6 ms·
Up until recently I figured that driving was the most dangerous activity I engaged in on a regular basis, but nowadays I'm convinced that walking near an active
by paxys 3y ago
Up until recently I figured that driving was the most dangerous activity I engaged in on a regular basis, but nowadays I'm convinced that walking near an active roadway is worse. I have lost count of the number of near misses I've had due to inattentive drivers basically in tanks. The problem is significantly more noticeable after moving to the east coast where turning left or right without checking for pedestrians is the norm, and it's on you to watch for cars when you are walking regardless of what the light is and who has the right of way. And yes, car designs with massive pedestrian-sized blind spots is making this all that much worse.
- SoftTalker 3y agoWish it were another way but reality being what it is, one has to assume invisibility when it comes to cars (and buses and trucks). Assume they don't see you. If you're about to step into a crosswalk, check not only for crossing traffic but turning traffic. Be ready to dodge out of the way or wait. Even if you have the "right of way" you are going to lose if a vehicle hits you.
- falcolas 3y ago"Defensive walking" courses seem to be the next thing we'll start needing.
- InCityDreams 3y agoLook 'em right in the eye before you cross. "If you can't see my eyes, i can't see you".
- bee_rider 3y agoPractically yes, in the sense that not getting run over is a high priority. However, we should repeat that it is the drivers’ responsibility to be alert. That pedestrians have to take this sort of measure is a general failure on the part of our driving culture.
- zenzen 3y agoAnd are the only ones incentivized to, given the asymmetric danger between driving and walking. Drivers would be a lot more cautious with big spike in the middle of their steering wheel. Externalized risk (and unlikelihood of facing consequences if a driver were to maim or kill someone) has a very predictable outcome.
- bee_rider 3y agoI’ve lived in places where crossing areas have little buttons that set of flashers, but really it would be safer and put the responsibility where it belongs if that button would shoot a bollard post up in front of the crosswalk.
- reidjs 3y agoThis is difficult sometimes due to the extreme window tints many people have, especially in warmer climates.
- hef19898 3y agoLiterally what I was told in driving school, and as a kid in school before.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoLiterally impossible for many people due to height/tinting of people and cars.
- kspacewalk2 3y agoI make an important modification to this pattern. Whenever visibility is good, I act assertively when I cross streets, whenever my right of way is not in question. I leave just enough time to not be hit by the vehicle, but I don't hesitate nearly as much as other people. I want the driver to be uncomfortable, I want them to know they're doing something wrong, if they choose to go for it. Very often this is the difference between them deciding to cut me off and actually braking and yielding the right of way. If pedestrians don't take what's theirs (in a safe manner), there are just far too many drivers who will ignore them. Fixing that will take decades, best case, but I want to walk around my neighbourhood as a first-class citizen now. So I do. Disclaimer: I am tall, visible, only do this in good visibility, and live in Canada where driver behaviour is a bit better. If the situation is borderline, I never tempt fate, rather I throw my hands up in the air and make it obvious that yes, I hereby assert that this driver is being an asshole.
- craigmcnamara 3y agoWhat you said, but I'm considering carrying a rock now. Drivers seem to think I'm disposable for committing the crime of walking somewhere. Middle fingers are only so memorable, but that ding in the paint or a window might help them remember I have the right to not be hit in a crosswalk.
- xattt 3y agoYou will be quickly reminded by your local police force that throwing rocks at moving vehicles will result in at least a mischief charge. Your edgy angst is better spent engaging with local levels of government.
- falcolas 3y agoOr it may anger them into jumping a curb to explicitly hit you. Road rage due to damage to their pavement princesses is deadly when your in a cage of steel.
- ta1243 3y agoVictim blaming. If a driver can be goaded into murder, perhaps they shouldn't have the tools to commit that murder so easily.
- tetha 3y agoIt's not pretty, but in reality, "right of way" is a path to the hospital as a pedestrian. It shouldn't be, but their worst-case is a paint job, while mine is a jumble of broken bones.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoThey call that "dead right" - when you had the right of way, and you're still dead. I don't really feel that kind of need to assert my right...
- xur17 3y agoWhen running / walking downtown, I feel noticeably safer crossing illegally in the center of a one way road than I do at the cross walk when the walk sign is on. Reasoning: at a crosswalk I have to deal with cars coming from 2 or 3 different directions, including behind me. In the middle of the street, cars are only coming in one direction.
- lnsru 3y agoYes! If I can not use traffic light I will do that. Because green traffic light is just a signal and not ten feet thick concrete wall.
- mikae1 3y agoFrom a Swedish perspective this sounds horrific. > Assume they don't see you. So what about kids? They're usually not the best at that game. Are they not allowed to become autonomous beings because there are killer tanks on the move?
- robin_reala 3y agoSweden actually has driving tests that test the participants though.
- Libcat99 3y agoIn much of the US it is expected that kids will be driven everywhere. Walking is often dangerous. It's disturbing.
- roughly 3y agoBuddy if the gun situation around here didn’t convey America’s stance on child safety I don’t know what will.
- hindsightbias 3y agoWe're Free(TM) here. Autonomous roaming kinder will get you a visit from Child Protective Services. Major dense metros with viable transit are more immune to this, middle schoolers aren't unheard of but ridesharing probably has raised the threat level.
- toast0 3y agoThis isn't unique to being a pedestrian. You need to assume invisibility if you're a cyclist or a motorcyclist or even in another car. Even if you're in a car and have right of way, if another driver doesn't see you and collides into your car, it's going to ruin your day. The consequences aren't as bleak as if a vehicle collides into your body, but it's still pretty negative, and it's in your best interest to avoid a collision regardless of who would be determined to be at fault.
- jedberg 3y agoI teach my kids rule number one as a pedestrian: You never have the right of way. Legally you might, and it's important to go when it's your turn after you've made active eye contact, but realistically the car will always win that fight.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y ago"Yield to gross tonnage" is how I've always put it.
- jollyllama 3y agoThat's a good one. See also: "'He had his turn signal on' won't look good on your tombstone."
- falcolas 3y agoLearned this one from an old biker: The Right of Weight will always win.
- renewiltord 3y agoSeriously. That's how I've always described it. I drive a large vehicle. You will lose. Get out of the way. Use common sense and move. I like that. I'm going to put that on my car: "Yield To Gross Tonnage". Good shit.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoIt's not actually supposed to be a call to break the law...
- renewiltord 3y agoIt's a pretty good bumper sticker, though. It's like Pax Propter Vim. "Yield to Gross Tonnage". Cede Magni Ponderis
- r00fus 3y ago
- encoderer 3y agoI appreciate you pointed out the difference between east and west coast car culture. here in the bay area, pedestrians treat cross walks like magic force fields. Drivers have to stay alert. I try to teach my kids: the rest of the world is different. They will run you over and keep driving. Honestly I wish pedestrians would just cool it a bit here. It’s almost a power game for some. I find myself hanging back from the corner until traffic has passed so I can cross without holding everybody up. (I seem to have attracted the ire of car haters with this one. Heh.)
- J_Shelby_J 3y agoImagine if we wrote software and just told users not to do xyz and it won’t break. We should design pedestrian infrastructure with pedestrian safety in mind.
- nogridbag 3y agoBut it seems the only bug-free solution is to isolate pedestrians and vehicles at every crosswalk :) E.g. elevated overpasses or underground tunnels which are not practical. My neighbor was recently hit while walking her 4 year old and pushing her 1 year old in a stroller. In this case, the driver was making a left turn and as he completed the turn he did not see her in the crosswalk. On that road, it's not easy to make the left, so my assumption is they were solely focused on finding a gap to make the left. I can think of lots of improvements they can make: a crossing guard since there's a preschool there, some crossing flags, a turning lane, etc. But all solutions still seem to rely on driver's not making mistakes.
- ryukafalz 3y agoSlowing down traffic via traffic calming does wonders for pedestrian safety. When cars are moving slowly, drivers have more opportunity to notice pedestrians and crashes are less likely to cause serious injury or to be fatal. One other option there is to add raised crosswalks or a raised intersection, depending on the situation. That physically slows down cars as they enter the space where pedestrians may be.
- estebank 3y agoBollards, intersection daylighting, narrower streets, leading crossibg signals, raised cross walks, no right on red, fewer unrestricted left turns. Just a handful of things that can be done to make drivers drive in a safer manner without explicit coercion.
- erik_seaberg 3y agoI was pretty hopeful when Musk started talking about car tunnels.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- swozey 3y agoI previously lived and worked in Uptown in Dallas TX. I had a 1 mile walk to work which I thought would be awesome (barring summer). What it actually was was a game of leap frog. At 5pm thousands of middle aged men in button ups driving GMC Suburbans, Tahoes and F250s would be released into up/downtown with the sole goal of getting onto the highway as fast as possible so they could get to their suburb 30 minutes away. Pedestrians were just interruptions. Right on red? GUN IT! Red light? HA! Scooter crossing the road? Run it over! I wound up almost never walking to work those few years because of how ridiculously mad max walking through Uptown at 5pm was. I saw probably 10+ people on scooters get hit by cars. That part of the city would've been really cool if there were pedestrian bridges at every major intersection. But that's not much of a Texas thing.
- rconti 3y agoYep, I was going to comment on the blind spots. The massive A-pillars, especially, on newer airbag-equipped vehicles, makes pedestrians simply disappear. I have to constantly stay on top of it as a driver, and as a pedestrian/cyclist, I often see people turn their heads directly in my direction but they CANNOT SEE ME as their entire head is blocked by the pillar. I found this post[1] to be a really informative read about why we don't see things near pillars. --- At a traffic junction all but the worst of drivers will look in both directions to check for oncoming traffic. However, it is entirely possible for our eyes to “jump over” an oncoming bicycle or motorbike. The smaller the vehicle, the greater the chance it will fall within a saccade. This isn’t really a case of a careless driver, it’s more of a human incapacity to see anything during a saccade. Hence the reason for so many “Sorry mate, I didn’t see you” excuses. The faster you move your head, the larger the jumps and the shorter the pauses. Therefore, you’ve got more of a chance of missing a vehicle. We are effectively seeing through solid objects, with our brain filling in the image. Additionally, we tend to avoid the edges of the windscreen. The door pillars on a car therefore create an even wider blindspot. This is called windscreen zoning. --- 1. https://themartincox.co.uk/raf-pilot-teach-safe-road/ https://themartincox.co.uk/raf-pilot-teach-safe-road/