3 ms·
No psychic phenomena has ever survived the scientific method.
by WalterBright 3y ago
No psychic phenomena has ever survived the scientific method.
- ekianjo 3y agoEven most of science does not survive the scientific method...
- wizzwizz4 3y agoThe stuff we actually use does, though, like GPS and surface tension and anti-coagulants. The replication crisis is mostly an issue on the cutting edge.
- autoexec 3y agoI'd put my money on most research that wouldn't be replicated successfully if eventually tested being industry propaganda, psychology, and sociology. There's likely a lot of unchallenged complete garbage that goes back many many years. The cool cutting edge scientific research that's just too new (or too difficult) to have been replicated yet is always going to be somewhat of an issue, but it's the wrong stuff that's been around for ages that worries me most. Not only because of what it's influenced in all this time, but because when something believed to be true for a long time is invalidated it can cause problems for a lot of other research that was built off those lies, not to mention huge amounts of wasted time/effort/money.
- wizzwizz4 3y ago> but because when something believed to be true for a long time is invalidated it can cause problems for a lot of other research that was built off those lies, Most of the examples of flawed research (e.g. Thenaros; single-factor treatments of cancer/aging/neurodegeneration (e.g. Aβ*56, telomeres); those MMR vaccine claims in 1998) were known to be erroneous by experts in the field long before they were officially debunked. Some of them have yet to be officially debunked (e.g. Sigmund Freud's theories of psychosexual development; the high-/low-functioning autism distinction; "ABA is harmless and curative"; Blanchard's typology; most use of revealed preference theory; "React is fast"), so many outsiders (e.g. people who decide who gets grant funding) still consider their advocates experts in their respective fields – but the claimed results are just so obviously wrong that they're ignored wherever you can get away with ignoring them. Academic science is eventually correct, but sometimes it takes a long time getting there. Even so, you can usually tell the difference between "academia knows this" and "academia claims this but something went wrong": all the examples I've given are of the same, largely-social, phenomenon.
- mock-possum 3y agoHow would you characterize the difference between ‘science’ and ‘the scientific method’ in your statements
- 6510 3y agoNo scientist has ever survived psychic phenomena. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nn2grEJPw70 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nn2grEJPw70
- 6510 3y agoThe silence is deafening.
- gverrilla 3y agoTrue, but there's no shortage of liars, scammers, etc. For instance, last year I had a lawyer friend telling me "science has proven there is life after death", and in the end it was a shitty paper with no logic whatsoever (the method was not even on the horizon), but funded by some rich university in the USA. Truth is the scientific method is a quite complex subject to understand and 6 months in uni is just not enough (in quality, not necessarily quantity). Problem is it's one of the main pillars of science, so doesn't surprise me the recent up-rise in anti-science "ideas". Analog to that, the way I see it, there's also a fundamental and severe problem with journalism that needs to be addressed, and can be seen clearly through the up-rise of fake news in last years.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]