3 ms·
> If the majority of the country feels this way, why should you push your Western Values on them. While social permissiveness is distinctly a phenomenon of the
by rayiner 3y ago
> If the majority of the country feels this way, why should you push your Western Values on them.
While social permissiveness is distinctly a phenomenon of the west, I wouldn’t characterize “western values” by that single phase. For most of the history of the American Republic, it was taken for granted the government could regulate morality as an aspect of the public welfare. Regulation of businesses believed to be morally harmful, such as strip clubs and pornographic magazines, was deemed within the scope of government power into the mid-20th century, until anti-democratic Supreme Court decisions interpreted constitutional provisions in ways that would have shocked the people who wrote them.
- kube-system 3y agoI took the parent to be referring to contemporary western values.
- lo_zamoyski 3y agoIndeed, as the classical and Christian notions of freedom, as opposed to the liberal variety, entails self-discipline, self-denial, and the restraint, disciplining, and purification of the appetites through things like fasting and abstinence.
- all2 3y agoAnd Justice. True justice is missing from the West.
- dukeofdoom 3y agoKind of ... Would a native Hawaiian, consider themselves free, that they live under Western Laws. They have western freedoms, and democracy, and all the shiny trinkets. But now also lack autonomy, and the real control over their native land. Democracy is kind of useless to a Native Hawaiian, when they'll be outvoted by outsiders every time. I think plenty of them would just want their land back. And Westerners can shove it. I think "contemporary western values" is just a feel good saying, a pretty wrapper, on economic expansionist policy ... globalism. And there are plenty of taboo topics in the West too, and it's enforced as well. Celebrities have handlers, FBI goes around planting informants and extorting dissenters for political gain. People get canceled, fired from jobs for saying dissenting opinions. And its done in the name of "social harmony" and greater good here as well.
- kube-system 3y ago"Contemporary western values" is not a statement that means everyone in the west has the same values, nor it is an endorsement. It is referring to the generally predominant mainstream consensus.
- throwaway2037 3y ago"Contemporary western values" I agree. This is a virtually meaningless term. Just look at New York State or Washington State (in US). The largest city (NYC and Seattle) are extremely liberal. However, the country side is much more conservative. Do they share the same "contemporary western values"? Hmmm...
- jowea 3y agoI do believe what they do share is "contemporary Western values". I think both sides would agree with at least some form of the rule of law, freedom of religion, gender equality and support for liberal democracy. Don't you think they would look at most any form of governance pre-1850 and agree it's bad?
- kube-system 3y agoDon't confuse 'broad' with 'meaningless'.
- piuantiderp 3y agoDon't confuse Western with US. And yes, for all the protestations to the contrary, they are pretty much made out of the same...
- clarionbell 3y agoI suppose they could console themselves with knowledge that it was never their land. The monarch of the island, and later islands, or local chief had control over it. The very concept of people, or citizens, controlling their land is a concept that was imported.
- jen20 3y agoRegulation of liquor stores for religious puritanical reasons is still a thing today.
- kube-system 3y agoI'd argue only some alcohol control laws exist for religious reasons. Some of those old puritanical laws are still on the books, but stick around today because they are useful for regulatory capture.
- jen20 3y agoI think in this case (liquor stores being closed exclusively on Sunday morning in Texas), you'd need extraordinary evidence to assume that it's not because of the facade of puritanical ideals. Perhaps that's not the case in Northern New Jersey (which, crazily, also has similar rules) though.
- kube-system 3y agoI was thinking along the lines of alcohol control laws which limit licensing, distribution, sales, etc. Those groups with preferential treatment have become special interest groups in many places that want to perpetuate those limits because it prevents competitors. Somewhere around a quarter of states have mandated some form of monopoly in regards to alcohol, and others have limited licensing schemes that are highly politicized.
- piuantiderp 3y agoIt's still happening through the credit card companies and such... What do you think cancel culture is about?
- throwaway2037 3y agoWhile social permissiveness is distinctly a phenomenon of the west How about Japan or Taiwan? Reminder: Taiwan legalised gay marriage in 2019! I don't like to use the term "Western" too much. It's more clear to say "modern". Example: Japan is not at all Westernized, nor Taiwan, nor South Korea, but they are definitely modern. -- Edit -- As a counterpoint, I would say that India (in my limited experience on-the-ground) is way more social conservative than Sri Lanka. I was genuinely surprised by the social permissiveness in Sri Lanka. It was a world apart from India. Thus, I would say Sri Lanka is on-the-cusp of being considered modern (in my eyes).
- stann 3y agoA cynic would see Japan, Taiwan, and South Korea as vassal states of the US and as such "Western".
- jowea 3y agoI think we're talking about culturally Western here, not geopolitically Western. I can't see even a (sane) cynic call these 3 countries culturally Western unless you think being a liberal democracy automatically makes you culturally Western. And Japan is one of the countries said to have "Westernized"!
- rayiner 3y agoThese countries aren’t fully westernized, but it’s impossible to deny they’ve been heavily influenced by the west. For example, traditional diets are being replaced by unhealthy western diets: https://www.seattlepi.com/lifestyle/health/article/Pacific-Currents-Rising-rate-of-obesity-causes-1103751.php https://www.seattlepi.com/lifestyle/health/article/Pacific-C.... Or in another example, Japanese people are increasingly giving “unique” names to children: https://www.tus.ac.jp/en/mediarelations/archive/20220913_8238.html https://www.tus.ac.jp/en/mediarelations/archive/20220913_823...
- trimethylpurine 3y ago>Japan is not at all Westernized, nor Taiwan, nor South Korea, but they are definitely modern. Free speech and democracy are Western ideals. I think most people would say that these countries are absolutely westernized. China, and much of the Arab world, is modern, and largely at odds with Western values. Maybe these are better examples for your comment.