if you were hiring, you'd be well advised to try and poach folks from Amazon right now.
- potatopatch 3y agoEverything I've heard about Amazon makes it sound like the perfect place to hire from if you want top talent that is a little burned out at the start.. They seem designed to be a short term exploitation firm.
- johnny99k 3y ago[flagged]
- ryandrake 3y agoUnfortunately, Amazon tends to be the "Employee Relations Bad Ideas Incubator" for the rest of the tech industry, at least BigTech. Fully expect other companies to copycat this.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoIf workers don't organize [1], they will always be beholden to whomever was lucky enough to make it to the top and uses their emotions to drive organizational decisions. It's not just about comp, it is about not having agency. I totally get that this is frowned upon by a lot of folks who surf HN (call this whatever mix of bias you want, survivorship, confirmation, Dunning-Kruger, etc), but the stats tell a different story [2] [3]. People under 30 are very pro union (obviously! the US labor force dumpster fire need not be enumerated as a wall of text here), and older leadership or "thought leaders" [4] [5] will age out eventually (average CEO age is 59) [6]. Note no emotion or politics in this comment, because it is unnecessary but also unproductive. These are facts derived from first principles. If you as a worker wish to continue to suffer, status quo. If you want to not be treated like a disposable cog to be extracted from until tossed (whether out of the need to meet the quarter's earnings target or what feelings someone in leadership has), see above. My position is that the current deal is a raw deal, that it could be a bit more fair, and there are levers to pull to enable that. This isn't Marxism, this is "could we be a bit more kind to the people generating the value?" Life is short, and your exposure to the work/labor market during that lifetime should not be brutal. [1] https://code-cwa.org/ https://code-cwa.org/ [2] https://www.bbc.com/worklife/article/20230831-the-gen-zers-leading-a-new-pro-union-push https://www.bbc.com/worklife/article/20230831-the-gen-zers-l... [3] https://www.americanprogress.org/press/release-gen-z-is-the-most-pro-union-generation-new-cap-analysis-finds/ https://www.americanprogress.org/press/release-gen-z-is-the-... [4] https://fortune.com/2023/04/23/remote-work-bullshit-real-estate-legend-sam-zell-office-situation-will-change/ https://fortune.com/2023/04/23/remote-work-bullshit-real-est... [5] https://apnews.com/article/sam-zell-real-estate-billionaire-68dd59e71e5b4ad18308afa0b83c07f8 https://apnews.com/article/sam-zell-real-estate-billionaire-... [6] https://www.kornferry.com/about-us/press/age-and-tenure-in-the-c-suite https://www.kornferry.com/about-us/press/age-and-tenure-in-t...
- VirusNewbie 3y agoIf you want, you're welcome to go work at Boeing where there is a union software engineers can join. Or you could get paid 3x as much working for Amazon.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoOnly takes a majority to unionize. The minority can do what they want. You think you can find 51% in an org who still want to get ground down? I suppose we will find out what the self awareness and logic situation looks like on the ground.
- tash9 3y agoMy hot take: this is actually really good (and would be fantastic if all the big tech followed suit). Why? Imagine a world where big tech was cool with remote workers. They would be able to out-pay and acquire all the best talent, everywhere. With this self-imposed restriction, this leaves a big pool of high end talent able to be recruited by smaller start-ups who ordinarily wouldn't be able to compete on comp, benefits, and stability.
- danaris 3y ago> Why? Imagine a world where big tech was cool with remote workers. They would be able to out-pay and acquire all the best talent, everywhere. Assuming this is true (which I think is very much in doubt), then it indicates there is a much bigger systemic problem that needs to be dealt with: namely, big tech functioning as essentially the landlords of the Internet and skimming profit off of everything that happens there. No one sector of the economy should have this much influence. Certainly no group this small of companies this large should have this much power over anything. Any time you find yourself saying, "Well, yes; this change should make life better for tens (or hundreds) of millions of people, but if we make it, this group of people over here will be able to take advantage of it to enrich themselves at everyone else's expense," I strongly recommend taking a look at that group of people over there and considering whether they should have that ability, and if not, how you might be able to change that. (And if so, why, exactly, you think anyone should have that ability.)
- voisin 3y ago> indicates there is a much bigger systemic problem that needs to be dealt with: namely, big tech functioning as essentially the landlords of the Internet and skimming profit off of everything that happens there. Seems like you haven’t been paying attention as this is precisely what has happened. Or are you being ironic?
- danaris 3y agoNeither: I'm pointing out that this is a problem that needs to be dealt with, rather than simply a fact of the world. We shouldn't be giving up on improving people's lives just because Big Tech would take advantage of it; we should be changing the system so Big Tech can't leverage those improvements to screw everyone else over.
- darth_avocado 3y agoAmazon is infamous for treating employees poorly. The label “PIP factory” started with Amazon. Yet, thousands of people flock to them for jobs. You can’t really blame Amazon at this point, they’ll use all the leverage they have because they know they can.
- hamandcheese 3y agoAt least in my circles, I only know people who have left Amazon. I've never met someone who went to Amazon mid career.
- hef19898 3y agoWe don't know each other personally, but I fall in both groups. Don't regret it, and woupd do it again at the same point in my career. Because you learn more there in a year than you do in at least 5 elsewhere.
- wnolens 3y agoI did. It was terrible for my mental health.
- RandallBrown 3y agoI've met a few, but it's certainly less common.
- no_wizard 3y agoThe flip side is their stock options are generous, they have (had?) generous hiring bonuses and their salary was good enough, and you got a top 10 business on your resume. Then, there is always a chance you land on a team that isn't dysfunctional at least for a couple years and you learn a ton. Amazon allows you to learn in abundance when you work on a functional team. Eventually, the system eats you alive, or you move high enough up the chain that the system changes
- eschneider 3y agoOnly if you live long enough to vest and it seems the majority of folks don't.
- CSMastermind 3y agoAt the end of the day the counter to this is starting and building companies with remote work forces. If remote work truly is equal to or superior to in office work then you should be able to out compete in the long term using this competitive advantage.
- mitthrowaway2 3y agoYes; unfortunately the counter to that is economies of scale, network effects, and cost of financing, all of which big established companies like Amazon have. If you're going to compete against Amazon, you can't be merely their equal.
- QwertyPi 3y ago> If remote work truly is equal to or superior to in office work then you should be able to out compete in the long term using this competitive advantage. Or they'll just buy you out. Competitive advantage doesn't work too well when your competitors have large moats of cash that you don't have access to. Honestly, people just need to organize unions. That's the only effective counter to policy like this.
- sonicanatidae 3y agoI agree. It's hard to wade through the headwinds of Scrooge McDuck piles of money working counter to you.
- maerF0x0 3y ago> they'll just buy you out That would require you to sell. And if one is confident they can win in the marketplace then why sell to them when you can eventually flip the scenario and have them asking to be acquired? Fully granted that in my experience, in the USA for the past long time, it's felt like Corporatism has made this scenario far less likely. But, perhaps that's more of a sign to start your company elsewhere. Perhaps America is no longer a good place to start a company.
- fishtoaster 3y agoYou say "buy out" like it's a bad thing. Presumably that's a huge win for you if you started (or have equity in) the company - and if not, you can just... not accept the buyout offer?
- drcongo 3y agoSomeone should put together a handy list of all these companies with RTO policies, with metadata about which ones have abused it to force people to leave, and which ones have forced it on people hired into remote positions.
- whitten 3y agoMaybe a recruiter could see the cost of maintaining such a website/database as a business advantage.
- nicole_express 3y agoRefusing to promote? I had to leave my employer entirely because I didn't want to work from an office where none of my team was.
- acbullen 3y agoThis is definitely a stressor in my current job. Fortunately I have a couple coworkers from before acquisition knocking around so there's at least some folks knocking around the office providing some social benefit, if not actual productivity boosts.
- thesuitonym 3y agoIf you want social benefits, go to a bar. Work time is for working.
- buggeryorkshire 3y agoYeah. I quit as after WFH 200 miles away from my office for 3 years after COVID lockdown I was expected to come in 3 days a week. They were perfectly happy with me working from another office 100 miles away - our call centre. What exact benefits growth or knowledge wise do I get from there?
- dvfjsdhgfv 3y agoIt is very interesting to unfold the next chapter in this power struggle between employers and employees. So far one thing is clear: senior staff in general is tending towards WFH. There are exceptions of course but the tendency is clear. In my niche, on job boards the top-paid positions are all WFH. The reason is clear: if you really want to have the best people and keep them for long, you not only pay them well but there is also mutual respect.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gustavus 3y agoI've been hit up multiple times by Amazon to work at AWS. Every time I've responded to the recruiter by telling them I've heard that the way Amazon treats it's employees is not the kind of place I would want to work. I've yet to hear anything about Amazon that makes me reconsider that.
- endemic 3y agoDuring the height of COVID, they were offering remote-friendly positions -- glad that their overall negative reputation stopped me from taking them up on it.
- mathverse 3y agoI dont fucking get this RTO. I am working from home and working more than I should because I feel obliged to deliver and show visibility. Companies get more from us employees working fully remote. Saying that as I just finished 3h of unpaid work. I really dont get this. (am an EU employee)
- generic92034 3y agoManagers at Amazon were already able to fire employees not complying with the RTO policy. So I am not sure the ability to block promotions will have much impact. Those non-compliant employees with enough leverage not to get fired might get that VP approval for promotion anyway.
- zactato 3y agoI know that the common perspective on HN is that remote work is good. Certainly, as a senior engineer and parent I appreciate the flexibility that remote work provides. However I think there’s a huge problem that’s silently growing. New engineers are falling behind. We’re growing a generation that isn’t developing some critical social skills. They’re not learning how to effectively learn from their peers. Maybe this is simply a set of skills they’ll develop later, but I worry about their future careers. I don’t know the reasons that these big company’s are choosing to force RTO, but I do know that colocated teams have a better culture and perform better.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gustavus 3y ago> but I do know that colocated teams have a better culture and perform better. Citation needed. I work on a remote team, we see each other once every other month or so, and we get along great. It's one of the best teams I've ever worked with. I don't know what this "culture" companies keep trying to foster is, I'm not building a civilization, I'm not trying to "change the world" I'm showing up to do my job and get paid. I'll do my job to the best of my ability, I'll be considerate and polite and try to get along well with my coworkers. But at the end of the day I'd rather see my wife and kids than spend more time with my coworkers.
- dangus 3y agoRight, since when does culture always equate to making money? Amazon and Walmart have pretty shitty work culture and they make a lot of money. Even if remote work is less productive than in person work, office rents aren’t free. Meta leases millions of square feet in Manhattan for I can only assume is at a cost of over $50/sq ft. You can hire a medium sized company with that kind of money flying out the door.
- zactato 3y agoThe team's I'm talking about don't meet in person that often. Once or twice per year. Every month feels like a good cadence to develop and maintain good relationships. I should push for more frequent meet ups. Given how spread out people are this is certainly difficult.
- OhMeadhbh 3y agoAmazon promotes employees? I didn't know that.
- hef19898 3y agoSure, one of my former team mates made it from level 2 before joining my team in 2015 (?) to level 5 as of earlier this year. And they absolutely deserved that, Amazon being the only place I know something like that still happens to people without academic education.
- jlarocco 3y agoThat sounds fair to me. On the other hand, pre-COVID I quit a job and took a pay cut to get a fully remote one, so it's a trade-off I'd personally be willing to make.
- dn3500 3y agohttps://archive.li/s2pRx https://archive.li/s2pRx
- olgeni 3y agoThe problem is that the "emotionally intelligent" baboons got really obsessed with people and culture lately, so they need some actual people around in order to inflict the fad-of-the-day on them.
- hbosch 3y agoI have to admit, you had to have seen this coming. In terms of corporate structure, it never feels good to see managers enjoying a "benefit" that their employees don't. Imagine a remote manager in Florida who manages a team of people who are expected to live in and commute to Seattle every day? It just doesn't bode well for morale or team-building IMO.
- Apocryphon 3y agoGoes to show that there’s a use case for unions in tech. Having access to high compensation and mobility during boom times doesn’t mean the companies still have the power to dictate policy even when a majority of their employees disagree. Beyond the remote work issue, ask yourself: when has a modern tech company permitted their workers to work in cubicles, let alone offices, instead of open office floor plans?
- teaearlgraycold 3y agoI get a lot of downvotes on HN for being pro in-person and hating remote work. But I gotta say, if a large portion of your employees want something to make them happy and they can be productive that way, you are an asshole for forcing them to comply.
- thesuitonym 3y agoAnd certainly, Amazon is big enough that you can have a portion of people who work from home, while keeping large enough contingent of in-office people that they'll be happy with their watercooler time.
- teaearlgraycold 3y agoI think it’s about more than watercooler chats. Showing up in person but still having all of your meetings over video calls sucks. You should try to build a subset of teams that are in person.
- meindnoch 3y agoGood riddance. Switching jobs has better RoI than those anemic promotions anyway.
- surgical_fire 3y agoThis is the correct answer.
- nsxwolf 3y agoMy career has been one long carrot and stick of promised promotions that never materialize, so this threat would have no effect on me.
- paradox460 3y agoOoh sorry you just missed promotion targets this time. Keep working hard and you'll be up for it next time
- nsxwolf 3y agoWe won't be able to consider it until the start of the next fiscal year. Oh, we've been having some financial difficulties, maybe next year. Oh, you're laid off.
- tmdyn 3y agoIf the promotion doesn’t come with a commensurate increase in salary to cover the commuting/relocation costs, I guess you’ll just get folks doing the whole rest and vest thing (as much as you can at AMZN)
- aathromzn 3y agoAmazon employee here, currently sitting in an office that is overcrowded, smells bad, and is too cramped to get any work done without distractions. The phone rooms are always taken, usually have broken lights or trash on the floor/desk. There’s absolutely no perks. The office cafe is expensive and awful food quality. My team wanted to have a holiday dinner and was told the company won’t pay for it, we have to pay out of pocket. There’s no budget for things like after-work events. Want to get drinks after work with your team? No budget for it. We’re forced to sit in agile desks that nobody likes. You aren’t allowed to customize your desk is any way. You aren’t allowed to leave anything overnight on your desk, even if you’re going to use the same desk the next day. The _only_ perk we have is that you are allowed to get one free coffee per day from the onsite barista, and even that they have tried to get rid of multiple times. I used to work at a company that had a hybrid workforce and it had no issue getting people to come into the office by incentivizing people with basic stuff like a nice office or company-sponsored events. Amazon is all stick, no carrot and it’s honestly embarrassing that a company this big could be so inept at something other companies figured out decades ago. Either that, or they aren’t even trying. I don’t know which is worse.
- eschneider 3y agoIf they could treat engineering the way they treat the warehouse workers, they would. When a company tells you who they are, believe them.
- sokoloff 3y agoOne coffee per day?! If I was to have one coffee per day, I’d for sure need to lift that bucket with my legs to avoid a back injury.
- Gigachad 3y agoThat’s pretty wild. I’m generally pro office, but that sounds like the worst office I’ve heard of.
- kulahan 3y agoAmazon has always struck me as a pretty aggressive employer. I wonder if it'll ever come back to bit them in the ass. One free coffee a day is asinine. MS gives you all the free soda and coffee you could want, and their food courts are great. I assume this is true of Google as well. How the hell does Amazon keep finding employees?
- mensetmanusman 3y agoMustttt saveeee realestateeeee The zombies are in charge again!
- glimshe 3y agoThis is so Office Space, so Milton-in-the-basement. Instead of terminating people who aren't complying with their policies, they use a passive-aggressive tactic for them to quit. One more bullet point in my "Why I should never work at Amazon" list.
- MattPalmer1086 3y agoOur recent all hands company meeting: Senior manager 1: we are increasing the number of days in office per week for everyone. Senior manager 2: our new remote collaboration solution is brilliant, you can even work on an airplane. Everyone else: sitting at desk in front of a video call listening to people in different locations, as usual.