6 ms·
No, that's just one interpretation of the facts that we are relatively sure about. But nobody knows who the paymasters were. Note that there are still Ukrainia
by jacquesm 3y ago
No, that's just one interpretation of the facts that we are relatively sure about.
But nobody knows who the paymasters were. Note that there are still Ukrainians fighting on the Russian side and that 'the fog of war' is a thing.
- meeuwer 3y ago[flagged]
- jacquesm 3y agoThat's an easy one: USA. But there is also: https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/2023/11/11/nordstream-bombing-ukraine-chervinsky/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/2023/11/11/... In case you weren't aware of it yet. It's a huge mess and with Putin, the US and the Ukraine all in play there are a whole slew of possible scenarios. Nothing short of a massive investigative effort will clear this up.
- andreygrehov 3y agoBright democratic countries are not interested in the investigation. The resolution failed to pass because it only received three votes in favor (Russia, China, and Brazil) and 12 abstentions.
- jacquesm 3y agoI think the general consensus is that they don't want this to become a distraction. Regardless of who did it it's a footnote and it doesn't change the fact that Russia started a war next door to the EU on a flimsy pretext and that's the thing that matters.
- andreygrehov 3y agoI kinda both agree and disagree with you. I agree that it won't change much in the grand scheme of things, but at the same time I disagree on the footnote part. If blowing up a natural gas pipeline is just a footnote, then it means the responsible parties can do all sorts of attacks and then later simply say: "well, it's just a distraction, let's forget about it and move on".
- jacquesm 3y agoCompared to attacking a nuclear plant and blowing up a dam I think it's a footnote. War is ultimately destructive and any kind of infrastructure connected to the belligerents is at risk.
- meeuwer 3y agoHere's a funny weird little fact. The IAEA inspectors and even Mr. Grossi himself have been documenting and even 'hearing' shelling 'on a regular basis' while present on the ZNPP premises. But they've never attributed the shelling to either of the parties, not once. [1] Isn't that unusual given how quick all the officials and media are to blame just one side of the conflict (we know which one) for everything, with or without evidence? [1] https://www.google.com/search?q=site%3Aiaea.org+znpp+shelling https://www.google.com/search?q=site%3Aiaea.org+znpp+shellin...
- jacquesm 3y agohttps://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Just_asking_questions https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Just_asking_questions
- meeuwer 3y ago> ... it should be clear that "just asking questions" only applies when the answers are already well known, where the question embodies a point refuted a thousand times, and where the questioner exhibits willful ignorance. If, for example, someone phrased their political argument as a series of questions — but provided sources to back up said questions, or has raised logical arguments in said questions — then it is not enough to dismiss the argument as "just asking questions". So, the IAEA and Grossi either can't establish where the shells are fired from (hard to believe given the prolonged and intensive nature of the shelling and the amount of evidence) or are hesitant / not allowed to incriminate the party they believe is responsible.
- meeuwer 3y agoThe problem here is that the main suspect has control over both WaPo and those who hold the guy in jail. Oh, and over the countries that carry out the investigations too. Essentially, you're asked to disregard the motive, the capabilities, the unambiguous public statements made by the most likely suspect and accept their fall guy explanation. That's a bit too much disbelief to suspend.
- ceejayoz 3y agoNord Stream 2 was ended long before it blew up. February 2022 saw it decertified; March 2022 saw its employees fired and the company filing for bankruptcy. Sanctions and diplomatic pressure successfully prevented it from "moving forward" and "brought an end" to the pipeline's existence as a going concern. If you believe "bring an end to it" can only encompass explosive options, Trump's call to "put an end to" the Republican primary debates must be quite confusing. https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/4227533-trump-campaign-calls-on-rnc-to-put-an-end-to-future-debates/ https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/4227533-trump-campaign...
- pydry 3y ago>Nord Stream 2 was ended long before it blew up. Nord Stream 2 was pressurized ready to deliver cheap gas (which German industry desperately needs) with one flip of a switch. That presented a risk to the United States, who didn't want them to be tempted. >If you believe "bring an end to it" can only encompass explosive options Absolutely not but when an end to it is brought explosively and one party has threatened to do just that and has the most motive: * German energy intensive industries is being lured over to America with promises of cheap energy. * Germany is now paying a lot more TO America for its expensive LNG (something it has publicly wanted for a while). * The US has been wanting to pull Germany out of Russia's economic orbit for a long while now. Then the most plausible story is the one broken by the same guy who broke my lai: Biden not only threatened to do it, he did it.
- ceejayoz 3y ago> Nord Stream 2 was pressurized ready to deliver cheap gas (which German industry desperately needs) with one flip of a switch. That presented a risk to the United States, who didn't want them to be tempted. That's a potential motive, yes. "Make it look like US/NATO/Ukraine did it to sow discord" is also a plausible potential motive. (It has also been speculated that the destruction of the pipeline gets Gazprom out of some delivery contracts via force majeure.) > Absolutely not but when an end to it is brought explosively and one party has threatened to do just that and has the most motive: When was an explosive resolution specifically threatened? Biden was even asked in said press conference how it'd be accomplished and declined to be specific.