3 ms·
Isn't the education system already pretty full of a pretty large range of game-like and competition-like scoring and motivational devices? We've got completion-
by _delirium 15y ago
Isn't the education system already pretty full of a pretty large range of game-like and competition-like scoring and motivational devices? We've got completion-based ones, ranking-based ones, competition-based ones, the works. Degrees, points on assignments, percentage scores, exam grades, GPAs, percentile ranks, science olympiads, etc. They were even made literally into games starting in the 1970s, with the edutainment-software movement. I can see tweaking these scores, removing some, introducing others, but the idea seems pretty standard.
Overall, though, I'm not sure the secret to education is that we just haven't invented a better scoring system to feed you Skinner-box-esque reward pellets whenever you do every incremental good thing. In fact we're already pretty decent at that. We're less good at convincing people why they should care beyond that. It's very easy to convince students that they should care about their grade and the badge (degree), but much harder to cultivate any sense of actual interest.
There's also some research that extrinsic rewards tend to reduce intrinsic motivation: once you start doing something for the brief high of getting the "ping!", it becomes much harder to bring yourself to do it later if the reward is removed, even if it's something you originally enjoyed; which means I think we have to be very careful in gamifying/badgifying/achievementifying things. It's a bit different debate, but Chris Hecker has a good talk about that where he worries that modern videogames are focusing too much on the "achievement unlocked!" aspect of gaming, at the expense of deeper and more actually engaging game mechanics: http://chrishecker.com/Achievements_Considered_Harmful%3F http://chrishecker.com/Achievements_Considered_Harmful%3F And if that's true in videogames, I would also worry about it irl.
- didgeoridoo 15y ago>...modern videogames are focusing too much on the "achievement unlocked!" aspect of gaming, at the expense of deeper and more actually engaging game mechanics I absolutely agree. "Badges" and the like are a half-assed (quarter-assed?) way of going about gamification. But some game mechanics simply act like heroin on the brain. World of Warcraft and Ultima Online had this effect on me in past years. I can't put my finger on it precisely (hence the ambiguity in the post), but I can't shake the feeling that there is something special about the incentive designs of WoW and UO that we can leverage to improve engagement in education and in the working world.
- mjn 15y agoAs far as the working world, there are some fascinating Soviet attempts with that. I wrote a brief bit about it at http://www.kmjn.org/notes/soviet_gamification.html http://www.kmjn.org/notes/soviet_gamification.html based on some preliminary research, but I'd really like to read a proper analysis written by a Soviet-history expert. It's obvious why the USSR found the idea enticing: since they didn't have tools like higher pay or bonuses to reward workers with, they hoped that they could incentivize workers with some kind of inner cognitive motivation, patterned after whatever secret sauce works in games and sports. It's probably fair to say that their attempts were of decidedly limited success, though it's less clear whether it was the idea that was bad, the Soviet implementation of the idea, the context, or some combination. The conventional explanation among capitalist economists has been that the idea was bad: you can't incentivize workers with games, but only with actual payment, so of course the Soviet attempts failed. But now a bunch of businesses, presumably run by capitalists, seem to think that the idea is worth a second look, which suggests that either they're wrong (and it's not worth a second look, for the same reasons it wasn't good the first time), or the answer for why the USSR's model didn't work is more complex.
- didgeoridoo 15y agoIncredible post & research -- thanks for sharing. The relationship of monetary reward to engagement has always seemed a bit weird to me. I've heard it said that compensation over $75K does nothing to increase happiness. However, I've also heard of fabulously wealthy people using money as a motivating scorecard, divorced from its purchasing power, simply used as a measurement of their success. Not sure if these are in conflict, or simply proof that money actually has a very oddly shaped marginal utility curve.
- obtu 15y agoGamification can help differentiate a business even if it doesn't have any positive consequence on education. That didn't apply to the Soviet attempt, a planned economy without much competition which is also analysed years after, in a more long-term perspective.
- aik 15y agoGreat points here, thanks for posting. I'm especially interested in your first point on the difficulty of cultivating care beyond all the "games" in school (grades, etc.). To extend on this, I agree you can be motivated to do work because you want a good grade, however the real struggle, and where it really pays off, is to be motivated to do work because you inherently want to. In a majority of school, students don't see the purpose or don't care about any given assignment, which is why the games/external motivators have been introduced. An alternative here is to spend much more time convincing the students why it's worth learning/doing, for example through providing more contextual information, introducing real-life scenarios, long-term projects, and so on. Once the students see the value, everything else (and so much more) will follow.
- bherms 15y agoI came here to make this point as well... Education _is_ gamified. While some seem to think that changing the scoring/reward system is the key to moving forward, I think the gamification itself is the problem with education (to a degree). It's far easier to say "did you answer this the way I wanted you to? If so, here's your A (or badge, or points) and you win," than to actually make sure people care about and grok the info they're meant to. I can memorize a formula to pass a test, but I may not know jack-shit about how and why the formula is applied to get the answer. That is a problem that is much harder to solve in education and I'm not sure it will ever be solved except by those that can inspire kids to see the beauty in the subjects they love.
- ttt_ 15y agoI don't think being scored in school and game scores are that much alike. In games, a bad score can be re-tried usually as many times as it takes for you to be satisfied with it. You're not at a loss as long as you take the time to re-do them until a good score is earned. On the other, in school, usually, your bad score sticks. That's it for you. Better luck next time or you might fail the entire year. Retrying in school takes an entire year of your life, you have to re-do even the things that you got right. It's quite punitive. That's without mentioning social aspects of it (peer view, self-esteem, etc). Also, there's a big difference between scores and game reward system. Game rewards (nowadays) are designed for addiction. Rewards begin plenty and often, then are made scarcer and occasional. Not any school system can beat that behavioral craving.
- gojomo 15y agoSee similar concerns expressed at: http://larryferlazzo.edublogs.org/2012/02/26/kathy-sierra-on-gamification-in-education/ http://larryferlazzo.edublogs.org/2012/02/26/kathy-sierra-on...
- doktrin 15y agoI agree. We should be very careful going too far down the pavlovian rabbit hole of immediate rewards. While people do need to be made aware of their progress, this shouldn't necessarily take the form of badges, awards or other superficial sources of recognition. These are ultimately hollow and meaningless measures of completion - nothing more. Where I think education - "gameified" as well as traditional - often tends to fall short, is in demonstrating the value of the skills learned. It's the classic problem of applicability. Algebra is boring until you recognize all the situations in which it applies - likewise for Calculus, derivatives, statistics, physics, etc. Likewise for the liberal arts. TLDR : We don't need to be trained like canines to seek education for the sake of virtual trinkets, but rather to become educated for the sake of doing.