5 ms·
They Want to Be Gatekeepers: Car Dealers Are Stopping Customers from Buying EVs
- redundantly 3y agoTo be fair, most cars salespeople don't know much about cars in general, including the ones they're selling. I've learned to take anything they say with a grain of salt.
- dumbo-octopus 3y agoSalespeople in general tend to not know much about what they're selling. Which is good in a way -- the idyllic psyco-product the salesperson is hawking will almost certainly be perceived as more valuable than the real thing. And any discrepancies can be handled by Engineering later on, after their commission check clears.
- joshu 3y agoIndeed. I remember getting into an argument with a salesperson who bet me an entire free car that I was wrong. IIRC it was something like the car MUST have DCT because it had paddle shifters, though they'd transitioned from DCT to a ZF8. They were wrong. Huge surprise, I never got the free car.
- 3seashells 3y agoAs long as they don't bait and switch. Minor accident damage (scratches) in the one you rest drive, major damage in "your" car they want you to drive of the lot in. Same model, switcheroo can happen easy, we are so sorry..
- rasz 3y agoThey know a lot about TruCoat https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B2LLB9CGfLs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B2LLB9CGfLs and financial engineering.
- Kirby64 3y agoAntiquated business model doesn’t want to get dragged kicking and screaming into the future? No surprise there. Seems like based on the article the salesmen don’t actually want to do any education or aid, and just want to make the sale. If that’s how they want to handle it, why do I need salespeople instead of just… an order kiosk or something?
- bruce511 3y agoThe old guard resisting the new wave. Is it not always this way? Especially for those who neither create the product, nor consume it, but profess to act as the middle-man, acting for the customer, reducing complexity but in truth getting revenue from the same customer, and ultimately working against, not for, their interest. Car dealers being slimy is something of a cliche, but that cliche is well earned. Of course change is scary for incumbents. Change leads to a disruption of the status quo, and opens the door to new players. Some will no doubt resist, others will embrace, invest, and grow. I'm sure it's easy to find dinosaur dealers. I suspect there are also progressives working to take their place.
- heresie-dabord 3y agoAnother aspect of the failure is the kind of vehicles that US automakers are building: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38249140 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38249140
- ryukoposting 3y agoObviously the ramcharger is asinine, but gas range extenders are a proven approach to "bridging the gap" in EV practicality.
- CaliforniaKarl 3y agoThat makes me think of residential HVAC companies and Heat Pumps: Folks like Technology Connections report that residential HVAC companies either don't want to sell heat-pump systems, or include a large markup, or include things that aren't needed (like an emergency gas furnace, or an overkill amount of electrical resistive emergency heating).
- huijzer 3y ago"it’s difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends on his not understanding it.” - Upton Sinclair
- droopyEyelids 3y agoI'd like to see some numbers about how much auto dealers make on service, and how much service EVs need compared to combustion engines. Off the top of my head, EVs only need regular maintenance for the air filters, tires, and wiper blades, maybe power steering fluid? ICE needs the same plus oil changes, belts, engine coolant, fuel filters, head gaskets, more brake fluid replacements, muffler/exhaust repair, oil filters, spark plugs, transmission fluid, water pumps, etc. Each one of those is a lost sales opportunity for EV purchases.
- eesmith 3y agoTires need regular maintenance, and wear out faster in heavier EVs. This also increases wear on the brakes. Cars need wheel alignments. Steering components need regular maintenance, as does the environmental system (A/C, heat, filter). In a Tesla (and probably other EVs), there's a coolant loop for the battery and power/control electronics. That can break and needs maintenance. Lights burn out and need replacing. An EV battery needs to be replaced, which is expensive. And do not let it get flooded, as a couple in Scotland recently found out. Hertz recently said that maintaining a Tesla costs more than an ICE.
- pinkgolem 3y ago> wear on the brakes Biggest complain about breaks in EVs I have read about is that they rust from non usage >Lights burn out and need replacing. With LEDs this is a non issue, even for gas cars for years. > EV battery needs to be replaced, which is expensive. We are talking 300k miles+ on somewhat modern batteries, 1 million miles+ for lfp most gas cars are long dead at this point And EVs are still usable, also you might need to charge them more often(yes some gas cars can go longer, but you often need a transmission rebuild + expensive repair in the motor) >Hertz recently said that maintaining a Tesla costs more than an ICE I would assume that's through the added collisions damages you have on rentals, but afaik there was no data published here
- rasz 3y agoProblem with LED lights is they are made as a big unrepairable blobs, and Car manufacturers love overcharging for bespoke parts https://www.carscoops.com/2022/10/gmc-hummers-taillights-will-cost-you-more-than-a-new-motorcycle/ https://www.carscoops.com/2022/10/gmc-hummers-taillights-wil...
- kumarvvr 3y agoThe transition to EV will hurt the dealerships in the long run. Not much you can swindle out from a customer if all that the car has is brake fluid, AC unit, a motor, a battery and chips. I also suspect that diagnostic systems or helpers will allow regular users to troubleshoot their car themselves, and become more immune to swindling by service centers. No wonder they dont want to sell EVs
- pengaru 3y agoIf Tesla door handles and Model X complexity in general are any indication, there'll be no shortage of stupid gimmicks needing regular maintenance/repair.
- Kirby64 3y agoObviously those have reliability issues (which, have mostly been fixed to my knowledge, as the design defect was fixed), but how is that any different from the myriad of issues of 'high complexity' gas powered cars? Everyone tells you to avoid older Mercedes S-class cars, precisely because there's so much random crap that can break. Seems like most EVs trend away from those gimmicks, though. It's mostly on touchscreens, which don't really have meaningful failure mechanisms, unlike all the mechanical contrivances in say, an S-class.
- ianai 3y agoYou still need to rotate tires pretty often. You have a point, but the world has to move on from oil.
- tomalbrc 3y agoSeeing how bad EVs actually are for consumers it's no surprise. Heck, I would buy a dinosaur burning car if i had to choose today
- ryukoposting 3y agoI drive a 23 year old car, and the only thing I've had to replace that I wouldn't have to replace on an EV is a timing belt. EVs are heavy. Their weight eats through tires, and reduces the service life (or increases cost) of suspension components. The battery in my mother's Chevy Volt is doing fine at 10 years and 100k+ miles, but there's no telling what condition it will be in at year 15 or 20 - both reasonable benchmarks for durability that no mainstream EV has reached yet.
- KevinMS 3y agoTruth is that EVs are a bad option for a lot of people. They might be simply providing good advice.
- gaganyaan 3y agoWhy do you think they're a bad option?
- KevinMS 3y agothere are millions of americans that live in apartments, condos or row houses, some have parking lots, some park on the streets but there is no place to plug in. Not only that, there are lots of people that go on short trips, like for a weekend, and they really dont want to plan around chargers. EVs really are only a good idea if you can plug in at home and just use your car for commuting and shopping.
- johnny99k 3y agoUnless it's a hybrid, EVs just aren't that practical yet. You can't travel that far on one charge, it can take over an hour, even on a quick charge, and the infrastructure is lacking. If you have a family with small kids, it's an impossibility. I also have to laugh because the UAW is against EVs (this has been stated many times by the president). The cars require less people to build them.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoI did a 3000 km trip with kids four times in an EV during the pandemic. Not only was it possible, it was very pleasant. With kids, bathroom breaks and snack breaks consume more time than charging does.
- gaganyaan 3y agoThe range is great, charging is not an issue, and they work great with small kids. Have you actually tried one, or just sneered at them from a distance?
- RetroTechie 3y agoLonger article from The Washington Post: https://www.washingtonpost.com/climate-solutions/2023/11/09/car-dealerships-ev-sales/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/climate-solutions/2023/11/09/... I loved this passage: Initially, Richards was hoping to buy an F-150 Lightning, but the truck was back-ordered. The salesperson could only get him an expensive trim that came with a high dealer markup. That markup added “insult to injury,” Richards said. He ended up buying a Tesla Model Y. Yes: treat customers like morons, and they will spend their $ elsewhere. Keep it up, and that will only speed the demise of EV-hater car dealerships.
- freefaler 3y agoThe premise of "gatekeepers" is strange. They try to sell what they have available, understand and know their margins on the sale and long-term on services. If they could get more money selling EVs they'd do that, but any car dealership with money blocked in inventory would try to sell this first. This don't look like an "anti EV evil trust", just basic market forces at work.
- thrill 3y agoUse a car buying service. Car dealerships are mental self abuse.