> Why would an HR department be afraid of being sued by an employee? The most likely explanation is that they want to fire them for performance and are trying t

> Why would an HR department be afraid of being sued by an employee? The most likely explanation is that they want to fire them for performance and are trying to limit the likelihood of a lawsuit. Most likely, HR has had complaints from at least one person other than OP. Beyond that conclusion, you're adding to the story to make it fit your narrative. Maybe they're afraid because he is a licensed gun owner. Maybe he brought his pet iguana to work one day and used it for rubber-ducking. (Using monospace throughout your message is a little confusing.)