5 ms·
> Yet this country continues to throw their hands up in the air and do nothing. It's not that. It's that most people in the US like car-centric culture, and l
by kelnos 3y ago
> Yet this country continues to throw their hands up in the air and do nothing.
It's not that. It's that most people in the US like car-centric culture, and like suburbs. They don't want to live in dense spaces and have to rely on transit.
I disagree with these people, but politicians are not going to be able to enact the things you've described without getting kicked out of office by the people who don't actually want them to do these things.
- NegativeLatency 3y agoI think some people do like the suburbs (and they're allowed to), but the sky high housing costs in "nice" or "popular" cities indicate that there is unmet demand to live in dense walkable areas. The car industry has been very very successful with equating driving with freedom though which makes this a hard conversation to have with people. It should all be priced accordingly, you want to drive your private vehicle into my city? Then be prepared to pay a fair value for parking and road maintenance.
- psunavy03 3y ago> The car industry has been very very successful with equating driving with freedom though which makes this a hard conversation to have with people. It can't possibly be a "hard conversation to have" because people disagree with you, huh? It has to be that the car companies brainwashed them? I see this everywhere on social media. "I have an opinion, my opinion is the right one, and if you disagree with me, you didn't actually come to an independent conclusion, you were just brainwashed or had an emotional response."
- NegativeLatency 3y agoNobody makes ads that make walking look cool or get you to where you’re going in style, because there’s nothing to sell you in that case. They do make ads of cars taking shortcuts, going to nature, driving really fast, looking really cool etc (closed course, professional driver, do not attempt) Demand as seen by prices and lack of affordability in walkable areas in the US is sufficient evidence that it’s an underserved market. BTW You sorta proved my point at how convinced people are, and how it's such a hard conversation to have.
- gosub100 3y ago> if you disagree with me, you didn't actually come to an independent conclusion it goes in line with taking rights and responsibilities away from the individual. You want to go somewhere? take the government's approved method of getting there. You dont like smelling urine or seeing trash or getting accosted/threatened by homeless at the train station? too bad, should have voted for my guy, he's 6 votes away from funding the next "program" to help fix it. Sorry we can't fund police, they don't respond to property crimes any more. we need to raise taxes again to fund the next $CHILDREN program, get with the times. and on and on.
- Mawr 3y agoYou're right, it's about freedom. The freedom of not having to use a car to get literally anywhere.
- mikrotikker 3y agoFuck that I love driving, it's one of my favourite hobbies. I can and do drive for hours, 26 hours is about my max. With my truck I know I can handle anything on the way and be self reliant. I can take lots of water. I can take almost all my tool for any repairs on the road. I can sleep in it. I can traverse off road terrain with the large off road tires. The 4wd can help with icy road conditions. I have a winch to self recover or help others in trouble. The large and bright lights and higher sitting position give good visibility of the road. These things are popular because they engender self reliance which contributes to practicality and convenience for the driver. Not everyone has a boring daily commute to a cubicle job in their tiny ev that has 100km range and coming home to put on nature videos while they run on their treadmill. Stop trying to make everyone fit into the same box as you
- NegativeLatency 3y ago> Fuck that I love having my lifestyle subsidized by other people Interesting that you're actually the one trying to make me fit in your box, when I said that it's fine for people to like what they like. Nobody's saying you can't drive your truck, go off road etc. I would like to be able to travel the 1/3 of a mile without having conflicts with drivers when I'm trying to walk. Additionally I'd like the freedom to be able to get places with dignity without paying many thousand per year in costs associated with a motor vehicle. Also since you brought up "self reliance" almost any bicycle is going to be way more repairable than a motor vehicle, and _much_ more reliable, more capable off road etc. Literally children can repair and maintain them.
- mikrotikker 3y ago> make me fit in your box Not really... > I would like to be able to travel the 1/3 of a mile without having conflicts with drivers when I'm trying to walk. Why? Are you flipping off all the SUV drivers you see? > Also since you brought up "self reliance" almost any bicycle is going to be way more repairable than a motor vehicle, and _much_ more reliable, more capable off road etc. Literally children can repair and maintain them. Yes and you can still fit tent and stuff in your backpack or take a little trailer if you need. Way less tools needed. Travel lighter, less impact, access more places via skinnier tracks, it's cool. And you get a workout at the same time! I modify and maintain my own vehicle, so making it back from a 6000km trip on road and off road is very rewarding experience as it proves your abilities at (technical) driving as well as at spinning spanners and camping conveniences. Can cover more ground in a vehicle, visit more places, see more sights. Take a few more creature comforts. We only get so much time off work.
- kelnos 3y agoBoth things can be true though. I agree that there's unmet demand in urban centers, but that doesn't mean that there wouldn't be a massive revolt if laws and regulations made the suburban lifestyle much harder or more expensive.
- hightrix 3y agoI love living in the suburbs and have zero desire to live in the city. Being accessible by car, I can get to anything I need in 15 minutes. The people promoting 15 minute cities completely miss the mark here. I, and many others, already live in "15 minute cities" since we can get to anything in 15 minutes by car. For me, it is great to be able to drive to Home Depot, then Target, then stop and get lunch, and finally return home with a load of goods that would have been impossible for me to carry alone. As you mentioned, I will strongly vote against, and even campaign against, any politicians threatening my way of life.
- Aaronstotle 3y agoHave you ever lived somewhere where you can walk to get lunch for example? I really detest having to get into my car and drive 15 minutes each way (30 minutes round trip) to do any errand.
- stickfigure 3y agoNot the parent, but I lived 17 years in the heart of SF before moving to the country. I loved it in my 30s, but was pretty over it by my 40s. Now I love cooking at home, letting my kid play outside, and throwing parties without worrying about neighbors. People like different things. The things people like change. Give the parent (and people like him/her) the benefit of the doubt.
- RHSeeger 3y agoAnd different people like different things. I live in the suburbs and there's somewhere on the order of 20+ restaurants I can get to within 15 minutes (and probably about 10 within 7-8 minutes. And I can also, like the poster you were responding to, go to several different stores, pick up a carload of stuff, and get back home. If I want to do city things, I jump on the train (or drive) into a city and do city things for the day/night. But I don't want to live there.
- alamortsubite 3y ago"Restaurants."
- iambateman 3y agoThis is absolutely correct. Suburbia is subsidized —- the cost of infrastructure is often 10x the property taxes. Millions of people are accustomed to paying $1,000/year in taxes to live on a street that costs $9,000 to maintain. “Asking” them to pay the true cost of their decisions is considered politically untenable —- until the city itself goes bankrupt.
- notacoward 3y ago> It's that most people in the US like car-centric culture, and like suburbs. To put a finer point on it, people who like suburbs live in them. People who dislike them move elsewhere - forfeiting any voting rights they might have had where the problems are most acute. So who's left to fight the NIMBYs and car-lovers where it matters? Too damn few, by a long shot ... and this outcome was obvious to anyone who was actually thinking about society or the long term instead of just themselves and the next few years. If you want to solve anything, instead of just shifting the problems around, you have to solve them where people are and will remain. Stay and fight. Unfortunately that's hard so almost nobody does it.
- Mawr 3y agoAsk the Dutch if they like their bicycles and the Japanese if they like their trains. They'll say yes. Funny that. People like the environment they grew up in, it's part of their identity. Americans are no different. Very few people go out of their way to meaningfully explore different approaches to life around the world and form an informed opinion on what they like.