4 ms·
Cities file objections to $13B PFAS settlements with 3M and DuPont
- ikekkdcjkfke 3y agoNobody going for class action lawsuit on behalf of all organisms on the planet?
- vineyardmike 3y ago> The deals are overbroad and too generous to the chemical companies—absolving them of liability for future contamination and personal injury claims, the objectors said. The settlements also aren’t enough to cover the municipalities’ cleanup and legal costs, they said. I really lost hope when this settled that we’d ever see meaningful climate action. Or much other similar societal improvements. A huge issue in modern society is the lack of pricing-in of corporations’ externalities. Why should anything less than 100% of the equity generated from PFAS business go to fixing PFAS contamination? This is a perfect example of a corporation benefiting from doing something wrong and expecting society to fix it for them. I don’t necessarily think that 3M/DuPont should be liquidated and torn apart to fund cleanup, but maybe their profits certainly should be hijacked for the efforts. If an average citizen caused public damage they can’t afford to fix, their wages would be garnished to fund it. Why not corporations?
- BobbyJo 3y agoDeterrence really only works on individuals (actual people) not corporations (not actually people). So we're forced to consider the cost/benefit to society. Maybe (hopefully) the reason they worked it out this was is because it works out better financially in the long term if we dont kneecap the companies in exchange for a little extra money toward cleanup. The real issue is that the actual people that made the decisions that led to the problem will walk away from all of this rich. We need more accountability on the part of corporate offices if we want to deter these types of decisions.
- chmod775 3y agoIf your corp causes damage or commits crimes, you're not magically shielded because you did it as a business. You can absolutely be held personally liable. Extracting money from your company just so they can't come after it doesn't work. An example is the Bollea v. Gawker lawsuit, where the founder had to personally pay $10m on top of everything else, or the demise of criminal enterprises such as Prenda Law. Deterrence absolutely works because individuals are affected in the end.
- BobbyJo 3y agoThe problem isn't the law, it's enforcement. We can't prove wrong doing in most cases because who made what decisions with what information is often intentionally obfuscated. This is a good example. DuPont almost certainly knew these chemicals posed a long term risk to human health, and DuPont chose to keep manufacturing them and making money with them, but we can't arrest DuPont. Instead we have to prove that individuals within DuPont did the above, but no single person (or collection of coconspirators) is likely to be proven to commit the above crime.
- stonogo 3y agoThe company, at that point, is a collection of coconspirators. This is the fundamental difference between the executives of a company and other employees. The executives should be held responsible.
- BobbyJo 3y agoIs that the way the law has been applied? Or are you saying thats how it should be?
- stonogo 3y agoIt is arguably the entire purpose of the managerial class to take responsibility for the times when organizational policy results in illegal actions. Wage theft is a well-documented (and well-litigated) example of management being held personally liable. Obviously the way the law is applied is that none of these executives will be held accountable. I often wonder where the line is.