6 ms·
Pseudoprose
- timeagain 3y ago> Writers overuse commas. What is it about writing that drives people to write lists of imperatives for writing? As writers we all start somewhere that is some distance away from our taste. As we progress we learn what little tricks we need to tell ourselves to achieve writing that makes us happy when we read it. For me, I might write, “start with the point, then expand; you aren’t writing a mystery novel!”
- surprisetalk 3y agoI see the same pithy stuff in woodworking and software too! I'm a huge fan of a book called The Inner Game of Tennis. Something I picked up from that book: I think a lot of advice works not because it's correct, but because it causes craftsmen to observe a thing they weren't observing before. "Am I overusing commas?" is a useful but unanswerable question :) EDIT: The book also makes a strong case against judgmental language, so "overusing" commas is probably not the best word. So instead, maybe, "What do commas make sentences feel like?"
- stavros 3y agoThat's an interesting notion, thanks! I'm now wondering what else I can be asking myself about my preconceptions.
- reidjs 3y agoI try not to do it, but I’m absolutely guilty of this. When you start writing, it’s sort of the lowest common denominator topic to write about. You’ll be sitting there thinking what should I write about? So you start writing about writing itself.
- voidhorse 3y agoI'm kind of tired of the "programmer's take on craft that's been around for centuries longer than programming" genre. Writers have been using "pseudoprose" for eons, they are called "outlines" and "notes". Just like we don't necessarily need programming languages for recipes in the kitchen. What's up with programmers and their urge to ignore the rich history of any given subject only to fart out a piece on "here's how we could suck all the life and art out of X and make it just like programming!" No particular offense intended to the author. General ignorance of other art forms and desperate, half-baked, square-peg-in-round-hole attempts to understand everything in terms of programming is just a definite style of thinking that I find extremely frustrating, and it's not clear to me why programmers in particular seem to be so susceptible to such totalizing, reductive forms of thought. You don't see many writers going around writing pieces on "gerunds for code" and things like that. Jeez.
- louislang 3y agoPeople approach things through a lens of familiarity. Programmers are likely relating it to their experience.
- keyle 3y agoNIH syndrome, every day, twice on Sunday.
- adfm 3y agoThank you! 100
- beloch 3y agoI see a couple things interacting here to promote this kind of post. 1. The bar is low to call yourself a programmer and have a programmer's blog. Maybe they have a university degree that required them to take courses in a variety of fields to become well rounded. Maybe they just went to a technical school and got good job experience. Maybe they just jumped into a programming job after dropping out of highschool. They might be very good programmers, but not knowledgeable about anything else and not particularly aware of it. 2. HNews has a lot of programmers in it's membership. Earth shaking stuff from a variety of diverse fields gets promoted because programmers have diverse interests, but they also tend to read a lot of other programmers' blogs and post them, even if they are somewhat less than earthshaking. Every news source has its weaknesses, and the tendency to see low-effort, poorly researched programmer blog posts promoted above genuinely interesting material is one of HNews's problems.
- surprisetalk 3y agoAuthor here! I'm 100% guilty of applying to "programmer's brain" to everything. You'd cringe if you saw the alt music notation I've been working on for the past decade. It's an ascii abomination. Seriously, it's got functions and everything is represented in base twelve. Anyway, I thought pseudoprose was worth sharing because of how LLMs might change the writing process itself. I've been experimenting with using GPT to expand ultra-condensed notes into essays. But I've found that I'm too obsessive over my writing voice to ever let it fill in gaps for me haha But even without LLMs, I still naturally gravitate to writing with pseudoprose. It's how I've taught myself to structure thoughts. But maybe thoughts don't need structure, and that's just my programmer's brain imposing order on the orderless :)
- thequadehunter 3y agoThis reminds me of something hilarious I saw on Facebook a few years ago. My graphic designer friend was joking about how she has a ton of PSD files in a folder with funny numbers, names, and notes in the filename. Then, a programmer swooped into the comments section and tried to sell her on the merits of using git for version control. LOL. I nearly died laughing.
- Brajeshwar 3y agoAh! How many of her files has "final" in the filenames? ;-) Well, there was even a "Git for Photoshop." I think it was LayerVault[1] -- a search brings it up. Of course, yes, the trick with PSDs and static assets during the early days of the web were the file naming patterns. I did one in my 2nd or 3rd job long back (early 2000s), and when I met the team after 10-years; they were happy that they were pretty much still following the convention/pattern that I outlined. 1. https://www.layervault.com https://www.layervault.com
- whatshisface 3y agoThere's a meme somewhere about how if hackernews laughs at something, it's six months away from a successful product launch and years of profitable sales.
- stavros 3y agoWhat's funny about that? That sounds like a great idea.
- thequadehunter 3y agoThat's why it's funny. It IS a great idea, but they're preaching to the wrong choir.
- gizajob 3y agoOr, write instructions about how to construct good prose using messy, context-absent, prose-free bullet points.
- gizajob 3y ago"Always avoid superlatives." (Not including the most superlative of superlatives, the universal quantifier, that I'm using here willy-nilly.)
- surprisetalk 3y agoGlad somebody noticed the joke :) "Use adverbs sparingly" is another I tried to sneak in there
- jmprspret 3y agoI prefer to write on paper :^)
- clairvoyant_cod 3y agoIn response - Code requires creativity - In that sense it's art - If code is art... Are LLMs a medium? - Van Gogh's critics said: - Thelonius Monk's critics said: - Edgar Allen Poe's critics said: > "What's up with artists and their urge to ignore the rich history of any given subject" Maybe they weren't ignoring it, but building on it. Or maybe they wanted to tear down the altars, like Dada. Everybody's a critic. Edit: formatting
- npunt 3y agoI quite like this as an exercise in thinking a bit differently about writing. Something missing though is examples - I'd love to see a few raw and final pieces to see how to use it in practice, as well as expanding on the specific recommendations. I also see this as something to mix in with bits of specific desired prose, much like markdown can always have html plopped into it. When I'm coming up with ideas I often find some really clarifying sentences and metaphors that the piece shapes itself around, which I'll often just pre-highlight so readers know what to take away.
- instagraham 3y ago'Pseudoprose' might be a better format to train AI on writing arguments than regular prose, due to its explicit nature
- fergie 3y agoOn a related note: this guy has the coolest workstation setup -> https://taylor.town/my-battlestation https://taylor.town/my-battlestation
- mock-possum 3y agoI dunno, it just looks… like an exhibit or something, to me. Like when a historical figure’s childhood home has been turned into a museum, and each room has been staged to give an impression of what it might have been like while they were alive? It just looks sterile. Like no one uses it. Real life is so much more cluttered and uncoordinated in my experience. Or at the very least - my office is an absolute trash heap compared to this.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]